3 ms·
I think this is an example of real versus expressed preferences: I’ve known a bunch of libertarians who would when thinking about the issue say all roads should
by acdha 9y ago
I think this is an example of real versus expressed preferences: I’ve known a bunch of libertarians who would when thinking about the issue say all roads should be toll roads but at all other times act as if they should be taxpayer funded, complain that their taxes are way too high and should pay for plenty of roads, talk like construction prices shouldn’t have gone up since 1960, etc. Their unconscious way of thinking about it was basically the same as everyone else, and I think that’s in part because like everyone else they didn’t really want to pay every time they drive somewhere.
- pdonis 9y agoOne can be a libertarian in the sense of believing that the optimal system would be privately owned roads with each road owner being able to set pricing appropriately for their road, while also believing that, since such a system is not going to magically come into existence in an instant, there is still potential value to be gained by trying to improve the current system. Or, to put it somewhat differently: our current system is basically that governments own the roads. Well, if they own the roads, then they should take responsibility for properly managing them--which includes making sure the people who use the roads are aware of their real costs, and also making sure that those costs are reasonable. If I'm paying taxes to the owner of the roads in my area for years, while seeing no maintenance at all being done on those roads, I have a right to complain even if I don't think the government owning the roads is optimal to begin with.
- acdha 9y agoI understand that, it's just that I've heard plenty of “the {city,state} should make my commute better” rants and no calls to, say, charter a toll company that I can remember. Come to think about it, I've also heard more complaints that existing tolls are too high than calls to create more toll roads. At some point it's natural to wonder whether this is something they find ideologically necessary but don't actually want.