3 ms·
The story doesn't exist to discuss the right approach to curing death, or the most efficient and expedient way to get there, or the current techniques in the fi
by JoshTriplett 9y ago
The story doesn't exist to discuss the right approach to curing death, or the most efficient and expedient way to get there, or the current techniques in the field.
The story exists to help get people to the baseline point of acknowledging that death is bad, because even that much can be shockingly non-universal. If we could get to a point where a large fraction of people genuinely believed that, then the rest of the problem becomes far easier.
If the primary problem was simply "how do we solve this", that'd be hard enough.
- pzone 9y agoThe fact that developed nations spend 10% of GDP on healthcare belies this. (That fraction is significantly higher in the US.) The potential market for viable treatments to extend human lifespan is in the trillions. Maybe some individuals don't care about death because they are carefree people, but society as a whole seems convinced it's something to fight. It's a revealed preference, from how much money we spend to stay healthy. Let's put it another way: do you think pharmaceutical companies and academics aren't trying hard enough to attack this multidimensional problem? Who seems to be lacking urgency?
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> The fact that developed nations spend 10% of GDP on healthcare belies this. In the parable, this would be mostly equivalent to people who find themselves on the list of next dragon transport spending money on getting themselves pushed to a list in the future. Everyone expects to be eaten by the dragon, but if there's money, you can be eaten later and not just now. Most of that money is then burned somehow, and very little of it finds its way to anti-dragon research. This seems to reflect the views of a lot of people on on aging and death itself. "Death is good and natural, and I'll eventually die too, but I'd prefer to die later". > Let's put it another way: do you think pharmaceutical companies and academics aren't trying hard enough to attack this multidimensional problem? Who seems to be lacking urgency? Do you think this is how urgency looks? It isn't. Urgency looks like Apollo Program. Or every single Olympics. Lost of people working directly on a particular goal, with lots of money flowing in. As it is, there seems to be only few people working on aging/life extension directly. Urgency would be when, besides that 10% GDP spent on healthcare, you'd spend a few percent more directly on life extension.
- mikeash 9y agoWhat is health care if not life extension?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoLife preservation against non-aging-related causes, reduction of suffering, improving quality of life. As it is, healthcare isn't really directly concerned with extending human lifespan beyond the expected figures.
- mikeash 9y agoA huge amount of health care is preserving life in the face of aging. There are a ton of diseases that come from aging, and many treatments for them. This whole thing seems to be about drawing a nonsensical line between “disease” and “aging” and either ignoring the former as a cause of death, or deciding that it has enough effort behind it already. If someone has a cancer that’s going to kill them in six months, and it’s cured with a medical treatment, how is that not extending their lifespan? What would lifespan extension look like, if not a slow, broad development of myriad treatments to treat or cure the many things which kill us?
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> This seems to reflect the views of a lot of people on on aging and death itself. "Death is good and natural, and I'll eventually die too, but I'd prefer to die later". Why do you say this? I have never met anyone who thought that "death is good and natural". I've heard many people say that it is inevitable and it is futile to try and avoid it, but "good and natural"? There is no such thing as a natural death. Nothing that happens to Man is ever natural, since his presence calls the whole world into question. All men must die, but for every man his death is an accident. And even if he knows it and consents to it, an unjustifiable violation. Simone de Beauvoir after Tolkien: http://confusedneurons.tumblr.com/post/80683906667/all-men-must-die-but-for-every-man-his-death-is http://confusedneurons.tumblr.com/post/80683906667/all-men-m...
- 9y ago
- verylittlemeat 9y agoBecause nothing helps solve an intractable problem better than poorly defined outrage right? "Hey I'm really mad that I'm gonna die! Someone do something about this!" Wow you mean this whole time you didn't want to die. What an absolutely shocking revelation. That changes everything.