4 ms·
> Would you say that Americans would more readily pick up Danish? Or Finnish? Or Latvian? Or Polish? I would say that Americans (and people in general) are mor
by kbenson 9y ago
> Would you say that Americans would more readily pick up Danish? Or Finnish? Or Latvian? Or Polish?
I would say that Americans (and people in general) are more likely to attempt taking up those languages, if given a fairly equal choice between them and others that also require learning a new alphabet. For the same reason (although on a lesser scale) that they might shy away from Chinese or Japanese.
It's one more hurdle.
- kwoff 9y agoIn terms of hurdles, of those four I think Danish is a clear winner there. Finnish is "ah, hell no" as far I know. :) In terms of usefulness, I'm not sure - maybe Polish. (That seems quite complicated grammatically, like other Slavic languages.) Chinese, if you don't care about writing it, is simple grammatically (though a few concepts are hard to wrap your head around).
- _delirium 9y agoDanish is "ah, hell no" if you want to try speaking it out loud...
- Fins 9y agoAre you saying that "people in general" == "people whose native alphabet is Latin-based"?
- kbenson 9y agoEh, sort of. I kind of got mixed up between the point of saying "I think people in general are more likely to attempt a language with less obvious initial hurdles given a relatively equal set of benefits from learning them (to their understanding)" and a statement about those languages in particular that follows along those lines. So, for your proposed equivalence, I think my original statement is true, and I also think the more general statement above is likely true in a wider sense.
- Fins 9y agoApart from relative usefulness of different languages (Latin script based Kazakh would probably be considered less generally useful than Chinese, say). Initial attempt maybe. But I think very soon most people will find out that if you are coming from an Indo-European background, Kazakh or Finnish, regardless of script used, is far more foreign than Russian or German.
- kbenson 9y agoSure, but the catch-22 is that most people won't have a good idea how to assess the difficulty of learning a language until they've tried, and it seems different people have different difficulties with the process. From the outside at the beginning, the different alphabet seems like quite a big deal. Thats how it feels to me at least when I think about learning another language. It's a data point of one, but I don't think I'm that unique in this.
- Fins 9y agoI'm not sure if most people start learning languages just because they seem "easy" either. There has to be some reason. And once you do start, something like differences between analytic and synthetic languages probably would be more of a tripping point.