3 ms·
There is nothing altruistic about commercial shipping, it typically serves the needs of consumers. They could just as easily choose not to consume as they choo
by rootusrootus 9y ago
There is nothing altruistic about commercial shipping, it typically serves the needs of consumers. They could just as easily choose not to consume as they choose not to take a sightseeing trip from points A to B. It is most sensible to charge road users based on the wear and tear they cause to the road, and this means trucks would get charged quite a lot. Good. It's a business, and the cost of those roads absolutely should be communicated back to the wallet of the consumer benefiting from the ability to quickly ship product.
- ryandrake 9y agoCharge by a multiple of the number of unoccupied seats in the car. 2 seater with 1 person? 1x fee. SUV that seats 7 with one person? 6x fee. Motorcycle is free!
- rootusrootus 9y agoI am not entirely comfortable with that. There are legitimate reasons someone may be driving a larger vehicle by themselves, and what you suggest seems a lot like trying to make it a moral punishment, assuming that everyone who has unoccupied seats is unnecessarily luxurious. Ultimately I like the idea of using weight. We have weigh-in-motion scales already, and the relationship between weight and road damage is well understood.
- quotemstr 9y agoThe price is there to reduce congestion, not road damage per se. You want to charge by congestion causes, which is probably proportional to vehicle size, not weight. More broadly, trying to figure out a priori what is and is not useful for society is pointless. Moralizing economic decisions never works. Just charge people for the costs they incur and the optimally beneficial configuration will emerge on its own.
- jrs235 9y agoThe overhead and transaction costs to calculate and collect the tax can't be overly burdensome. Once a year, at tab renewal time, the vehicle should be brought in for an odometer reading and the miles put one over the previous year should then be multiplied by it's weight or maximum rated hauling weight (or some formula using both) to determine the amount of tax owed.
- im3w1l 9y agoWith multiple people in the car you get to split the cost.