14 ms·
From a family of hive owners: Not sure this will have any sort of meaningful impact except raise prices elsewhere... It's a grand gesture, but the science just
by exabrial 9y ago
From a family of hive owners: Not sure this will have any sort of meaningful impact except raise prices elsewhere... It's a grand gesture, but the science just isn't there. The real problems are mites, which we do not have any sort of effective treatment for, and decreased biodiversity as African bees continue to push into North America.
- pedrocr 9y agoDo you have an opinion on the treatment-free option? The idea that you can adapt the bees through selection to make them resistant enough to mites seems interesting and there are quite a few success stories. Probably none on a large commercial scale though.
- olliej 9y agoThere are actually a few such programs going on in America. I’m aware of strains where the bees bite off the limbs of mites, and some that are more aggressive towards them. There is at least want breeder that has managed to get queens that seem to result in mite free hives (Edit to clarify: resistance to mites isn’t really the problem - the problem is that the mites are very effective at spread more or less all viruses that harm bees, and the feed on the larvae just for good measure. Basically you want bees that actively fight infestation so that they don’t have to become resistant to every single disease)
- roel_v 9y agoThe consensus in the scientific community is that resistant breeds are the real solution, the question is what to do until then. Every apiculture research group has at least some people working on varroa resistant breeds, and questions like whether local breeds (in Europe) are better suited to combat varroa themselves. The whole 'no treatment' controversy is about beekeepers who treat and those who don't in the same area. On the one hand, there are those who treat and create weak colonies, on the other there are the non-treaters who might infect those weak colonies. It's sometimes bitter.
- kokey 9y agoI've seen how healthy the bee populations are at the wineries around Cape Town. The Africanized bee seems to handle the varroa mites quite well and also somehow seems unaffected by widespread neonicotinoid use.
- mikro2nd 9y agoHave you tried open-bottomed hives? The mites that get groomed off the bees fall to the ground where they're vulnerable to predators and can't crawl back up to the top of the hive to re-infest the bees. Supposedly solves the problem. I confess I have not tried it myself yet, but I'm still learning, working on a very small scale in a very benign climate and have not yet experienced any significant mite problems, so ymm(likely)v.
- exabrial 9y agoNice! We have very rough winters in Kansas (driving, persistent wind and no humidity), so it won't work year round, but it may work for our summers
- s73v3r_ 9y agoAre the hives outside during the winter? Maybe something like a greenhouse could help?
- lostlogin 9y agoIt helps, but you have to treat too where I am. Your bees over there have a degree more tolerance to the mites than ours as they are relatively new here in New Zealand.
- olliej 9y agoOh boo, varroa got to NZ? :(
- lostlogin 9y agoOh yes. And like everywhere they go they have caused havoc and spread disease. It’s very sad.
- awakeasleep 9y agoThere hasn't actually been any conclusive proof that open bottomed hives help at all
- olliej 9y agoVarroa are the big problem for /honey bees/. Honey bees are not the most significant pollinators (they’re technically fairly innefficient pollinators compared to other bees - bumble, carpenter etc) The vast majority of pollination is via non-bee insects, but just reducing the destruction of wild bees will help at least. As for mite treatment you may want to look into oxalic acid, although it’s not technically approved for use in hives (despite being less harmful than regular mite pads)
- bjelkeman-again 9y agoRegulations vary. Oxalic acid and formic acid are allowed and commonly used in Sweden, for example. We can also use thyme based extracts. We prefer cutting out drones, but we find it is not sufficient in our hives, so we complement with the other methods as required.
- olliej 9y agoIn california at least oxalic acid is not allowed, so you can only use the formic pads/strips. That said oxalic acid is "wood bleach" and i have heard multiple tales of keeper "cleaning their frames in situ"
- lostlogin 9y agoIt rusts out the metal and isn’t great for the beekeeper either. It’s seeming like a good alternative in the face of mite resistance to the synthetic treatments though. The Randy Oliver Method is with OA doused strips is gaining traction. http://scientificbeekeeping.com/tag/maqs-strips/ http://scientificbeekeeping.com/tag/maqs-strips/
- exabrial 9y agoThis recently popped up on HN which is extremely promising: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-19137-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-19137-5
- narrator 9y agoWhat would convince you that neonicotinoids kill bees? A study recently done at Purdue University perhaps?[1] Pesticides are absurdly politicized. The amount of ridicule and PR flak pesticide critics get is insane. [1] http://pollinatorstewardship.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Krupke-et-al-2017-neonic-corn-seeds.pdf http://pollinatorstewardship.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/...
- exabrial 9y agoIndeed, so sad, because as things become politcal, it goes from science to pop culture, and lies become truths because they are repeated so often. Thanks for the link to the study. I had not read that one yet. To give a counterpoint, this article on slate I thought was very convincing in the other direction: http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/2017/06/the_data_do_not_support_the_idea_that_neonics_hurt_bees.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/201...
- kenny87 9y ago>>The data were rife with other contradictions. Worker bees and drones in Britain struggled to survive the winter, but the same variety of wild bees increased in Germany. Egg production also increased in Germany but fell in Hungary. It seems a lot of bee studies only look at honey bees, but there are some 4,000 types of native bees in North America, some of which are better pollinators then the non-native European honey bee and secrete silk instead of honey. Yet our urban spaces don't do a great job of providing good habitats for native species to thrive. So that's a least part of the solution to the bee problem, not just banning a pesticide. I could go on but just check out this great SciFri episode on this topic: https://www.sciencefriday.com/segments/beyond-the-hive-the-wonderful-world-of-native-bees/ https://www.sciencefriday.com/segments/beyond-the-hive-the-w.... And do your part by supporting your local, native bee species.
- tptacek 9y agoWhat is it that you think that Purdue study says? It doesn't contradict anything that the parent comment said. Their comment seems like a pretty straightforward recitation of the situation in the US: feral honey bees --- an introduced, non-native species --- were eradicated by the Varroa destructor mite, decades ago.
- bambax 9y ago> into North America The article is about Europe.
- lostlogin 9y agoHoney bee numbers are the highest they have ever been here in New Zealand. The numbers are so great that honey takes per hive are decreasing and disease levels are high. Despite the diseases, honey bees are doing just fine. The bit that matters more though, is that native bees are struggling. http://www.afb.org.nz/beekeeping-in-nz http://www.afb.org.nz/beekeeping-in-nz
- jsilence 9y agothere has been a very positive perspective in mite treatment with a simple lithium salt. have no reference at hand, but it should come up with a google search. correct dosage still has to be researched, but it all looked very promising.
- filoeleven 9y agoYou may want to look into Paul Stamets’ research into this. He’s the mushroom guy, and he’s doing a pilot study with beekeepers, giving bees diluted extracts from certain kinds of mycelium. As of the last talk I heard him give about it, none of those colonies have collapsed. There’s a whole 20-year story that led to him testing this, starting with noticing when his bees spent a few days pushing wood chips aside to get at Garden Giant mycelium and licking it, which puzzled him. https://www.forbes.com/sites/grrlscientist/2017/06/05/can-a-mushroom-save-honey-bees https://www.forbes.com/sites/grrlscientist/2017/06/05/can-a-...
- scruple 9y agoAlso ants and robbing behaviors. Mites and ants cover the overwhelming majority of hive loss that I have personally witnessed (non-commercial, of course, and in SoCal).