3 ms·
Anyone and anything but Trump caused this. That's what I'm seeing today, and I don't think that's remotely correct. Only one major change has taken place, and
by cryptonector 9y ago
Anyone and anything but Trump caused this. That's what I'm seeing today, and I don't think that's remotely correct.
Only one major change has taken place, and it's not a change of presidency in SK.
Whether we like him or not, President Trump did this, and we should rejoice. SK's President says Trump made this possible -- shall we ignore that?
- youwishboye 9y agoif you aren't trolling, you're massively disillusioned buddy
- blhack 9y ago>Anyone and anything but Trump caused this. I initially misread your comment. To anybody who wants more info on how this all went down: SK wanted to meet with NK specifically because the US was taking increasingly aggressive stances towards NK, and they wanted to avoid conflict. The rest of the peace talks are a direct result of Trump agreeing to meet with KJU. https://www.csis.org/analysis/peace-korea-what-you-need-know-about-koreas-summit-and-trump-kim-summit https://www.csis.org/analysis/peace-korea-what-you-need-know...
- cryptonector 9y agoThat quote was a sarcastic comment on the state of this thread. If you look at my other comments on this thread you'll see I am crediting President Trump. Look folks, no one has to like DJT, but we mustn't deny his successes -- we mustn't twist ourselves into pretzels to deny that he caused NK to sue for peace.
- blhack 9y agoI misread your comment. Sorry about that! Edited. The link I posted is still a good one.
- tomtheelder 9y ago> Only one major change has taken place, and it's not a change of presidency in SK. This is so wildly inaccurate. First off, a colossal scandal and changing of power from one party to another party in one of the countries involved in the treaty certainly counts as a major change, especially when it's a transition from an anti-reconciliation government to a pro-reconciliation one. In fact, this is the first time that the president of SK has held that position during the reign of Kim Jong-Un. In addition to that, NK has finally actually demonstrated nuclear capability, turning that into a FAR more credible threat than ever before. Lastly, China's position on NK has been shifting over time (definitely started during the Obama presidency) and they have become increasingly impatient and intolerant of NK. That has accelerated during (and likely because of) Trump, but he 100% didn't start it. I am sure that Trump played a role in this, but to suggest that he is the only major change is pure American exceptionalist nonsense.
- cryptonector 9y agoNK had been working towards ICBMs + nukes for decades. This had been the biggest source of conflict with the U.S. during all that time. That their project completed is not enough to explain why the DPRK is coming to the table. Giving up their nuclear capability means they can never do this again, and they'll have no way to ensure that we keep giving them whatever it is that we'll agree to give them. Which is why I fully expected them to insist on a continuation of the status quo, with them retaining their nukes. That they are willing to [verifiably, presumably] give up their nukes is a very big deal. It means that the DPRK was faced with something very bad for them. That can only have been Trump's twisting of the screws on the DPRK. My impression is that Trump would starve them to the point that Kim would end up hanging from a lamp post, and that he has the leverage on China needed to make that happen. The change in the American approach to the DPRK nuclear weapons issue is the biggest change, and it is the direct cause of Kim suing for peace.
- openasocket 9y ago> Only one major change has taken place Trump taking office? You don't think this has anything to do with the fact that the DPRK now has a working ICBM and thermonuclear warhead, giving them much more leverage in negotiations?
- cryptonector 9y agoNot at all. Their project to make ICBMs and nukes goes back to the early 90s. It culminated recently, yes, but it's not like Trump was elected and Kim went all like "oh no, they elected Trump, let's go make nukes and show them how much we dislike Trump!". Without the DPRK's ICBM and nuclear weapons program there would have been no negotiations in 1994 (under Clinton), not in the aughts (under Bush), and not now (under Trump). EDIT: They never needed nukes. Vietnam has no nukes and we've all left them alone. Iraq would have been left alone had Hussein not invaded Kuwait. Afghanistan would have been left alone had 9/11 not happened or had the Taliban turned over bin Laden. And so on. We don't yet know what the DPRK will get out of this. So far it seems like "security guarantees". Probably also money and such, but in any verifiable nuclear disarmament by the DPRK all of such concessions are one-time. I'm shocked they're even offering anything given that once they give up the nukes they give up all leverage, but it goes to show that we (Trump!) have something even stronger leverage: we can starve the DPRK into submission because we can hurt China in the pocket book, and everyone believes that Trump means to do these things.