6 ms·
This makes me incredibly (to me) sad. The identity is so completely soulless, and the logo is the opposite of timeless, trying to grasp currently oh so hip and
by zokier 9y ago
This makes me incredibly (to me) sad. The identity is so completely soulless, and the logo is the opposite of timeless, trying to grasp currently oh so hip and pop retro aesthetic. Nevermind that the retro logo and super sleek modern visual identity seems to clash with each other, both are abandoning the playfulness that was so prevalent before, most clearly evident in the various Go gopher illustrations.
And its not that the designs here are bad in isolation; overall the visual identity is very sleek, and I could imagine it working well for something else; RedHat and JetBrains are the first things that come to mind. But for Go, this logo is the one that I acknowledge:
https://blog.golang.org/gopher/logo.png https://blog.golang.org/gopher/logo.png
Funny thing here is that I'm don't even like Go that much, and still I had such strong negative reaction to this branding.
- hashmal 9y ago> I could imagine it working well for something else this sums up why this new brand isn't good.
- wiremine 9y agoThis is true of ANY good logo before it gets traction. There's nothing special about the Apple logo (or Apple as the name of a corporate name), for example. I mean, seriously, it's a clip art apple with a bit out of it. What makes it a great logo is everything in your head and heart that is associated, good or bad, with that image.
- juliangoldsmith 9y agoI'd agree here. It's like they tried to make the new branding as generic as they possibly could. I liked the simple, basic site that Go has always used. It seems inevitable that they'll redo the site, to include megabytes of JavaScript for features that nobody wants, like hijacked scrolling. (The site[0] for the design agency they talk about loads about 3 MB. Almost none of it is images. The site loads all that to display approximately ten words.) Also, >The circular shape of the letters hints at the eyes of the Go gopher, creating a familiar shape and allowing the mark and the mascot to pair well together. If by "pairing well together", you mean not going together in any way, then yes. [0]: http://within.us/ http://within.us/
- FridgeSeal 9y agoJesus christ that site is bad. It's like they tried to tick every box in the "obnoxious and annoying" category: * It's inexplicably large * It's slow af * Scroll hijacking * back button hijacking * There's elements that appear when I scroll, but they disappear so you don't actually appear to be able to look them any more than in passing. (Notably the colourful logos for Google and Priceline). * Did I mention it's slow? Scrolling is slow. Clicking on things is slow. Animations are slow. * ~Half the code isn't even minified and a coworker pointed out that some of it doesn't appear to even be used.~ Nevermind, some of it does appear to be minified/resized. * 3.8+ Megabytes of JS, really? Really really? Why?
- bausshf 9y agoLet's all send angry emails to them
- Stratoscope 9y agoI like the part where dragging on my phone scrolls the page the opposite of the direction I'm dragging. I think this happens when I drag one direction, then change my mind and drag the other, and the site (sorry, "app") forgets to forget my previous drag.
- cozuya 9y agoIt doesn't even have a favicon!
- fermienrico 9y agoI am so utterly infuriated at their incompetence. How could they not see these obvious points? I hope they're reading because they ruined the face of an otherwise, very cool programming language project in our times.
- dingo_bat 9y agoI visited the website. It just shows a big W: https://kek.gg/i/78bwZ-.png https://kek.gg/i/78bwZ-.png
- bostik 9y ago> The identity is so completely soulless, and the logo is the opposite of timeless So true. When I look at the new logo, it reminds me of Adidas in the 1980s.
- mattwoodnyc 9y agounrelated to this thread... but Adidas had plenty of soul in the 80s. RunDMC wrote an anthem specifically about the brand [0], which completely changed the Hip Hop's relationship w/ commerce. [0] — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=virlWcB_G-E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=virlWcB_G-E
- hellcow 9y agoThe proposal makes me sad as well. As someone who uses Go everyday -- professionally and personally -- Go's branding was always simple and fun, which (to me) was reflected in the language itself. The new proposal is trendy, but Go was never about being trendy -- Go as a language explicitly rejects so many trendy features from other languages. Go to me is simple, fast, fun, and doesn't change a whole lot (a very good thing). Most of the Gophers I know, myself included, are a little weird and different -- in a good way. So was the branding. I liked that... and I'm going to miss that.
- signal11 9y agoLook at it this way, Google's making a commercial statement with this, that they think Go is important enough for them to brand. It's like Duke and Java -- Duke still exists as a mascot. I suspect the gopher will be around for a long time to come. If anything this is a harbinger of Go becoming more mainstream than it is already (think TIOBE top-10).
- dsl 9y agoNo, this all started with an email to UX/design of "I want a professionally designed slide deck for this talk I am giving" and they sent it off to an agency. There is no way self respecting Googlers were involved in this shit show.
- pjmlp 9y agoSomehow I think that the coffee cup is better than running letters.
- Zyst 9y agoI didn't even know Go had a logo, so long as they aren't touching the Gopher I honestly don't care.
- dmd 9y agoBut they are. That's what this is about.
- aikinai 9y agoThey're not; there's a model sheet for the gopher in the brand guide.
- vram22 9y agoYa, same here. To me, the gopher was the logo - I didn't even know if they had a separate logo or not, and never bothered. I mean, when you have one like the gopher, why do you need anything else?
- niij 9y ago>But for Go, this logo is the one that I acknowledge: > https://blog.golang.org/gopher/logo.png https://blog.golang.org/gopher/logo.png Check the link again. They pulled the rug out from under you.
- mseepgood 9y agoThe link still refers to the old logo for me.
- djur 9y agoI think you might have been confused by the fact that the new logo is basically just a polished-up version of the original one. Were you expecting the gopher at that URL?
- niij 9y ago>Were you expecting the gopher at that URL Yes, I was expecting the gopher, especially because of the URL's path including the word gopher. Looking at the wayback machine shows you're right, this is the same picture that's been at that URL for years. I just always thought of the gopher as their logo, didn't realize there was another logo they used (I don't use Go so not too familiar with it).
- masonic 9y agothe logo is the opposite of timeless, trying to grasp currently oh so hip and pop retro aesthetic I'd have expected to see that logo on the e-bikes scattered across the neighborhood.
- jknoepfler 9y agoThe logo is awful. - it ham-fistedly plays on the name Go (look, the logo is "going"...) - it is not opinionated (it conforms seamlessly to contemporary corporate logo design, it looks like stock art) - it does not repay sustained attention Go is a brutalist language. Clean lines, no frills, lots of power, close enough to the metal. I want monotype, exposed beams and concrete, RTFM, no ugly movement lines. I would actually rather they had taken a photo of the word "Go" written in concrete. And honestly, I don't care about any of these things, it's just window dressing on a very solid programming tool. It's frustrating when the miss is that obvious, though. Whoever pushed this through was clearly very risk averse, rushed, or both.
- slg 9y agoThe logo also appears to have lifted several elements from the podcast Jordan, Jesse, Go [1]. The font is almost identical. It has the white text on almost the exact same shade of blue. It has the three lines trailing part of the logo. EDIT: Here [2] are the two logos side by side. The number of similarities would make this one hell of a coincidence. [1] - http://www.maximumfun.org/shows/jordan-jesse-go http://www.maximumfun.org/shows/jordan-jesse-go [2] - https://i.imgur.com/0KkdFR1.png https://i.imgur.com/0KkdFR1.png
- mygo 9y agoI don’t think there’s enough evidence that they’re inspired by each other. movement lines aren’t original. they’re a classic visual archetype, commonly used to convey movement in static images. they exist in every comic book ever printed. Sans-serif fonts in all caps consisting of two circular letters “G”and “O” can look similar, depending on who’s looking no car
- slg 9y ago>they’re inspired by each other. That is unfortunate phrasing. The Jordan, Jesse, Go logo has been used for roughly a decade and the podcast is older than the Go language. There is only one possible direction that any inspiration could have flowed. Any one or two of these specific details can be explained away, but at a certain point the number of coincidence start to indicate that they are not in fact coincidences.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Lev1a 9y agoYour first paragraph immediately reminded me of the logo/CI transition for one of Germany's largest hospital operators, "Helios" (subsidiary of Fresenius): "old" logo (easily recognizable as a medical institution, easily discernible "H" for "Helios"): http://www.medical-network-hessen.de/images/News/Helios_Kliniken.png http://www.medical-network-hessen.de/images/News/Helios_Klin... "new" logo ("H" not clearly discernable in the two green blobs, no reference to medicine at all): https://www.helios-gesundheit.de/fileadmin/_processed_/d/4/csm_Helios_Logo_136cd733ff.jpg https://www.helios-gesundheit.de/fileadmin/_processed_/d/4/c... All in all, from quite good to meh.
- mcgreevy 9y ago> "H" not clearly discernable in the two green blobs, no reference to medicine at all I've never seen either of these logos before, but in the new one I immediately see the "H" formed by the white space between the two "green blobs", which to me look like "healing hands" and which I take as a medical reference (although TBH they do make me think "chiropractor" rather than "doctor"). I don't think the new one is great, but I much prefer it to the old one, which looks like a very half-assed attempt to combine an H with the Rod of Asclepius. It's like they weren't even trying.
- Lev1a 9y agoWhat I meant to say is that the old one is a logo that (without any text or anything) practically screams "hospital"/"medical institution" to anyone looking at it for the first time, while the new one is rather ambiguous, especially if you have no context for it.
- vanderZwan 9y agoRelevant: golang-nuts mailing list discussion from 2011 where someone claimed the logo lacked "professionalism" and was thoroughly mocked for it (including by a younger, more juvenile yours truly). https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/golang-nuts/JZ-gUROfB5A https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/golang-nuts/JZ-gUROf...
- vram22 9y agoGopher mascot and no logo was fine. I do see - I cannot call it a trend, but multiple individual instances - of companies going from a better logo / brand image to a sometimes worse one (this is purely subjective opinion on my part, of course, not based on any objective criteria at all). Another example is Google's current logo of the company name. I don't find it attractive - flat and sort of dull. But the one they had earlier for a long time, was attractive, the colors sort of seemed to gleam or sparkle, and the overall effect was pleasing, even though the colors were the sort of primary colors you find in the kindergarten. Note: All this said just as a guy who has no UI design expertise at all, just speaking as a layman to that field.