6 ms·
You should feel upset and scared. Sites like 23andMe are just a small subset of genes and variations of them. The number of false positives due to this limit is
by superkuh 9y ago
You should feel upset and scared. Sites like 23andMe are just a small subset of genes and variations of them. The number of false positives due to this limit is significant. In whole database fishing searches by non-experts (ie, police) it will result in false positives every single time.
And also contributing is the increased sensitivity of the DNA amplification methods and lax procedures at most labs. See http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/03/forensics-gone-wrong-when-dna-snares-innocent http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/03/forensics-gone-wrong-...
>In 2013, geneticist Michael Coble of the National Institute of Standards and Technology in Gaithersburg, Maryland, set up a hypothetical scenario in which a mix of DNA from several people had been found on a ski mask left at a crime scene after a series of robberies. Coble asked 108 labs across the country to determine whether a separate DNA sample, which he posited had come from a suspect in the robberies, was also part of the mix. Seventy-three of the labs got it wrong, saying the suspect's DNA was part of the mix when, in fact, it was not.
- sedatk 9y agoIt only allows finding the suspect. A full DNA test is required to be conclusive. I think it is the case here.
- st26 9y agoThe Wikipedia notes the police acquired a sample of the suspect's DNA and confirmed a match to the crime samples
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- astura 9y agoYes, and they even acquired a second sample after the first came back positive just to confirm.
- fixermark 9y agoIf anything, I'd expect people to have more concern about the fact that the police in California are allowed to steal your stuff and grab DNA off of it than the risks from them being allowed to submit your DNA to a privately-owned database full of voluntary DNA submissions.
- haZard_OS 9y agoI agree that the use of a public genealogy database is problematic but the way in which the police obtained the genetic material is not. Once a person discards any material as trash in a public space, it's fair game. The police didn't begin doing this sort of thing when DNA tests were invented.
- astura 9y ago"steal your stuff and grab DNA off of it" It's not stealing. First off, if you discard something in the trash you no longer are laying a claim to it and giving it up for the trash handlers. Secondly, it was established in California v. Greenwood that you don't have a privacy right to trash left out on the public curb for pickup; which obviously implies that you don't have a privacy right to trash placed in a public bin.
- fixermark 9y agoExcellent; thank you for the clarification.
- autokad 9y agoI dont think thats a good analogy. a better one is your neighbor discarded trash, and your trash is like your neighbors. I personally think privacy laws need to be set up right away. I think it should be illegal, even in cases of national security, to infer something from your DNA from others, such as relatives without the use of a warrant. you should not end up in what is effectively a police line up just because your brother submitted his dna to the public domain. people should not be able to use information about his dna, in any way imaginable to infer anything about you.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- z3t4 9y agoPolice, judges and lawyers probably don't know the difference between a DNA test and a DNA test. People used to go to jail because they had the same blood type as the criminal.
- lawlessone 9y agoConsidering it's their job i'd say they no quite a bit.
- dx034 9y agoDNA-based evidence led to a lot of wrong convictions in the early stages but methods have improved significantly. No judge would send someone to jail because a sample at 23andme matches. But they could issue a warrant to allow a further DNA test of the suspect.
- Retric 9y agoThere is significant lag between false convictions and proof of innocence. So, it might seem like a huge improvement but it's far smaller difference than you might think.
- mannykannot 9y agoIf things were that bad now, the relative whose DNA first came up as a a close match would now be in custody and on her way to a conviction. To see how things were actually done, RTFA.
- fixermark 9y agoRight, but the issues with using geneology-resolution DNA to match a specific individual are already understood---you yourself have highlighted them. A defendant is one expert witness away from undermining a case that relies on that low of a resolution of matching alone. In this case, that data was only used as a pointer to suggest to police that deeper scrutiny of the identified suspect was warranted.
- cat199 9y ago
- ImSkeptical 9y agoI don't think it should be the only evidence required to convict, but it sure seems helpful. If further testing, and other details, line up, what's wrong with this approach?
- Shivetya 9y agoDoes anyone know which professions in the US that are government related that the DNA information is preserved? I would surprised if there are not positions which require it. Surely law enforcement is keeping the records on some convicts. Do they even need a warrant to obtain it? what I am leading up to is I can easily see where it becomes a requirement for others and it might start off with police forces because of the high visibility of abuse issues. From there it is not a big leap to other high visibility groups to include military and eventually everyone gets lumped in for medical safety and such. It isn't that we need to be scared of what 3rd party sites do, it is that we need to be ahead of the game and limit how government can gain and maintain this information
- reaperducer 9y agoEach state has a DNA database and there is also and FBI DNA database. In California, the police can add you to the database (forcibly if needed) if you are arrested for a felony, or if you have a felony record and are arrested for a misdemeanor. Note that I used the word “arrested,” not “convicted.” SCOCal has ruled that a conviction is not needed. Just an arrest. All of this came about through two different voter referenda.
- jra_samba 9y agoHere is a useful link: https://customercare.23andme.com/hc/en-us/articles/212170688-Requesting-account-closure https://customercare.23andme.com/hc/en-us/articles/212170688... I just used both methods listed to request account closure and deletion of all my data. I suggest people do the same.