4 ms·
The was an article in The Atlantic a couple+ months back - which after 10 mins I still can't find - about some scientist and his alt view / theory on DNA. The g
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
The was an article in The Atlantic a couple+ months back - which after 10 mins I still can't find - about some scientist and his alt view / theory on DNA. The gist, if I recall correctly, was (and forgive me if I fall short of capturing the significance of his idea):
How DNA functions is far more complicated than how current accepted science pictures it.
1 - Certainly seems like he might be onto something.
2 - If so, could the use of CRISPR be premature, if not dangerous?
- ItsMe000001 9y ago> How DNA functions is far more complicated than how current accepted science pictures it. From what I learned in courses on edX (e.g. MITs Eric Lander's "Introduction to Biology" or RiceX BIOC300.2x "DNA: Biology's Genetic Code"), that is already well known and taught. Scientists are not naive and overconfident in their knowledge, individual examples to the contrary notwithstanding. Guess what - they teach what is actually reliably and verifiably known. It's just a bit too much to expect scientists to work with methods and knowledge they don't even know exist yet, or even to teach them - but that doesn't mean they think they already know it all. Science is full of this exact thing: Layer upon layer of models. Bohr's atom model is very far from what a physics student learns these days. The Newton universe vs. the relativity universe. Chemical bonds in high-school, then in early university chemistry courses, and then what physicists work with who study bonding seems like it comes from entirely different universes, although it all describes the same thing. Same with DNA. The more courses you take the more the knowledge resembles a Mandelbrot set image. Actually, that's a horrible analogy, because in that image when you go deeper you still get similar structures, but when you go deeper in science the same thing starts looking very different. The reason why I still use this analogy is because the part that seems applicable and important is that you can go deeper and deeper and deeper and... (etc.) However, as far as I could tell from just a few courses that complexity already is being taught as far as this is possible (as I mentioned above, it's hard to teach "unknown unknowns", to quote a famous American politician philosopher /s ). What you should keep in mind though is that on each level of knowledge there are a lot - often A LOT - of experiments and applications of that level of knowledge that have been shown to work reliably and well. It's just that new levels of knowledge (and models) open up new possibilities. "Every model is wrong, some models are useful", I only understood what that means when I learned more and more and realized how useless the word "truth" is when attempted to be used in absolute terms. Each model is "true" for the things it successfully and reliably predicts, and for the applications it makes possible. Finding deeper models does not invalidate what you already learned and used successfully. I would suggest seeing science not as the search for "the one final truth". As practised, it is far more practical (yes, same word twice, deliberately). You find something, you demonstrate that it works, you show that it is useful ("you" is many people), you move on. "If you want 'truth' you are in the wrong lecture, philosophy is down the hall" is a sentence I remember to have read having been said a (biology? physics?) professor when he started the first freshman lecture. By concentrating on what you can demonstrate you don't need to have "the final truth" before you are able to do anything useful. You go step by step, and while you don't know if there ever is a final word that does not really matter. That means your statement > How DNA functions is far more complicated than how current accepted science pictures it. actually already is built into science. You can always assume that there is much more that you are not yet aware of.
- klmr 9y ago> 2 - If so, could the use of CRISPR be premature, if not dangerous? This is really an ill-posed question. First off, CRISPR is a tool. Its novelty is the fact that it makes an experiment vastly simpler and more reliable — but, fundamentally, the experiment was already possible beforehand. So CRISPR itself isn’t dangerous. At most, modifying genetic material could be. Secondly, genetic modification — whether by CRISPR or other methods — is an extremely generic process. Sure, it could be dangerous, if you use it to perform dangerous experiments. Can it have unintended side-effects? Sure, we already know about those. In fact, one of the great things about CRISPR is that it drastically decreases side-effects. But is CRISPR dangerous specifically because we underestimate the complexity of DNA? No. Nothing about CRISPR assumes that we know all biological processes that involve DNA. In fact, we know that we don’t know them all. Lastly, somebody with an “alt view on DNA” immediately sounds like a crackpot with a poor handle on modern biology. That may sound harsh but biology is a science, not a pseudoscience or protoscience (or magic): we’re moving within some relatively fixed boundaries imposed by experimentation and evidence. Uncertainty or lack of knowledge isn’t a free-for-all to insert wild speculations that usually amount to “everything we know is wrong”. It’s very rare that “everything we know turns out to be wrong”. In reality, subsequent findings refine existing ones, or disprove specific hypotheses. They don’t disprove an established field. Even something as revolutionary as Einstein’s theory of relativity didn’t do that: gravity continued to function just fine afterwards. Newton continues to be taught in school, because Newton’s laws continue to be relevant.
- laythea 9y ago"...biology is a science, not a pseudoscience or protoscience (or magic)" I agree with your overall point but I take slight issue with this statement. I am not biologically educated, but I am biological. I have no idea what my conscious is or why/how it works, even though I do know that I exist. And neither do you, nor anyone. To me, that is the classic definition of magic. This differs from eg electronics, physics etc, because I am biological. I have a personal perspective on it, in a manner that I could never with electronics, physics etc. Ie. I can readily understand how far away from understanding the biological process humanity is.
- 9y ago
- ajross 9y ago> How DNA functions is far more complicated than how current accepted science pictures it. So, specifically: i-motif structures were understood experimentally. They had never been detected in vivo before, and doing so constitutes great science and a solid find, but no: this isn't something out of left field that our naive hubristic minds couldn't conceive. These scientists found i-motif in vivo because they were actively looking for it. Beyond that, what you say is true of course, but only in a specious sense that applies to every field of science. The whole point to doing these experiments is that we don't understand things completely and want to. I mean, would you argue against air flight in 1903 based on the fact that a computational framework for dealing with the Navier-Stokes equations was still decades in the future?
- 88e282102ae2e5b 9y agoThe danger of using CRISPR could have, in principle, been worse than it turned out to be, sure. But the fact is, CRISPR has been used to modify living organisms, and those organisms don't have any more mutations than average, and they seem to be just as healthy as unmodified organisms (unless the edit itself is deleterious). We might find out some day that there's some behavior of DNA and DNA-binding proteins that CRISPR interferes with, but if it does exist, the effect has to be small enough that we wouldn't notice it. edit: I should clarify, there's still work left to do to ensure CRISPR's safety. It needs to be looked at in more cell types, and work in somatic cells in adult organisms is still in its early days. My point is just that putting CRISPR into a cell, in some scenarios, doesn't cause substantial problems.
- robbiep 9y agoApologies for going off tangent but, as someone who majored in biochemistry/molecular biology (now almost 8 years in the past, which was pres CRISPR but has been reinforced by continual education in medicine) This is such a beautiful inadequacy of our knowledge. My intro to science and molecular science was first massively sparked by an E. coli article I randomly jumped to in the early stages of Wikipedia. It talked about error correcting proteins, and versions of this and that, and I thought holy shit the cell is a computer. As I came to understand more of molecular biology I was fortunate to find it very easy to visualise and understand not just the idea that the theories and molecular pathways we understand are an amazing set of dominos that have to fall in a particular order but also the stochastic relationship of them all - on, off, according to molecular affinities, and those are just the pathways we have been able to understand by way of intelligent experiments and human ingenuity. To jump radically back on topic - There have to be and are so many more layers to how the code that builds life executes that we don’t understand that it is pure arrogance to assume that we understand the system enough to perfectly execute any modifications to it. That doesn’t mean it’s wrong to look down the rabbit hole, after all, that’s all we’ve ever done
- chiefalchemist 9y agoFound it! Here's the previously mentioned bit in The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/06/its-like-all-connected-man/530532/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2017/06/its-like...
- allenz 9y agoThe The Atlantic article is sensationalized and oversimplified. The scientists are mainstream, and they found that most of the variation between people in complex traits such as height are due to variation in genes outside core pathways. In other words, there is relatively little variation in genes responsible for growth hormone; instead the cumulative effects of millions of variations in seemingly unrelated genes is what explains differences in height. This is not relevant in the context of gene therapy, where we only change one gene or a small number of genes. From that paper, we would expect that a single change would have a tiny, negligible effect on unrelated genes. Moreover, the initial targets for CRISPR therapies aim to correct mutations. For example, cystic fibrosis is caused by a point mutation in the gene for a mucus protein. CRISPR would be used to restore the genotype that all healthy people have. Since healthy people have this gene, side effects are unlikely. (However, we do expect side effects from other mechanisms such as immune rejection.)