11 ms·
Do We Need a 37-Cent Coin?
- BerislavLopac 16y agoActually, the search for "the most efficient coin system" is kinda pointless -- if you are as advanced to discover and implement such a system, you are certainly advanced enough to implement and use a cashless system based on digital payment transactions...
- gregpilling 16y agoThe cash system will be hard to get rid of in the US. Many people want to be able to hold their real money, not just have it on a bank statement. With these same people - for fun - have a few drinks with them and try to explain to them that the dollar bill they are holding is also not 'real' in the sense that it is only a piece of paper and has no intrinsic value of its own.
- xyzzyz 16y agoCash is also useful for anonymous transactions. The anonymous cashless protocols are very complicated compared to cash, and I don't even know if anyone implements them at all.
- rdl 16y agoThe irony here is that anonymous digital cash protocols, while complicated, are also basically built around digital tokens or "coins", so efficient change-making is still relevant! (although the coins would be handled by software, so 11 or 37 unit coins would be acceptable; generally systems have used coins in the powers of two sizes, to reduce number of coins per transaction, at the expense of total number of denominations).
- m_eiman 16y agoIt would be awesome to track every transaction in an economy, though. We'd finally be able to tell exactly what our taxes are used for, and who's paying the CEO's bonus. Not to mention the benefits when combating organized crime..! I can see how some people might think it's worth sacrificing anonymity :)
- limmeau 16y agoYou'd still not know which of the incoming payments to an account is causally connected to which outgoing payment.
- m_eiman 16y agoYou could, if the system is designed for it. Lots of little digital "coins" that are shuffled around between different accounts, with traceable history.
- uxp 16y agoDollar bills have serial numbers, so it is already possible to track incoming and outgoing transactions to an extent. The problem would come in assigning a static serial number to a pool of bits. If I spent an electronic dollar, did that dollar come from the few bucks my neighbor gave me for gas after he borrowed my lawn mower, or from my paycheck? It's not like I care which one gets spent, since they are the same, but how would you determine which one get priority. I guess the same argument applies to dollars sitting in my wallet, but its something one would have to consider designing such a system.
- xyzzyz 16y ago>The problem would come in assigning a static serial number to a pool of bits. I don't really see it. There are cryptographic protocols designed just for this kind of things. The real thing is it would be more awkward than just cash.
- limmeau 16y agoIf for every dollar you spend, you have to be aware of its history ("Oh, sorry, I can't buy cigarettes now, I only have two research-grant-dollars and three from my non-smoking mom, neither of which may be used for tobacco"), then the money ceases to be money (in the meaning of uniform tokens of value) and you're back at some later stage of bartering economy.
- dstein 16y agoPeople always use this as an example, but I don't think it's true. Next time you're in line at a retail store, or even a coffee shop, pay attention to how many people use cash. It's probably down to 50% or less these days, people already use a credit card for pretty much everything if only for the value points, convenience, and high ATM fees.
- chopsueyar 16y agoCurrency dependent on power sources?
- tomjen3 16y agoShouldn't matter - you would be dead within two weeks of a total global loss of power. We simply couldn't produce enough food.
- ars 16y agoTwo weeks? You are making the common "predict the future" mistake of assuming people will not try to do anything, and will just sit around. In actuality if there was a global loss of power people will figure out many many things to help.
- tomjen3 16y agoMaybe, but without electricity, how are you going to transport, prepare and store food?
- chopsueyar 16y agoPropane. Propane powered vehicles, propane fueled fire, propane refrigeration. ...and there is this (A Solar Ammonia Absorption Icemaker): http://homepower.com/article/?file=HP53_pg20_Vanek http://homepower.com/article/?file=HP53_pg20_Vanek Now all you need is a way to power your currency.
- chopsueyar 16y agoSpeak for yourself, fella.
- ajdecon 16y agoWho said global? A localized loss of power or connectivity for a substantial time period is not necessarily catastrophic. But there still has to be some exchange of goods and services both within this locality and between it and the outside world. Without some accepted medium of value exchange between an electronically disconnected region and the outside world, it becomes much more difficult to establish or restore connectivity. So the purely cashless system is actually much less robust with respect to physical failures.
- syvex 16y agoAfter working with payment processing of credit, debit, EBT, and gift cards for the past few years, I have started using cash more. For most transactions, a merchant is charged between 2-3% of the purchase price. This means that whatever you are buying could be 2-3% cheaper if cash were used instead. (However, for high-volume stores this may not be true since credit transactions take less time than getting change from cash.) Furthermore, if someone steals your credit card number, you call them and have the charge removed. Does your credit card company take the loss with this? Not usually. The merchant that accepted the stolen card will pay. This in turn, makes the price of goods go up again. These things take some toll on the overall economy. The real question becomes, how can we make cash transactions more efficient so that it improves commerce for individuals and improves the profits of businesses?
- elai 16y agoATM/debit bank cards? Often only a flat .25 a transaction, PIN only, and you can't chargeback just like cash. Online transactions need a PIN interface although.
- mhb 16y agoOne way would be to get rid of any rules which prevent retailers from passing through the cost of credit card charges to credit card users in an obvious way. Like by saying that credit card transactions will cost 2-3% more than cash transactions. I think this is either discouraged or prohibited by credit card issuers.
- stan_rogers 16y agoThat'll require a fundamental re-ordering of a lot of the financial system. How do you pay the poor, whether working or on the dole (many of whom are refused bank sevices, which is currently a perfectly legal practice in most jurisdictions)? What level of loss per transaction would be unacceptable, and who gets to draw the line? What happens to garage sales, flea markets and charity bazaars? Can you lend me twenty bucks until Thursday, or do I need a bank loan?
- pmjordan 16y agoI quite like the idea of 1/3/10/30 cent denominations. The even more efficient combinations would be mainly a social experiment: would people adapt with better mental arithmetic, would they revolt or would they rely on automation (cash tills, computers) even more? The Euro/cent has far too many denominations with 1/2/5 at each power of 10 up to €500 (split between 8 coins and 7 notes). Combining 2s & 5s into 3s would reduce that to 10 denominations total, and I think it would be reasonable to drop single-digit cents from cash transactions entirely. IIRC Finland has "banned" 1 & 2 cent coins already. (they're in circulation obviously, but no prices require anything below the 5 cent coin)
- sethg 16y agoI like the idea of a ternary currency: redefine the dollar¹ to be worth 81 pennies², and then issue 1p, 3p, 9p, and 27p coins. (cf. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balanced_ternary http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balanced_ternary) Of course no country other than Geekistan would actually do this, so I would settle for a 1/3/10/30 system. ¹Or pound or euro, of course. ²We couldn’t call them “cents” any more, could we?
- pmjordan 16y agoOf course no country other than Geekistan would actually do this You do know about pre-decimal Pound Sterling, right? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pound_sterling#Pre-decimal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pound_sterling#Pre-decimal I particularly like the insanity of the Guinea denomination (1 Pound + 1 Shilling = 21 Shillings). My girlfriend's mother apparently was still nominally paid in Guineas as a legal secretary in the early 70s. Reminds me of volume controls that go to 11.
- dbfclark 16y agoThe story (picked up from Daniel Davies at http://d-squareddigest.blogspot.com http://d-squareddigest.blogspot.com) goes that the way one argued with Milton Friedman was to listen until he got to the part of his argument where he said "let's assume x" and then say "no, let's not!" That is, the part of the argument doing all the work tended to be hiding in some premise that economists consider innocuous but is in no way representative of the world. So here, premise (2): "probability of a transaction resulting in value v is uniform." No! Not true! In reality, people price a disproportionate number of transactions to make easy change with the coins we have, be easily divisible, be .01 less than a larger number of dollars, and so on. The discovery that cash transactions had a uniform distribution of change would actually be quite weird. But worse is the smuggling in of an unconsidered definition of the good in the form of the efficiency metric -- fewest coins per transaction. Even granting the uniform distribution, making change out of your pocket is still solving the subset-sum problem in your head, which is of course NP-complete. The existing setup of coins, including the first three powers of 5, makes this problem very easy while almost all the proposed "better" solutions actually make this aspect of the problem harder rather than easier. Who cares if I have to handle a few extra tenths of a coin per transaction if it means I don't have to spend two minutes puzzling out how to make change? I suppose the lesson, as usual, is that business logic is lived experience, not theory.
- xyzzyz 16y ago>making change out of your pocket is still solving the subset-sum problem in your head, which is of course NP-complete. Generally speaking, that's true. Most currencies however are designed, so that the greedy algorithm always works and produces optimal solution. The coin systems given in the linked article do not have this property, so they are actually inferior to real systems. edit: come to think of it, they in fact do, but it requires ridiculous amounts of pennies, so my argument still holds.
- Locke1689 16y agoFWIW I got that from the original poster: the general case problem is NP complete but most of our special cases are not.
- jerf 16y agoI rather suspect that if we consider "the ability for most of the population to correctly and reliably perform mental math using the tokens provided" that while our current system still doesn't win it has a much better showing. And yes, I'm willing to ignore the fact that people are already familiar with the current system, but I can't come up with a much better one off the top of my head. By that metric, 37-cent pieces are just about the worst coinage possible, 11-cent pieces are a joke, and even 15-cent pieces which don't evenly add up to a dollar are a suboptimal. Even by economist standards, ignoring this aspect of the system is rather a disappointment.
- jjcm 16y agoPerhaps a good measure of whether or not the general populous can perform mental math based on the value of the coins is to check and see whether or not a single dollar is divisible by the value of the coins (as you hinted with the 15 cent coin). It allows for many mental paths to arrive at the correct answer for what amount of coins are needed to make a certain sum. Take the nickel for example, to make 50 cents you might think to yourself, "I just need to divide 50 by 5, which is obviously 10." Alternately one might think, "I know there are 20 nickels in a dollar, if I halve this I'll have half a dollar, which is 50 cents. That means I need 10 nickels." I'd say that the pool of coin values we can choose from then are 50, 25, 20, 10, 5, 2, 1. The two cent piece is already in use in Europe, and many economists have suggested adding it to the coinage in the united states (usually in replacement for the penny altogether). It'd be interesting to see if the 20 cent coin would be a viable addition though.
- daychilde 16y agoI very much agree that's the practical pool of possible coin values. Seems to me if one wanted to simplify the system, a good solution would be (1, 5, 10, 50). This would really make the math simple. But I don't think people would give up quarters happily; nor do I think fifty cent pieces would go over well; and I think it's high time to lose pennies. So if I was the evil overlord in charge, I think I'd just drop to (5, 25). Cash transactions would round to the nearest nickel instead of penny. Getting back four nickels instead of two dimes would be gotten used to quickly, I think.
- impeachgod 16y agoActually, in the Soviet Union you used to have 3-kopek and 15-kopek coins, as well as 3-ruble notes.
- listic 16y agoClarification: late Soviet ruble (1961-1991) had the following coins: 1, 2, 3, 5, 10, 15, 20, 50 copecks and 1 ruble http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_ruble http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_ruble I think if you really want to minimize the number of coins per transaction, you can always add more (than four) denominations of coins, up to some reasonable number.
- z0r 16y agoAbolish the penny, use a uniform rounding rule to make the nickel the smallest denomination. I hate pennies.
- matrix 16y agoI strongly agree. This is the correct answer to the problem. That and adding sales tax to the tagged price (i.e. don't add sales tax at the time of the transaction).
- Splines 16y agoThe problem with adding sales tax to the price tag is that sales tax isn't uniform across the U.S., and residents from one state can buy something and have a different sales tax applied (I see this happen frequently with Oregon -> Washington travelers). I suppose the first step would be to unify sales (or whatever) tax across the country.
- ultrasaurus 16y agoIn Ontario specifically the tax can depend on the total purchase: fast food purchases under $4 (total) are taxed less than those over $4, so we have a lot of $3.99 value meals. If you buy two, it's 13%, if you buy one it's 5%.
- billpg 16y agoWhat if you buy one, and then another seconds later? (Just curious)
- stan_rogers 16y agoPerfectly legal (although you're likely to draw intense ire from people behind you if you try it in a lunchtime lineup, since you don't actually have to leave the counter in order to create a separate transaction). Oh, and it won't work in a drive-through (not because there's anything wrong with it as such, but that ungrouping the orders makes fulfillment a pain in the butt, so restaurants usually won't do it as a matter of local policy.
- growt 16y agoMaybe he should take into account that in the real world most prices are xy.99, this might change stipulation 2.
- jonknee 16y agoExcept there is sales tax, so your $xx.99 purchases usually don't end up that way. For a $1.99 purchase in my city I end up paying $2.13 which would be helped nicely by the $.37 cent coin. I see your point, I doubt the distribution is completely uniform. But it's probably not as clustered as you'd think (different taxation levels helps).
- growt 16y agoOk, I see. I live in germany, where the tax is already included (a 99 cent coin would be really efficient here).
- jonknee 16y agoOr retailers that don't do the .99 business when tax is already in place. For whatever reason, movie theaters in the US do this. They build the tax into the price and then use even units (it's still way overpriced, but at least you know the $6 pop-corn and $4 soda will mean you owe $10). You're still ahead of the game because for a .99 purchase you'll get .01 back which is just one coin where if I'm using bills would need to pay with two singles and get .93 back (which for the US is at minimum 8 coins). It's no coincidence why I have tons of change collected.
- jasonjei 16y agoThe problem as others have stated with including the tax is that if you have a multi-state presence, the tax rates for different cities, counties, and states are different, and sometimes are a huge difference (2-3%). I don't think it should be up to the retailer to foot the difference. But I do think rounding is an easier solution than a 37-cent piece.
- 16y ago
- jasonfried 16y agoYes!
- laut 16y agoI'm more concerned about other aspects of the U.S. economy. Such as inflation. That's what made pennies worth so little in the first place. These numbers are also more interesting than pennies: http://usdebtclock.org/ http://usdebtclock.org/
- martingordon 16y agoJeez, the 37signals worshipping around here is getting a bit out of hand. In all seriousness, how about vendors start pricing products with tax included, rounding to the nearest quarter dollar? Say what you will about movie theatre concession pricing, at least you're not going to walk out of there needing a tub for your change as well as your popcorn.
- decadentcactus 16y agoAt least here in Australia, prices at the shops will include taxes. So getting the correct change out while waiting in line is pretty simple.
- points 16y agoSame in the UK. Sales tax in the US is just ridiculous. I've never understood why they would prefer things that way.
- hugh3 16y agoAs mentioned elsewhere, it's because sales tax varies from state to state and from county to county. So if you're going to advertise something for a given price, you either have to exclude sales tax or accept that you'll be making significantly less profit selling it in California than in Oregon. It's a crazy system, but state and local governments are dependent on sales tax revenue so it's impossible to dislodge. The system in the UK isn't exactly sane either though, as I recall from the fact that everything at Pret is advertised with an "eat in" and "take away" price since the two scenarios are taxed differently. If you say you'll take it away but then change your mind and eat it in, you're presumably in serious (theoretical) trouble. And then you've got the Australian system which is at least invisible to the consumer but is still annoying and inconsistent to the merchant. It was going to be a consistent 10% applied to everything, but the minor left-wing parties insisted at the last minute that it needed to exclude some but not all forms of food. Meanwhile feminists have been agitating for years to get tampons excluded as well... not because any analogous male or unisex product (toilet paper?) is excluded but because they have apparently run out of any serious problems to complain about.
- vaksel 16y agofrankly I don't see why we even need coins at all. Talk about your waste of resources minting all of those. It was fine when a can of coke was 25 cents or when you could get a new car for 2 grand. But in this day and age? It's just a waste. should just switch to a digital currency already...disposable credit cards that can transfer funds between each other.
- protomyth 16y agoWell, some people really like cash, and I still run into places, particularly in rural areas, where credit cards are only allowed on purchases over $20. The credit card fees are a great incentive to keep cash / coins.
- vaksel 16y agoI'd imagine the digital currency would be run by the government. So they'd be 'minting' these new cards, and as such there'd be no fees to talk about.
- swaits 16y agoBecause the government does everything else so well and it's all totally free!
- vaksel 16y agothat's what we have now... are you seriously suggesting that we should outsource the "minting" of our money? are you insane?
- whatusername 16y agothat's what we have now... (where do you think those credit cards come from) // Sorry - couldn't help myself.
- sethg 16y agoFrom the government’s point of view, there is no reason to make it easier for citizens to anonymously and untraceably send money to one another. It’s politically impossible for them to eliminate paper/metal cash, but they’re not going to make cash transactions any easier. (And any country whose central bank supports completely digital anonymous cash will suffer the fate of Nauru: first it will attract money launderers from all over the world, and then the world financial system will shut off all contact with it until it reforms.)
- Anomaly775 16y agoI'm willing to use 0.60 more coins during transactions if it saves people from actually learning how to count.
- frgbhnmnjh 16y agoCan i suggest splitting the $ into 20 equal parts and then each of those parts into 12cents. Then you could have 1,2,3,6 cent coins and 1,2,10 part coins. For anyone that can manage the calculations for feet/inches/yards/miles, drams/ounces/pounds/tons it should be simple.
- blahedo 16y agoBrilliant! But perhaps we could go with a 2.5 part coin instead? There's just something that feels right about that.
- frgbhnmnjh 16y agoA sterling suggestion - I award you half-a-crown
- Aron 16y agoThe negPenny! Anyone want to write a quick script to check combinations that include negative values?
- limmeau 16y agoJoking of which, complex currency would also be an interesting toy. The imaginary part could represent some orthogonal aspect of worth, e.g. consumption of scarce resources.
- jerf 16y agoInteresting, but since there's no reason to multiply two money values together (what use is a square dollar?), it doesn't really do anything. It ends up trivially degenerating into two currencies with some exchange rate between them.
- Dove 16y agoI already consider food to have costs in two currencies: one in dollars and one in calories. There is no conversion between them; I must meet both budgets.
- jerf 16y agoWhat on Earth are you talking about "there's no conversion between them"?!? You can't trade dollars for food? You can't trade food for dollars? What are dollars good for if there's no conversion between them and food? The lack of an abstract market selling and buying abstract "calories" at some price doesn't mean there isn't a conversion between them, just that it isn't clean and has a lot of other moving parts, just like everything else in the real world. Hie thee hence to a microeconomics textbook forthwith, I've been enjoying http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Price_Theory/PThy_ToC.html http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Price_Theory/PThy_ToC... but heck anything would do.
- Dove 16y ago
- nsfmc 16y agoSay what you will, at least the article has a sense of humor. “How can you tell that Patrick is a young economist from the preceding discussion? Because he finds that the current government solution for the coins we use is 98 percent efficient and thinks this is inefficient.”
- saraid216 16y agoit would be a lot more efficient if we went to only 1 decimal place and got rid of everything but the dime.
- ryanwanger 16y ago10 years ago, when I visited Australia, their currency was similar in value to the US (I think an aussie dollar was worth roughly 65 cents US), and they had no pennies OR nickles. It started at 10 cents. They also had 1 and 2 dollar coins. The best part was that the change in your pocket was worth enough to actually allow you to buy things with it. Not like we have now, where people only use it to avoid getting more change back.
- JoeAltmaier 16y agoWho uses coins to pay exact change? I use bills, pocket the change (or leave it in the dish), it piles up in jars at home. Make the coins lighter! So my pocket doesn't wear out from carrying half a pound of worthless metal.
- code_duck 16y agoI hate economists.
- julius_geezer 16y agoThe novelist Anthony Burgess once wrote about the convenience of the old British system of pence, shillings, pounds, and guineas: the pound was evenly divisible to a value in pence if not shillings by 2, 3, 5, and guinea also by 7.