3 ms·
The problem with doing this analysis of a bunch of college students at top-tier colleges is that there’s a big selection bias. My guess (from having spent four
by jacobolus 16y ago
The problem with doing this analysis of a bunch of college students at top-tier colleges is that there’s a big selection bias. My guess (from having spent four years as a Harvard student and talking to many of them) is that, statistically, the kids who manage to get into a school like Harvard while having low latent inhibition probably need to have something else working for them to compensate for that.
In other words, the types of people who get in can be (as a model, remember; this is far from completely accurate) classified along two dimensions, let’s call them A and B, where:
+A = Great latent inhibition. Able to focus and work really diligently on some assigned task.
-A = Less latent inhibition. Some probably ADHD. Less able to focus diligently because they get distracted more easily.
+B = Really "creative"/bright/clever/smart/"rich mixture of thoughts". Think "high IQ" here, though there are a bunch of correlated dimensions here that can’t ideally sort people. Better description might be "paying close attention to the world" or "picks up new things quickly".
-B = Less "creative"/bright/clever/smart/whatever
Okay, so think about who gets into a place like Harvard. I posit that you end up with some +A+B types, some +A-B types, some -A+B types, and a lot less -A-B types.
In other words, to get into Harvard you’d better be a hard worker, or pretty sharp, or both, but if you’re neither you’ll have some trouble.
So now, what does this study actually do? It splits up the population into two groups, +A and -A, and then tries to find a correlation between that and +B/-B.
Well, in the first group we have +A+Bs and +A-Bs, while in the second group we only have the -A+Bs (the -A-Bs having already been excluded by the admissions criteria)
Then the study (or at least the Wired write-up) turns this into a causal link between -A and +B.... well, count me at least skeptical. I know some really really smart people who are also able to focus really well. Which is not to say that there certainly isn’t some other relationship between these two dimensions, but only that a study like this doesn’t seem like "proof". If we imagine these dimensions as normally distributed and independent, where you need some cut-off sum of A + B to get into a selective college, the number of students falling at the far right end of both bell curves (the +A+B bunch) at once might be really small.