4 ms·
Harass maybe. Coerce, I don't really see that. There's a fairly wide gap between being a massive dick and outright criminality. I have no trouble imagining that
by pvg 16y ago
Harass maybe. Coerce, I don't really see that. There's a fairly wide gap between being a massive dick and outright criminality. I have no trouble imagining that an ambitious prosecutor might find something to hang on him but I was wondering what 'textbook case', shoved-into-back-of-a-police-cruiser crime cperciva was seeing here.
- jacquesm 16y agoJust a list of stuff that seems to be confirmed: - reading private communications of people he knew in real life - retrieving IM conversations and publicizing them without consent or knowledge of the user - re-inserting himself in contact lists after being removed to stop the harassment - seeking real life contact with people whose private information he had retrieved Let's hope there wasn't more. Each and every one of those would be a firing offense, the fact that this is beyond just snooping and led to irl contact between this guy and the people (kids?) he was stalking means the situation is more than out of control. Mistakes happen, but such a series is not a mistake any more. A position of such trust requires a more than ethical behavior and good oversight. Google failed in the second. A good sysadmin has 'sysadmin blindness', even when you're looking at user data to do your job, you are not going to read the emails that sit in those inboxes unless you are specifically directed to do so by the owner of the data. For the rest those files might as well contain random bits. That is why I got angry with PG in this thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1278617 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1278617
- pvg 16y agoAgain, behaviour that's outrageous and reprehensible is not necessarily criminal. I am well aware he did some pretty nasty stuff. I'm not talking about any of the things you're bringing up - I just found it interesting someone saw the this as an obvious crime worthy of immediate arrest. So I asked why. That's all.
- Xurinos 16y agoDoesn't some of that stuff fall along the lines of stalking? If the term "authorized" can be defined properly in this context, isn't there a branch of cybercrime that deals with "unauthorized" access to or use of information? Is it possible for the victims to use DMCA here? Finally, in that his victims were minors, are there extra protections afforded them, especially with the violation of the intent for users of the service to block? How about trespass? Some of what this guy did is akin to forceful entry into your house in order to press his agenda, whatever it is. I am not a lawyer, but I can imagine at least asking for someone to look within these categories. I would personally feel very violated if I had some stranger even commenting about an email that was not directed towards them ... and even more violated if that stranger manipulated the system to get beyond whatever walls I threw up.
- btilly 16y agoI fully agree with you. I further wouldn't mind laws covering it. But I'm not sure there are any laws in the USA that do cover it. If not then the legal issues that are available are that he can be fired. Which he was. (Edit: Note that I work at Google as an SRE. This limits how much I can say in this discussion.)
- ErrantX 16y agoTry and find a prosecutor to bring the charges. This is the huge problem we are still facing with computer crime; because the law is still quite vague and unresolved. Juries have a tendency to not really "get" what has happened and so figure it's not all that bad etc. It seems rotten but the best chance you would have with this is in getting the Jury excited about the stalking aspect and the contact with children. Technically he has broken the law (at least, I think he has). Proving it though, along with mens rea (intent) is an absolute minefield and it would be torn apart by a decent lawyer. This is why most computer criminals are currently prosecuted for other crimes (in this case, probably the stalking offences).
- jacquesm 16y agoThat might be problematic but there is no indication at all that google did anything to even contact the justice department, let alone that they filed charges.