3 ms·
I think the whole moderation thing is completely opaque. Last time I discussed this, and suggested some changes involving various "queues" and "waiting areas" f
by alkonaut 9y ago
I think the whole moderation thing is completely opaque. Last time I discussed this, and suggested some changes involving various "queues" and "waiting areas" for review etc - it turned out most of this already exists. There is a whole secret machinery behind the facade that somehow is hidden from users. I have been a user for years and never seen that. As far as I can see there are votes, close votes, and then questions just disappear.
When I see a poorly worded question, I might comment with some suggestions for improving the question, then immediately start writing an answer. Before I'm
done with the answer, it doesn't matter whether the asker had improved his question. It's probably already closed. That is to me one of the biggest issues, The "race" nature of Stackoverflow. Did you find an easily answerable but unanswered question? Don't write a good answer, write a quick one. Then maybe improve it. If your answer is the top one, you'll get upvotes forever. If it's the best one but stuck at the bottom - no upvotes. Same with questions. If your question was poor for 5 minutes, but is later fixed? Sorry. Closed. I just I don't get why the system wants to encourage someone to write the same question again, rather than improving one?
Worse, it seems moderators fall in this trap: it seems to be a rush to find things to moderate. They have so successfully gamified the notion of moderation and cleanup that it's now also a race. A suggestion: if there is any kind of point system, statistics, badges or anything like that - hide it from the mods themselves. It just shouldn't be gamified.
- marzell 9y agoOne of the biggest problems, if not the biggest, for people in tech (especially new CS students, etc) is knowing how to ask the right questions. There's several 'layers' of tech-speak that people learn (or not) to adopt, and many ways of asking essentially the same question. These practices of gatekeeping, being opaque, and failing to practice patience and interactive dialogue on SO are extremely frustrating, and cause the system to fail to support some of the people that most stand to benefit from the community. It creates an attitude of elitism, and while I see how these attitudes can be self-serving for the karma elites, and help create a perception of the community being concise and clean. But it leaves many people falling through the cracks, and when questions aren't answered within 3-5 replies, the threads are often locked, deleted, and otherwise 'swept under the carpet'. For this reason, I don't contribute to SO at all anymore. If it comes up as a result in a Google search when I need help with something, I'll use the info made available, but otherwise I'm intentionally just a leech because I don't feel it's worth navigating all the negative aspects in order to contribute. Edit: I do hope that the changes and attitude they've outlined in the OP blog post do help resolve a lot of what I've just described, and I do intend to re-evaluate my opinion after enough time has passed for real changes to manifest.