2 ms·
This is normal. In http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674537514 http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674537514 it is appropriately call
by btilly 9y ago
This is normal. In http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674537514 http://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674537514 it is appropriately called the exploitation of the large by the small. That book is short and a classic. It is worth reading by anyone who is interested in these matters.
The underlying reason is that most of the time, most are only motivated to put out significant effort for their own personal gain. Which means that in public goods, only if they believe that they will make the difference. Therefore public goods tend to fall into one of the following buckets:
1. A single individual or group supplies it out of self-interest and everyone else is a free rider. (This is the exploitation of the large by the small.) A good example is how most of the world lets the USA play global policeman and, despite complaints, contributes little to the effort.
2. A small group provides the good with complex negotiations where each tries to do as little as possible. A fun example is the infighting within OPEC as it tries to keep oil prices high.
3. A large group that is formed for some other purpose and is coercive in nature provides the good. Most government action falls into this category.
4. The public good fails to be provided. Examples are too numerous to bother listing.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoThank you for the recommendation. The weakness in the privacy fight is not only the size of the corporate coalition, but it's correlation. They're all in the same industry. When one weakens, the others tend to as well. What does Dr. Olson recommend in terms of broadening coalitions?
- btilly 9y agoThe weakness in the privacy fight is not only the size of the corporate coalition, but it's correlation. The weakness that you identify above is that individual citizens aren't jumping into it. We are willing to sit back and let large companies to deal with it. Anyways if you want to create results, find a reason for people to be part of the your organization that is not tied to the goal, and then use the organization for the goal. As a concrete example he used AAA, which people belong to because they want various services that AAA offers, and then can use their money and position to advocate for things like better roads.
- confounded 9y agoI find these sorts of theories by US economists (that game theory is how humans think, all humans are lonely, distrustful, little 'value' hoarders) little more than telling introspections. They're approximately as scientific as evolutionary psychology. In the context of privacy, how would 1, 2 or 3 explain the FSF, the EFF, or Wikipedia? Does the selection explain things better than people wanting them to exist because they inherently believe that public goods are good, and they want to make a better world for everyone? (Even if such a belief is 'irrational' and thus game-theoretically impossible.)
- jccooper 9y agoThey do not need to be explained under the parent's rubric, because that's describing the provision of public goods by large organizations. FSF, EFF, and Wikipedia are small organizations and operate differently. Which the linked book covers. Even in its precis, had you bothered to click through.