9 ms·
Are you really Facebook’s product? The history of a dangerous idea
- sid-kap 9y agoI'm surprised the article doesn't mention Richard Stallman's essays on Facebook. That's the first place I saw this idea expressed. (He calls users of Facebook "useds".)
- throwajay-rms 9y agooften i have longed for a way to convince stallman that the smug pseudo-clever tone evinced by his word games pushes away more people than it attracts. alas
- marnett 9y agowords directly affect thought. while some substitutions can be overkill, it can still help the reader better perceive the precise thought the writer wants. this idea is at the core of books like 1984, for example.
- stochastic_monk 9y agoI like Stallman’s emphasis. Considering how resistant people tend to be to the idea of not using Facebook, underscoring that they’re being sold is an important point. And not for the purposed of exerting control like 1984’s.
- flycaliguy 9y agoI feel like that guy has a public attraction ceiling. He's better doing himself.
- Zarath 9y agoIf you believe that the major danger of Facebook is that it allows people to easily be manipulated, then sugar coating your true meaning to be more appealing may just be counter to your purpose.
- hamburga 9y agohttps://stallman.org/facebook.html https://stallman.org/facebook.html
- na85 9y agoStallman's juvenile demeanor detracts from the perception of his message. Calling rap music "c...rap", calling them useds instead of users, the gravmass stuff, writing diatribes about not wearing ties, not to mention eating his toe jam on camera that one time... He's a kook and will never be taken seriously. Like it or not we are superficial beings and culture carries with it certain norms that must be adhered to if we wish to maintain broad spectrum appeal or credibility. It's not enough to have good ideas.
- Wingwing 9y agoIt sounds like you are the problem here to be honest.
- vinceguidry 9y agoI think RMS would disagree with you. He considers his cause to have been successful beyond his wildest dreams. Reading his biography paints a stark picture of a tech landscape being increasingly dominated by corporate interests. His organization offered another way. He never thought it would get off the ground, but it turned out that corporations are desperate to save a buck and are more than willing to work with free software in order to do it. The GPL was the first keystone, his advocacy helped to popularize it. His choice of appealing to nerds like him was perfect, and his kook persona where he doesn't bother trying to button up his rougher edges is far more convincing than any amount of sanitizing ever would be. More to the point, Stallman is insanely smart, and is more accomplished than probably anybody posting on HN, including even pg. He didn't stop being smart just because he became notable.
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoSpot on. Often being unconventional is more effective than being likable.
- zeveb 9y agoYou're not wrong, but neither is rms. The little boy pointing out that the emperor's new clothes are non-existent is no less right for breaking social mores, but is rather less likely to actually be paid attention to.
- sharemywin 9y agoI thought that saying was pre-facebook
- the_af 9y agoI first heard it about TV, which is what TFA mentions :)
- sharemywin 9y agoummmm....HN is free. I'm just saying...
- chrischen 9y agoHN is mostly non-profit (it does drive attention and reputation to Y Combinator though).
- diasp 9y agoAds? 3rd-party tracking?
- icebraining 9y agoThere are ads (links to job postings of YC companies). They appear like regular submissions, but you can't vote or comment on them.
- dredmorbius 9y agoIt's selling start-up founder visibility, as well as pulse-checking both the community and those who'd seeek to influence it. A recruiting bonus as well "who's hiring", and HN startup pitches.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sharemywin 9y agoThe news is a little hypercritical with it being free and all.
- matte_black 9y agoFacebook’s product has always been highly targeted ad placement. Users are in no way the product, and for people to keep saying that is grossly misrepresenting the business model and puts all sorts of weird ideas into people’s heads. Unless you are being bought and sold you are not a product. There are people in this world who ARE products, and we should be doing everything we can to liberate them.
- losteric 9y agoFacebook sells access to you, through their highly targeted advertising platform. Ads consume your mental focus, bandwidth, battery power, and screen real-estate. You are a product, in the same way that celebrities are products.
- matte_black 9y agoSo not at all then. You don’t buy celebrities you buy their output. A billboard by a highway doesn’t mean that traffic is now the product. You’re selling placement.
- icebraining 9y agoThe placement is only worth anything because of the traffic. Your distinction is not false, but is it relevant in practice?
- badrabbit 9y agoIf someone sold my body in part or whole then they are selling me. For most people,their intimate private lives and the essence of who they are is just as important as their body. So, if facebook collectes such intimate detail about a person and not only made it known to third parties but used that information to manipulate the person,then I would it is that person who is being traded. Who can I claim to be without my private life,secret thoughts,desires and my identity itself? Even 19th century american slaves had some private life and kept information about themselves secret from the slave masters (of course I am not comparing their hardship,but the small privacy they had) and they were literally sold at markets. The grand trick of the modern economy is that they have consumer behavioral psychology figured out: convince them they made the choice all on their own and take away as much of their intangible freedoms and possesions as you can -- "if you can't touch it, it isn't real"
- onewhonknocks 9y agoAccess to users is the product, not the users themselves IMHO.
- icebraining 9y agoWhat's the difference in practice?
- themacguffinman 9y agoThe difference in practice is mostly in security: neither advertisers or publishers on Google or Facebook actually possess your data, so it can't be leaked by breaching any of those companies. You'd have to breach Google or Facebook themselves.
- lotu 9y agoIt also means advertisers can’t miss appropriate your data (this could be part of the security thing). So I can’t say I want to know what themaguffinman’s been searching and google will send me a list of his searches for $50. When people say selling your data that’s the image I get even though it is compleatlly in accurate.
- Lionsion 9y ago> “Television delivers people” was not about data privacy. It was about the medium’s impact on culture and politics. Serra and Schoolman’s critique was that TV placed the interests of advertisers over those of viewers in a subtle but deeply insidious way: by purveying content and ads that perpetuated the consumerist status quo, deadening free thinking and dampening activism. The big networks would never produce a show that threatened the interests of corporate America, they reckoned, because it was corporate America that they ultimately served. That's true, but the "critique ... that TV placed the interests of advertisers over those of viewers" easily extends to questions about data privacy. > What people seem to mean when they say that you’re Facebook’s product is that Facebook treats you like a product—that it fails to respect your individualism, your humanity, or your long-term interests. And the implication is that this disrespect flows inevitably from the fact that you aren’t paying for Facebook’s service. When I use it, I also mean that Facebook's incentives aren't to cater to me, but rather to itself and to a lesser extent, its advertiser-customers from which it gets its revenue. I, as a non-paying user, have little leverage to demand consideration. It loses no revenue if I leave. > That helps to explain why Google and Facebook really don’t think of their users as their products—at least, not their main products. Their leaders have always regarded advertising, and by extension users’ attention and data, as means to the end of building the products they really care about: Google search, Google Assistant, Facebook’s news feed. I don't buy it. Google kills products that it has trouble monetizing. They aren't labors of love, begrudgingly subsidized by advertising. Scandals like Facebook's are finally exposing this excessively optimistic line of thinking as the lie that it is. Tech companies aren't some special kind of company, they're companies just like Ford, Goldman Sachs, Philip Morris, Boeing, etc. > But it’s 2018, and it’s time for Facebook’s critics to move past what has become a tired cliché. There’s something nihilistic about telling people they’re the product of a gigantic corporation and there’s nothing they can do about it. “You are the product” paints us as powerless pawns in Facebook’s game but gives us no leverage with which to improve our predicament. This is BS. There's plenty they can do: they can disengage, they can find alternative services better suited to them, etc. It's only nihilistic if you think you have no choice except to use Facebook and play its game. > There are at least two alternative ways of viewing our relationship to Facebook that hold more promise for making that relationship a healthier and less exploitive one. The first is to view ourselves as customers of Facebook, paying with our time, attention, and data instead of with money....The second is to view ourselves as part of Facebook’s labor force. Just as bees labor unwittingly on beekeepers’ behalf, our posts and status updates continually enrich Facebook. But we’re humans, not bees, and as such we have the capacity to collectively demand better treatment. Aaaand it's confirmed: the author thinks we have no choice except to use Facebook and play its game, so we should try recontextualize our situation to motivate us to beg for better treatment.
- intrasight 9y agoIf I'm the product then I'm a lousy one for anyone buying it - since I have FB filtered down to just show friends posts.
- david_shaw 9y agoYou probably still view ads on the Facebook platform, though, right? You may not contribute much to Facebook's analytics platform, but you're still making them money when they display ads.
- rogerbinns 9y agoI disagree. Facebook makes their money from advertisers. The advertisers go where people are, but they are also careful about paying. For example if their product is only applicable to one gender, but the ads would go to everyone then they'd want to pay half as much. Sites that do not have demographic information about their users consequently can't charge anywhere near as much as Facebook which gets advertisers to pay more for the demographics they want. Even if everything in your FB profile is a lie, your friends then provide the demographic information about you. eg you are going to similar to them. And because you are on Facebook, you are now available to the advertisers.
- craigsmansion 9y agoStill, you get tracked on your interests online. Those get cross-checked with those of your friends, their friends, your age-group, the area you live in, your other hobbies, etc. providing useful information. Being in their web has value for them, even if you consciously try to avoid being of value. Making users think they got the better of them is part of the business model. The only way to win is not to play.
- jcbrand 9y agoYou still contribute to the network effect and to legitimizing FB as a good way to keep in touch.
- matchagaucho 9y agoThe Television "Nielsen Family" model has evolved from opt-in and we'll pay you to Default opt-in. No compensation. In all fairness, there is zero setup and overhead to use Internet services, whereas Neilsen families had to fill out daily usage logs and install special TV interfaces.
- rogerbinns 9y agoTwice in the last decade Nielsen has paper mailed me wanting to collect TV viewing information over a future week. They even included a $5 bill in the mailing with promise of more at the end. I was rather excited since finally Futurama and Stargate could have some support. But when it became time to fill out the logbook I couldn't actually do it. I finally figured out they couldn't care less what TV I watched, and were actually trying to work out what ads I had watched that had aired at most in the previous 24 hours. Kinda difficult information to provide when using DVDs, Netflix, and having cut the cord many years before. There was nowhere to even say that you watched stuff on Netflix. You could only supply channel names and times! (They also never bothered to check their help email worked, which it didn't. They apologised several weeks later.)
- tacon 9y agoSometime in early 2000, I decided I was watching too much television, so I just stopped, completely. I was actively avoiding watching any television. I was a few months into that when I got my one and only invitation to be a Nielsen person. I told them in advance that I gave up watching television a few months before, and I didn't plan on watching anything in the near future. They said sure, that was fine. So I got a log book and, of course, at the end of each month or whatever, I wrote 0,0,0... everywhere. After six months, I was not renewed as a Nielsen person. :-) I did watch election night 2000 and the whole hanging chad period, and eventually I was watching some again.
- jasode 9y agoI suspect that if Will Oremus wrote a shorter version of that post on reddit or HN, he'd get downvoted to oblivion. The meme of "if you're not paying for it, you're the customer not the product" has become a moral chorus. I'm ok with repeating that meme as a defensive mental checkpoint. Say it to remind oneself to limit data as much as possible to prevent its monetization for Facebook's advantage. However, I also understand the author's point that it's a thought-stopping soundbite that miseducates people on the economics of multi-sided platforms. The "you're the product" labels us as sheeple. Unfortunately, we don't seem to have another neutral word to describe audiences as quasi-non-paying-customers. Another example other than Facebook might be jazz festivals in the USA. A lot of jazz festivals organized by cities have free attendance. If the attendees don't pay, how do they pay the musicians? The cities rent space to vendors in the park to sell food and drinks. It's so critical that they sell enough food & drinks to break even (or make a small profit) that they make rules preventing attendees from bringing in their own food.[1] It's a multi-sided economy: (1) the attendees, (2) the musicians, (3) the vendors, and (4) the city The interesting point is that when I was growing up and attending these free festivals every year, nobody said, "you know at the Jazz Festival, you're not the customer, you're the product." There was no derogatory meme like that for those shows. (Even if there was, most of us would still go because we want to go see Herbie Hancock play piano.) There is a similarity between jazz festival attendees and Facebook users ... the consumers of free services in a multi-sided exchange ... but we don't seem to have a non-derogatory label for it. [1] http://www.nejazzwinefest.org/festival-dos-and-donts.html http://www.nejazzwinefest.org/festival-dos-and-donts.html
- willoremus 9y agoThis is a good analogy. Near the bottom of my piece I propose, "If you're not paying for it with money, you're paying for it in some other way." Admittedly that's fairly clunky. In a critique of my piece on Twitter, NY Magazine's Max Read suggests, more succinctly: "There's no such thing as a free lunch" https://twitter.com/max_read/status/989893433639755776 https://twitter.com/max_read/status/989893433639755776 That bit of folk wisdom isn't going to wow anybody in a TED Talk, but I think it's more apt than "you're the product."
- 9y ago
- vinceguidry 9y agoI can't think of a more illustrative example than the fact that some magazine companies will keep on sending you magazines even after you cancel and stop paying them, on purpose, so they can still list you as a subscriber. You're worth more as an advertising target than you are as a customer. I'd be willing to bet that their own advertising departments are more interested in increasing the advertising value of the subscribers that do respond than it is in actually selling subscriptions.
- EADGBE 9y agoThere’s truth in this when many publications will offer an entire year’s worth of print for $5-$10.
- fullshark 9y agoA lot of words here to basically say “yeah it’s true but it’s not original and is kind of mean.”
- acd 9y agoBy analyzing what you like Facebook knows almost everything about your taste, all locations that you ever visit. Further Facebook profits on your most valuable asset in life your family and friends. Personally I find Facebook disgusting especially after Cambridge Analytics and that funded by a hedge fund owner and white first on the board of directors and you can now buy an election.
- Sideloader 9y agoConvoluted piece that uses a lot of words to say very little and ends up being (yet another) defense of “social” media and its billionaire owners. It matters little if Facebook users, their attention-span or their data trail and the content they churn out are the “product”....Facebook’s business model (data, data and more data) requires the company to maximize the time users spend browsing, reading and clicking through its network. As we have seen, the company has no problem with using people’s psychology against them to achieve this. And the company’s devious and underhanded tricks (like its data mining “security app”) designed to Hoover up as much information as possible are legendary. Multiple studies show “social” media use is detrimental to people’s psychological wellbeing and these companies not only own the channels billions use to communicate daily, they own the CONTENT of those communications. With FB and Google/Alphabet cozying up to the DoS, DoD and intelligence services...and deploying algorithms to limit “fake news” (i.e. any and all information that challenges the status quo) these companies have way too much power. They are a menace to our societies and need to be busted up and regulated.
- yodsanklai 9y ago> the company has no problem with using people’s psychology against them to achieve this I'm playing devil's advocate, but the same could be said of most companies. It's the basis of marketing. Using people's psychology to sell them products or ads, which most of the time aren't really good (or even harmful, like sodas, tobacco, junk food) for them.
- ThomPete 9y agoThis is just not correct and at best a very simplistic view of reality. Instagram which uses no smart algorithms to speak of is the social network that is responsible for most depressions not FB. You need to be able to answer why that is before you can start making FB responsible for things that they aren't really. The real danger is our own vanity not clever algorithms from FB. https://www.forbes.com/forbes/welcome/?toURL=https://www.forbes.com/sites/amitchowdhry/2017/05/31/instagram-depression/ https://www.forbes.com/forbes/welcome/?toURL=https://www.for...
- 9y ago
- textmode 9y agoWill non-desperate FB employees continue to want to work for a company with a poor reputation amongst the press?[1] Will internet users outside of HN begin to reflect on what Facebook is doing behind the scenes? Will they care? An executive from a large data broker was recently quoted as saying users care more about "relevance" than they do about "privacy". Is this true? How would we ascertain what users care about? Would we ask them? Is Facebook's internet.org the modern equivalent of "free AOL CDs" for the underdeveloped world?[2] Is it true that 91% of Facebook's revenue comes from mobile apps and only 9% is from laptop/desktop?[3] Does this explain why Brian Acton advised users to "delete" Facebook, i.e. delete the mobile app? For example, when users non-interactively export data, e.g. photos, using mbasic.facebook.com via laptop/desktop each evening while they are sleeping, then upload the data to their mobile device and view the data outside of any Facebook-controlled app, free from any advertising or tracking, including while offline. Does this contribute to Facebook revenue? 1. See, e.g., The stupefying pointlessness of Facebook's political theatre http://www.wired.co.uk/article/facebook-cambridge-analytica-dcms-evidence-parliament http://www.wired.co.uk/article/facebook-cambridge-analytica-... Breaking up with Facebook: Users confess they're spending less time https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2018/02/13/breaking-up-facebook-users-confess-theyre-spending-less-time/319672002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/news/2018/02/13/breaking... They think it's over: Zuckerberg's former mentor says Facebook will get away with everything https://qz.com/1263785/they-think-its-over-zuckerbergs-former-mentor-says-facebook-will-get-away-with-everything/ https://qz.com/1263785/they-think-its-over-zuckerbergs-forme... Facebook Finds It Harder to Get More People to Log On https://www.bloomberg.com/gadfly/articles/2018-04-25/facebook-earnings-growth-in-daily-users-slips-as-revenue-gains https://www.bloomberg.com/gadfly/articles/2018-04-25/faceboo... 'Facebook is a morality-free zone': tech chief lambasted by MP https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/apr/26/facebook-morality-free-zone-executive-mps-cambridge-analytica https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/apr/26/facebook-mo... Facebook warns investors that more Cambridge Analyticas are likely https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/26/facebook-warns-investors-that-more-cambridge-analyticas-are-likely.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/26/facebook-warns-investors-tha... Facebook's Zuckerberg faces formal summons from MPs http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-43906956 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-43906956 Top programmers will leave Facebook and Google if they gain 'evil' reputations https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/04/27/top-programmers-will-leave-facebook-google-gain-evil-reputations/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/04/27/top-programmers-... Facebook Launches a New Ad Campaign With an Old Message https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-launches-a-new-ad-campaign-with-an-old-message/ https://www.wired.com/story/facebook-launches-a-new-ad-campa... Facebook: Crisis? What crisis? Look at our revenue, it's fantastic https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/04/26/facebook_results/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/04/26/facebook_results/ Brit MPs brand Facebook a 'great vampire squid' out for cash https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/04/27/facebook_schroepfer_evidence_dcms_data/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/04/27/facebook_schroepfer... Facebook CTO says sorry journalists feel firm is trying to suppress the truth https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-privacy-britain-sorry/facebook-cto-says-sorry-journalists-feel-firm-is-trying-to-suppress-the-truth-idUSKBN1HX1N3 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-facebook-privacy-britain-... 2. See, e.g., Facebook's Internet.org has connected almost 100M to the 'internet' https://techcrunch.com/2018/04/25/internet-org-100-million/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/04/25/internet-org-100-million/ 100 Million People Are Connected to Facebook's Walled-Garden Internet https://gizmodo.com/100-million-people-are-connected-to-facebooks-walled-ga-1825553262 https://gizmodo.com/100-million-people-are-connected-to-face... 3. Mobile advertising represents 91% of Facebook's ad revenue http://www.marketing-interactive.com/mobile-advertising-represents-91-of-facebooks-mobile-ad-revenue/ http://www.marketing-interactive.com/mobile-advertising-repr...
- ianamartin 9y agoDoes anyone know any investors I can pitch to? I'm actually serious about a social media platform that pays users to use it. It's a totally shameless clone of facebook. We'll collect user data, monetize it, track people, everything. The whole 9 yards. The only difference is that we'll take the profit and share it with users after we take a fair share for ourselves. Users will love it because they get paid for it. Advertisers will love it because the users will have extra cash to buy shit with. Everybody wins.
- cocoa19 9y ago"You know, Facebook's free. If something’s free, that means you’re the product." Even when a product is not free, you are still the product. I'm pretty sure Walmart is selling my purchase information to advertisers.
- ThomPete 9y agoOnly if you is part of their loyalty program.
- jessaustin 9y ago...or if you shop with a credit or debit card, or if you typically carry the same mobile phone with you most times you shop, or if you often purchase prescription medicine there, or if they ever get that facial-recognition cluster to work... this can be based on any somewhat durable identifier.
- ThomPete 9y agoBut they aren't selling it to the best of my knowledge.
- jessaustin 9y agoWhy not? It isn't because they don't like money. If they aren't selling such data (which is not clearly the case) it's because they judge that they can put it to more valuable use themselves.
- ThomPete 9y agoI don't think they are allowed to sell it. They are however allowed to use it.
- jessaustin 9y agoBut they are allowed to sell data based on loyalty programs? That would be a weird regulation.
- squozzer 9y agoI have begun wondering aloud about whether the social media era is our closest approach as a species to telepathy. And while hardly a (modern) sci-fi maven, I never encountered any works that tried to step through how a species would achieve telepathy. The stories I read that had telepathic species glossed over their transformation, usually with some variant on the phrase, "It wasn't pretty."
- hprotagonist 9y agoThe most famous quote about Facebook isn’t actually about Facebook—it’s about television. Worth rereading David Foster Wallace's "E Unibas Pluram" (1993), which is largely about our codependent relationship with TV and how it will inevitably metamorphose into a similar relationship with other forms of media: https://jsomers.net/DFW_TV.pdf https://jsomers.net/DFW_TV.pdf
- a-dub 9y agoIt took a generation, but I think that a big chunk of society learned to be wary of big media's outsized influence enabled by television. Most people I knew as a young adult had basically completely eschewed television with decent notions of its effects and annoyances. The internet, on the other hand was something new. Fresh, unfiltered and unmanipulated... Until recently, now it's just the same shit but exponentially more insidious. Where's Sidney Lumet when we need him? "I want you to go to your keyboards, throw open your windows and get MAD. I want you to scream goddamnit, I'M MAD AS HELL AND I'M NOT GOING TO TAKE THIS ANYMORE!"
- adultSwim 9y agoYes.
- mclide 9y agoThe concern of users becoming the product when using an ad-based business model was discussed in a 1995 paper presented at the Third International World-Wide Web conference: "The design of a medium strongly affects the revenue model that is applied to that medium. Entrepreneurs will seek an appropriate way of creating a revenue constrained and encouraged by the media technology. One example of this relationship can be discovered through examining the different variations of the television medium. The traditional technology of broadcast made it difficult for content creators to charge individual viewers for selecting a program. This lead to revenue sought via advertising, based on making the viewers the product rather than the customers, and resulted in bland programming in an attempt to get as large an audience as possible to sell to advertisers. The technology of cable television and scrambling made it easier to charge for subscription or pay-per-view, causing more directed programming towards smaller audiences. [...] The revenue model has implications for what content will be made available on a medium as well as the quality of that content. Web technology designers can strongly impact which revenue models will be used on the web. Creating alternative revenue models is important to avoid the application of potentially harmful revenue models due to a lack of alternatives." https://doi.org/10.1016/0169-7552(95)00039-A https://doi.org/10.1016/0169-7552(95)00039-A