5 ms·
Don't forget "innocent until proven guilty". I want to know what DNA they got from the Golden State Killer, and how they know that it was his. The guy that th
by btilly 9y ago
Don't forget "innocent until proven guilty".
I want to know what DNA they got from the Golden State Killer, and how they know that it was his. The guy that they arrested was a police officer during the period where the killing was going on, in an era before DNA tests existed. Did they take DNA from a sample that was accidentally contaminated by a police officer at the scene, and conclude that the DNA belonged to said police officer?
- stevenwoo 9y agoIn the first press conference the Sacramento police chief said they had DNA evidence lying in stuff that was already in an evidence room that they did not realize until recently, the chief was an advocate for more genetic testing at the state level. The killer did not work for the Sacramento police, ever.
- maxerickson 9y agoYou think it is likely they arrested a cop based on a facile interpretation of the evidence?
- djrogers 9y agoA former cop, who was fired in 1979. Please try to be somewhat familiar with the facts before posting inflammatory speculation.
- gojomo 9y agoMy possibly-incomplete understanding is: * there was enough genetic evidence at several of the original crime scenes to establish one particular person was involved * after this suspect came to their attention, apparently via DNA on genealogy sites, they surveilled his home and collected additional 'left-behind' DNA – perhaps from his trash, or a haircut, etc? – to confirm a match with the older crime-scene evidence
- gwern 9y agoIt sounds like they had semen or saliva from an old rape kit which has been in storage for decades from a GSK rape victim (http://www.nj.com/data/2018/04/how_a_nj_pathologist_may_have_helped_solve_the_gol.html http://www.nj.com/data/2018/04/how_a_nj_pathologist_may_have...), they sequenced it, uploaded it to the genealogy website, got a hit on one of his relatives, investigated that person's relatives until they noticed one guy fit the GSK profile perfectly (law enforcement training, trouble with the law, right age and height, lived in the right place) and then staked him out until they got a discarded soda can or cigarette butt he tossed or which was in his garbage can (remember, if you put your garbage can out on the street, anyone is allowed to take it!), but the first sample was too degraded for a match and they had to get a second one, which then matched perfectly.
- tysonzni 9y agoAny guesses as to which genealogy website was used? All the services I'm aware of (23andme, Ancestry.com) require that each customer provide their saliva sample.
- andrewem 9y agoNote that some services will allow you to upload a spreadsheet of SNPs which you got from another testing service. If the police had access to a non-commercial lab, say a state-run lab in California which can sequence a similar set of SNPs, then they could upload the results to those sites. For instance, FamilyTreeDNA allows raw data uploads, as does MyHeritage, and the non-commercial site gedmatch.com. Edit: or of course they could have sent a saliva sample to one of the genealogy sites, assuming they had enough to part with some, and it was in suitable condition to work with the site's test equipment.
- gwern 9y ago> Edit: or of course they could have sent a saliva sample to one of the genealogy sites, assuming they had enough to part with some, and it was in suitable condition to work with the site's test equipment. That's unlikely without special arrangements. Have you ever done a 23andMe sample? The tube requires a lot of saliva. My understanding it's vastly more saliva than they need and the main reason is to make it impossible to surreptitiously collect enough saliva to genotype someone without their cooperation via 23andMe etc.
- gamblor956 9y agoHe raped nearly (or possibly more than) 50 women in an era before DNA analysis was a thing that criminals knew to plan for. He left samples on lots of clothes, bed furnishings, cups, bottles, etc. If even one of those samples was intact and survived to this day, it would be enough to match against. Such a match would be strong evidence of his role in the crimes, considering that he was never part of the investigative teams for any of these attacks.