3 ms·
11.5km at 70kph is 10 minutes. That's on the aggressive side (but plausible) for peak-hours frequency of the most popular bus routes in the top 5 American citie
by closeparen 9y ago
11.5km at 70kph is 10 minutes. That's on the aggressive side (but plausible) for peak-hours frequency of the most popular bus routes in the top 5 American cities for public transit. Just to break even with car traffic. That was my point.
60m following distance is quite optimistic, the bus's stops count for something, and the only way you're getting 150 people on a bus is with the majority as standees, so you're comparing luxury living-room couches to a sardine can, and the sardine can isn't even doing that well on capacity.
I agree that in a theoretical universe with i.e. 2-minute bus headways, the bus wins hands down, but I'm not optimistic that any American BRT project will even try for better than 15.
- yostrovs 9y agoPlus the public's usage of public transit is going down. Americans are, for whatever reasons, not interested in public transport unless they're forced to use it. And they don't like to be forced.
- closeparen 9y agoIt's not actually clear that this is a lack of interest. Socioeconomically disadvantaged urban populations had the highest rates of transit usage, and resurgent upper-middle-class interest in cities means those populations are displaced to cheaper pastures that don't necessarily have usable transit. It could actually be the case that the gentrifiers are deliberately increasing their transit utilization from zero (just not enough to make up for the loss due to displacement), and displaced populations still want to be transit users, but can't afford areas with good transit anymore.
- yostrovs 9y agoMaybe. In my experience, simply the idea of getting on a bus frightens average Americans. The train seems less scary. So for those that have the freedom to make the choice, the bus is not the choice they make. And trains are rare save for a few cities.
- closeparen 9y agoRegardless of the role fear/classism play, the average speed for American bus systems is in the vicinity of a brisk walk, and that's while you're in motion. Throw in a 15 minute headway and it becomes a hilariously poor option to someone who has alternatives.
- wbl 9y agoFixable issues. You'ld be shocked to know the Model T was less reliable than a horse.
- jakecopp 9y agoThey're not interested in bad public transport. Why catch a bus when it is caught in the same traffic as a car? When a bus is faster than a car, including the last mile time - hopefully people will make the rational choice. This is why I think dedicated bus lanes are important - they are a cheap and cost effective method of increasing transport ridership and also increasing throughput.
- yostrovs 9y agoIf you add the cost of the ticket and the money the city spends on buses, they are cost effective only in a few places in America. Moreover, given the choice I estimate 90% of Americans will choose the car where they have privacy, safety, their radio and not someone's speakerphone, and smells that they like. Plus, having lived in big cities and used public transport at night, I always felt lucky to be a male in those situations.
- cimmanom 9y agoSay what? The busiest bus lines in NY run a bus every 2-3 min during rush hours. Many of the streets with bus lanes are ones where multiple lines run. My pet peeve is Livingston St. in Brooklyn, where 5 different bus lines temporarily converge. At rush hour it's common to see 2-3 buses (each one standing room only) with every traffic light cycle (so every 90 sec or so; a bus every 30 sec). The bus lane is completely unenforced - double parking in the bus lane and general traffic lane is more common than bus lane enforcement. Enforcing it would not only quadruple the commute speed for the hundreds of people per minute on buses, it would also speed up traffic for everyone who has to wait behind buses stopping for passengers; but god forbid placard holders obey the rules that apply to their placards. Oh, and if you tried to replace those buses with individual cars, even at 4 people per car, it'd take about 2 blocks worth of cars bumper to bumper for each bus. They would not only not fit on the street, they'd stretch for miles down neighboring Flatbush, even if Flatbush weren't already bumper to bumper itself. The solution to traffic congestion is moving more people per vehicle. Transit does that. The more efficient transit is, the more people take it. You add a bus lane and enforce it, people start taking the bus more. Then it makes economic sense to run more buses to keep those lanes even busier.
- closeparen 9y ago>The busiest bus lines in NY run a bus every 2-3 min during rush hours. Hmm. I double-checked; the lines I've depended on in Chicago and San Francisco get to 9-minute frequency at best. I guess this is another axis on which New York destroys the competition.
- organsnyder 9y agoMy mid-sized city of 200k has buses that run at 6-7 minute peak frequency. 10 minutes is table stakes for any decent-sized transit system.
- Steltek 9y agoYou're optimizing for pure "throughput", which is a good start, but the bus may win on "latency" as well. The bus will make the moving journey faster than cars waiting in traffic. You could argue time spent at the start/end however. Walking to/from the bus stop or finding/paying for parking. From my experience, my downtown walk from transit to work is very short, on the order of a few minutes. There are also larger societal reasons to support transit over cars, even if the math doesn't immediately work out: 1. It's healthier for people ("active" transportation) 2. A functioning transit system will attract more ridership and a bus lane is scalable in exactly the way you pointed out. 3. It's environmentally friendly, locally (smog) and globally (carbon) 4. It's safer for society. Car crashes are a significant cause of death.
- closeparen 9y ago>2. A functioning transit system will attract more ridership and a bus lane is scalable in exactly the way you pointed out. If transit planners actually took increased ridership as a reason to increase service, that might be relevant. As it stands, the revenue from crush-loaded commuter routes in my area is spent on any and all political priorities (concessions to labor, subsidized fares for favored groups, running highly frequent empty buses where no one wants them) other than the popular routes themselves.