4 ms·
Thanks for that. I submitted this because, although environmental issues come up here relatively often (the collapse of civilisation will, of course, affect tec
by CalRobert 9y ago
Thanks for that. I submitted this because, although environmental issues come up here relatively often (the collapse of civilisation will, of course, affect tech), I have seen very little with regards to the long-term consequences of our anemic approach to the situation (even the Paris accord is like a band-aid on a shotgun wound). It was nice, for the most depressing value of "nice", to see someone who has shown prescience to just come out and say that there is not much reason to think that we'll get out of this one with an intact civilisation, and to address that Teslas and reusable grocery bags aren't going to fix this. I also thought the mention of focusing on music and love and the things that used to mark a well-lived life as opposed to greater economic extraction might be the best approach.
We've been taking out loans from the atmosphere for a couple centuries without too much trouble, but nature is eventually consistent.
- dredmorbius 9y agoI've been looking into the question for some years. The "doomer" literature (not all of it is inherently dismal) is ... far more substantial and substantive than is generally credited. That is not, however, what he's generally remembered for, that would be cost-benefit analysis E.J. Mishan is an example I've only just discovered. He was a University of Chicago trained economist who questioned the growth mantra beginning in the 1950s. Leonard Silk, also an economist, ran a fascinating column in The New York Times from the 1960s - 1980s, and addressed Mishan several articles. This one, from 1972, I'd submited to HN without traction a few days back: "Economic Analysis: Dangers of Growth (1972)" https://www.nytimes.com/1972/12/20/archives/growth-vs-environment-anxiety-on-dangers-undermining-faith-in.html https://www.nytimes.com/1972/12/20/archives/growth-vs-enviro...
- ealhad 9y ago> the collapse of civilisation will, of course, affect tech I've been wondering about that for a few months. I am fully aware that the current organisation of the world will come to an end in like, ten to fifteen years; is it wise for me to continue working with computers, which I love, hoping they will still be of some use after the collapse of civilisation?
- dredmorbius 9y agoAs far as vantage sites to observe what's occuring, it's not a bad one. Some skills are transferrable, if you consider them well. Timing societal collapse is even more fraught than timing the market.