6 ms·
Actually, the search for "the most efficient coin system" is kinda pointless -- if you are as advanced to discover and implement such a system, you are certainl
by BerislavLopac 16y ago
Actually, the search for "the most efficient coin system" is kinda pointless -- if you are as advanced to discover and implement such a system, you are certainly advanced enough to implement and use a cashless system based on digital payment transactions...
- gregpilling 16y agoThe cash system will be hard to get rid of in the US. Many people want to be able to hold their real money, not just have it on a bank statement. With these same people - for fun - have a few drinks with them and try to explain to them that the dollar bill they are holding is also not 'real' in the sense that it is only a piece of paper and has no intrinsic value of its own.
- xyzzyz 16y agoCash is also useful for anonymous transactions. The anonymous cashless protocols are very complicated compared to cash, and I don't even know if anyone implements them at all.
- rdl 16y agoThe irony here is that anonymous digital cash protocols, while complicated, are also basically built around digital tokens or "coins", so efficient change-making is still relevant! (although the coins would be handled by software, so 11 or 37 unit coins would be acceptable; generally systems have used coins in the powers of two sizes, to reduce number of coins per transaction, at the expense of total number of denominations).
- m_eiman 16y agoIt would be awesome to track every transaction in an economy, though. We'd finally be able to tell exactly what our taxes are used for, and who's paying the CEO's bonus. Not to mention the benefits when combating organized crime..! I can see how some people might think it's worth sacrificing anonymity :)
- limmeau 16y agoYou'd still not know which of the incoming payments to an account is causally connected to which outgoing payment.
- m_eiman 16y agoYou could, if the system is designed for it. Lots of little digital "coins" that are shuffled around between different accounts, with traceable history.
- uxp 16y agoDollar bills have serial numbers, so it is already possible to track incoming and outgoing transactions to an extent. The problem would come in assigning a static serial number to a pool of bits. If I spent an electronic dollar, did that dollar come from the few bucks my neighbor gave me for gas after he borrowed my lawn mower, or from my paycheck? It's not like I care which one gets spent, since they are the same, but how would you determine which one get priority. I guess the same argument applies to dollars sitting in my wallet, but its something one would have to consider designing such a system.
- xyzzyz 16y ago>The problem would come in assigning a static serial number to a pool of bits. I don't really see it. There are cryptographic protocols designed just for this kind of things. The real thing is it would be more awkward than just cash.
- limmeau 16y agoIf for every dollar you spend, you have to be aware of its history ("Oh, sorry, I can't buy cigarettes now, I only have two research-grant-dollars and three from my non-smoking mom, neither of which may be used for tobacco"), then the money ceases to be money (in the meaning of uniform tokens of value) and you're back at some later stage of bartering economy.
- dstein 16y agoPeople always use this as an example, but I don't think it's true. Next time you're in line at a retail store, or even a coffee shop, pay attention to how many people use cash. It's probably down to 50% or less these days, people already use a credit card for pretty much everything if only for the value points, convenience, and high ATM fees.
- chopsueyar 16y agoCurrency dependent on power sources?
- tomjen3 16y agoShouldn't matter - you would be dead within two weeks of a total global loss of power. We simply couldn't produce enough food.
- ars 16y agoTwo weeks? You are making the common "predict the future" mistake of assuming people will not try to do anything, and will just sit around. In actuality if there was a global loss of power people will figure out many many things to help.
- tomjen3 16y agoMaybe, but without electricity, how are you going to transport, prepare and store food?
- chopsueyar 16y agoPropane. Propane powered vehicles, propane fueled fire, propane refrigeration. ...and there is this (A Solar Ammonia Absorption Icemaker): http://homepower.com/article/?file=HP53_pg20_Vanek http://homepower.com/article/?file=HP53_pg20_Vanek Now all you need is a way to power your currency.
- chopsueyar 16y agoSpeak for yourself, fella.
- ajdecon 16y agoWho said global? A localized loss of power or connectivity for a substantial time period is not necessarily catastrophic. But there still has to be some exchange of goods and services both within this locality and between it and the outside world. Without some accepted medium of value exchange between an electronically disconnected region and the outside world, it becomes much more difficult to establish or restore connectivity. So the purely cashless system is actually much less robust with respect to physical failures.
- syvex 16y agoAfter working with payment processing of credit, debit, EBT, and gift cards for the past few years, I have started using cash more. For most transactions, a merchant is charged between 2-3% of the purchase price. This means that whatever you are buying could be 2-3% cheaper if cash were used instead. (However, for high-volume stores this may not be true since credit transactions take less time than getting change from cash.) Furthermore, if someone steals your credit card number, you call them and have the charge removed. Does your credit card company take the loss with this? Not usually. The merchant that accepted the stolen card will pay. This in turn, makes the price of goods go up again. These things take some toll on the overall economy. The real question becomes, how can we make cash transactions more efficient so that it improves commerce for individuals and improves the profits of businesses?
- elai 16y agoATM/debit bank cards? Often only a flat .25 a transaction, PIN only, and you can't chargeback just like cash. Online transactions need a PIN interface although.
- mhb 16y agoOne way would be to get rid of any rules which prevent retailers from passing through the cost of credit card charges to credit card users in an obvious way. Like by saying that credit card transactions will cost 2-3% more than cash transactions. I think this is either discouraged or prohibited by credit card issuers.
- stan_rogers 16y agoThat'll require a fundamental re-ordering of a lot of the financial system. How do you pay the poor, whether working or on the dole (many of whom are refused bank sevices, which is currently a perfectly legal practice in most jurisdictions)? What level of loss per transaction would be unacceptable, and who gets to draw the line? What happens to garage sales, flea markets and charity bazaars? Can you lend me twenty bucks until Thursday, or do I need a bank loan?