3 ms·
I rather suspect that if we consider "the ability for most of the population to correctly and reliably perform mental math using the tokens provided" that while
by jerf 16y ago
I rather suspect that if we consider "the ability for most of the population to correctly and reliably perform mental math using the tokens provided" that while our current system still doesn't win it has a much better showing. And yes, I'm willing to ignore the fact that people are already familiar with the current system, but I can't come up with a much better one off the top of my head.
By that metric, 37-cent pieces are just about the worst coinage possible, 11-cent pieces are a joke, and even 15-cent pieces which don't evenly add up to a dollar are a suboptimal.
Even by economist standards, ignoring this aspect of the system is rather a disappointment.
- jjcm 16y agoPerhaps a good measure of whether or not the general populous can perform mental math based on the value of the coins is to check and see whether or not a single dollar is divisible by the value of the coins (as you hinted with the 15 cent coin). It allows for many mental paths to arrive at the correct answer for what amount of coins are needed to make a certain sum. Take the nickel for example, to make 50 cents you might think to yourself, "I just need to divide 50 by 5, which is obviously 10." Alternately one might think, "I know there are 20 nickels in a dollar, if I halve this I'll have half a dollar, which is 50 cents. That means I need 10 nickels." I'd say that the pool of coin values we can choose from then are 50, 25, 20, 10, 5, 2, 1. The two cent piece is already in use in Europe, and many economists have suggested adding it to the coinage in the united states (usually in replacement for the penny altogether). It'd be interesting to see if the 20 cent coin would be a viable addition though.
- daychilde 16y agoI very much agree that's the practical pool of possible coin values. Seems to me if one wanted to simplify the system, a good solution would be (1, 5, 10, 50). This would really make the math simple. But I don't think people would give up quarters happily; nor do I think fifty cent pieces would go over well; and I think it's high time to lose pennies. So if I was the evil overlord in charge, I think I'd just drop to (5, 25). Cash transactions would round to the nearest nickel instead of penny. Getting back four nickels instead of two dimes would be gotten used to quickly, I think.