3 ms·
Would you be okay with someone possessing nude photos of yourself? After all, "holding information isn't in itself harmful", as you state. What about, god forbi
by andrepd 9y ago
Would you be okay with someone possessing nude photos of yourself? After all, "holding information isn't in itself harmful", as you state. What about, god forbid, pornography starring your underage child. Is it still "just information"?
- pitay 9y agoBeing a reasonable person, I don't see any reason I would care if someone has nude photos of myself, even if I was a child at the time the photos was taken. The photos are not harming me, nor will they be harmful to me in any sense other than random chance. I know there is a photo of me pissing into the sea when I was young, it doesn't bother me a bit.
- andrepd 9y agoIt's good that you don't care, but don't I (or anyone else) have a right to care and not want those photos? And I don't believe that you wholly don't care. I'm almost certain you must have some photos, or potentially may have some situations, if you were photographed, that are embarrassing and that you wouldn't want the general public (parents, coworkers, boss) to see.
- GyYZTfWBfQw 9y agoDid he say that you don't have the right to care? He did not. You can care, you may not want these photos to be where they are, and you may attempt to have them removed if it is possible, but you don't have the right to punish people for not caring, and you don't have the right to force people to care for the things you do. I personally hate being on photos, so I try to avoid it to my best ability. I also asked someone to have a photo of me removed from somewhere. This is all understandable. The problem occurs when you are trying to dictate other people's lives by threatening to use violence against them for not conforming to your beliefs, etc. No need to resort to violence, come on. I have a feeling you would attempt to beat me up for my tone alone because you perceive it to be hostile. Not cool. :P
- letsgetphysITal 9y agoIf I make those photos available then yes, of course I would be happy. If they were taken without my consent, that is different. If I do not take adequate measures to protect them from accidental or malicious release, that is also different. I am specifically saying that owning knowledge should not be illegal. Creation, distribution, profiting from... All different things. Possession of data at rest should not be a crime, regardless of content. It's what's done with it that changes legality, in my opinion.
- andrepd 9y agoThat's reducing things to a logical extreme and removing all considerations of practicality. In the end, that's not a good way to look at law, or the nitty-gritty of the world for that matter. If you find someone with nude photos of yourself, and you didn't give them to them, then you can conclude that those photos were obtained illegally. That fixation on the distinction between "technically just posession" and "creation/distribution/etc." is not really helpful.
- GyYZTfWBfQw 9y agoThe following paragraphs may contain content that you might find extremely offensive. If you are generally a sensitive individual to such content, please stop reading NOW. Hahaha, gotta love it when they try to appeal to emotions and whatnot. Hey, I'm another person who doesn't give a shit about someone else having a photo of me on their hard drive. If it's there, it's most likely because I gave it to someone. At that point I lost control over who have access to my photo as that someone could share it with someone else and so on. If you don't trust that person, don't give it to them. If it gets to that person through government surveillance, for example, well, what the heck can I do anyways? I don't think that for a second that making it illegal to possess will somehow help me in that case. Do you think it actually helps you against genuinely malicious actors? Be more careful. In regard to pornography starring my non-existent underage child: yeah, how about, I don't know, pay more attention to your kid, improve your parenting? There are many resources to help you do that. What next, are you going to make the government threaten to kill others if they refuse to feed your kid through taxation because you bred despite the fact you are unable to feed your kid? Unbelievable that you expect "illegal to possess" laws to be effective. They are not. On top of that, people usually share all kinds of semi-nude (or even full) photos of their babies, etc. on Facebook. Maybe stop doing that? I wonder how many of these parents have a teenager daughter posting semi-nudes on Instagram, or full nudes on Snapchat without their parents' knowledge. Go educate your offspring of the risks and potential consequences. Pay more attention to them. Let me reveal another secret: many perverts on the Internet are probably also masturbating to these photos. Who cares? Does it make you furious? Buy a punching bag, or go for a jog. Your idiocy makes me furious and makes you a criminal per https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/21/section/127 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/21/section/127 if you are a British citizen, as you are causing me a great deal of annoyance. Unlike you, I think I should exercise my mental ability that allows me to ignore you and not give a shit instead of depriving you of money and potentially your "freedom". I wonder how you would feel then if I were just like you. You wouldn't like it now, would you?
- andrepd 9y agoYou shouldn't care about people possessing child pornography, because if you do then it's because you should have "paid more attention to your kid and improved your parenting". Got it. Have a nice day then. EDIT: I know I shouldn't reply to trolls, but your drivel ticked me off so, dumb as I am, I'm going to respond. Yes, criminalizing possession of child pornography reduces the consumption, and therefore demand, of said child pornography. I'm sorry if this offends you, or that you think your "freedom" (to own child porn?) is threatened by this, but I rather think reducing the number of child abuse cases is a worthier goal than stroking your misplaced sense of worth. >What next, are you going to make the government threaten to kill others if they refuse to feed your kid through taxation because you bred despite the fact you are unable to feed your kid? Oh you're one of those guys. You just couldn't resist the urge to shoehorn your agenda and announce at the top of your lungs: "look at me guys! I'm rugged and tough and I don't care about your kids! I am so smart!". >many perverts on the Internet are probably also masturbating to these photos That I don't give a shit about, and I never said that I did, so you can store your straw man back in the cupboard. What I care about is measurable decreases in demand for child abuse content that are the result of criminalization of possession. Finally, kindly knock off your stupid fucking derisive tone. I would wager a considerable amount of money that you wouldn't talk like that in person, with anybody.
- PurpleBoxDragon 9y agoUnder current law that is already legal as long as they hold copyright. There is a grey area deciding what is artistic and what is prurient, but if ruled artistic, they could publish it in a book and sale in on Amazon. But I think we should consider a major division between the rules of sharing information and the rules of possessing information. If I know how to make something bad, that shouldn't be wrong. If I share that for the sake of a discussion, that shouldn't be wrong. If I share it with someone who will use it to cause harm, knowingly aiding them in causing harm... well isn't that where we should say wrong has been done?