3 ms·
I have a dissenting opinion. Rather than getting two more fabs, Chinese state funds have just launched two more barely working ones that add to a long long lis
by baybal2 9y ago
I have a dissenting opinion.
Rather than getting two more fabs, Chinese state funds have just launched two more barely working ones that add to a long long list of their failed attempts to achieve self sufficiency in memory supply.
There were numerous attempts by Xinhua University Group in the past to launch memory businesses. Judging by that those fabs stand dark for years, none of them succeeded, and a lot of taxpayers money just got wasted again.
- dis-sys 9y ago> There were numerous attempts by Xinhua University Group in the past to launch memory businesses. Judging by that those fabs stand dark for years, none of them succeeded, and a lot of taxpayers money just got wasted again. That is the exact non-sense talked by many people 10-15 years ago regarding BOE and its state backed investment. Look at what BOE achieved in mid/long term.
- ksec 9y ago1. They weren't as serious as this time around. 2. The money involved before were tiny compared to this round. 3. They now have a market to absorb some lower quality components. 4. The market is now making so much money from NAND and DRAM that is unseen in past time. There is not better time to enter the market. Even at half the yield then other major competitor they would still be able to make money. 5. I don't think they will catch up in 3D NAND any time soon. But DDR4 seems to be a easier target.
- baybal2 9y agoKsec, there may be merit to your thought here, but just for point 4. Even though memory market was always the ultimate cash cow, and price collusion was always the second name to it, what we see today is something completely "beyond good and evil." I regularly meet Unigroup people just below the C-suite level during industry events in China. The do not give off any sense of brilliance to me, nor I can say anything high of their ability from what they did before. Sure, they are probably the top fund by concentration of Oxford and Ivy league grads in China, and have few returnee cadres with past stellar career in Western top tier investment funds. I can even go as far as to say that if judged individually, some can be said to be genuine talents. With all that star crew, why don't they fly? Because they are dominated people with stellar credentials, but all of whom are just meh and so so... Just look what their "genius stratagem" of joining RDA and Spreadtrum did: they took a leader in one market, a leader on another market, joined them and got one without lead in any. When Qualcomm was still greatly greatly handicapped in Chinese market by the fact that they were limited to high-end as low-to-mid-end market was a shark tank with likes of Spreadtrum and RDA in their prime. But when Unigroup decided to forcefully uproot both of them from their power base - domestic mass market, and mandate them to "abandon it all, focus on high-end, and make a chip to nail Qualcomm in under a year" they both lost their grip on their market niches, which Qualcomm and Mediatek were happy to devour, and of course they never came even close to scoring anything in high end market that Unigroup wanted. Now they have neither low-end lead, nor high-end lead. As the saying goes: you don't get iron by joining brass and bronze.
- ksec 9y agoI do agree with you on their silly "directions", But, Let just say marking DRAM isn't rocket science. The key really is yield. And there is going to be some learning curve involves. UniIC actually posted a picture last year in December about their success on DDR4, but it was quickly deleted because the yield was only in single digit, i.e really bad, the info was shared on Weibo and known internally within the industry but it was deleted. In Feb when Anandtech posted the news, I thought it was hoax again. Turns out UniIC actually did post a PR and yield is now 30%+. Which to be honest is still crap, but at least in today's market value, they could still break even. The more trial and error they do, the quicker they will be to up its yield. Something the market has allow them to do, if it was any previous years, the lost would be too great no one will be willing to "shoulder" this lost and lots of work will be needed to save faces. I don't think Unigroup will mess up again, unless they decide to focus on something like HBM or LPDDR4, otherwise I think there is going to be sizeable low end market within China using UniC. I don't expect them to complete in the high end, but their entry I hope will put a stop in the memory pricing. Which is like at a ridiculous level. P.S - UniGroup also has a change a direction and new objective under Xi, no longer are they acting mindlessly. Which is both a good and bad thing.
- fspeech 9y agoI don't think Spreadtrum and RDA were in any real sense leaders. Spreadtrum made money in GSM when that was going away. They also had a niche in TDSCDMA, which was forced upon China Mobile as a homebrew standards and from which China Mobile wanted to get out as soon as they could. RDA were more diversified in their mixed signal offerings, but their revenue peaked in 2012, and already declined significantly in 2013 when they were acquired.
- baybal2 9y agoAnd yeah, Unigroup people also have long history of fail trying make a Chinese x86 clone...
- userbinator 9y agoThere was plenty of foreign x86 in the 90s; here's a memorable one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UMC_Green_CPU https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UMC_Green_CPU Of course, VIA is still around too, as is this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhaoxin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhaoxin
- SomewhatLikely 9y agoHow much of Chinese government money is from taxes, and how much from profits of government owned companies? You could view the latter as 100% taxes, but with less disincentives to work. EDIT: If random quora answers are to be trusted, taxes are about 90% of government funding: https://www.quora.com/How-does-the-Chinese-government-fund-its-operations https://www.quora.com/How-does-the-Chinese-government-fund-i...