4 ms·
For city planners, there's a natural hierarchy of roads: limited-access freeways, arterials, collectors, and residential streets. Moving high volumes of cars is
by jcranmer 9y ago
For city planners, there's a natural hierarchy of roads: limited-access freeways, arterials, collectors, and residential streets. Moving high volumes of cars is intended to use arterials and freeways, whereas collectors and residential streets are deliberately designed for lower speeds as they may have a higher likelihood of pedestrians randomly entering the street (the child racing after his ball, to use the proverbial example).
In a nutshell, the problem with Waze is that it encourages drivers to shift from arterials to collector roads, where they very often proceed to drive in flagrant violation of safety standards. Getting drivers to not do that is challenging (and this problem predates Waze). Speed bumps don't meaningfully slow people down. Even prohibiting the through movement in a T intersection by means of an island doesn't work--people will happily drive over the curb to do so. By routing people down roads that are not designed for this traffic, Waze is pretty close to being complicit in these safety violations.
The proximate cause of this furor is that there is a street in LA that is too steep to be safe for through traffic, yet Waze is happily routing people along the street. Waze's response is, effectively, it's legal for through traffic, so Waze doesn't have to do anything, with the underlying reasoning being that it doesn't want to have to deal with everyone demanding special treatment.
Waze's attitude is, quite frankly, irresponsible. What they could do--and should be doing--is to look at potential factors that impact safety and update they app to not route people on roads that are clearly unsafe (Google's maps already have the ability to report grade on roads, for example). In fact, that's what the LA council is basically doing: they're looking to see if Waze could be doing more, and in the likely case they find that Waze is indeed not doing enough, finding some mechanism to compel Waze to do more.
The other element in play here is a complete about congestion. The truth is... you can't fix congestion. In transportation theory, there's an element called induced demand: if travel time improves in a corridor, then that induces people to take extra trips, often returning it fairly quickly to the same level of congestion. What many cities have realized is that trying to provide sufficient road capacity to meet demand is a game lost before they've even begun, and instead focused their efforts on trying to coax better utilization of current corridors (single-occupant vehicles on roads are basically the lowest-throughput transportation measures devised, except for Elon Musk's proposals which somehow manage to be even worse).
- galdosdi 9y ago> For city planners, there's a natural hierarchy of roads: limited-access freeways, arterials, collectors, and residential streets No it is not natural. it was invented half a century ago and maybe that hierarchy is a mistake. It creates artificial segregation between places that are geometrically near each other, especially for non-motor modes of transport and for short trips. And it creates natural hub chokepoints at every merge onto a bigger road. I'm a big fan of the Manhattan approach -- just have a big ass grid with much less distinction between so many hierarchies. Bonus points if you make one axis have one ways with "green wave" traffic light timings (this means in low to medium congestion, a driver never hits any red lights! Like a freeway, but mad cheap) The nice thing about a real grid is it is insanely resilient. There is a capacity to absorb a huge amount of thoroighput and route around huge amounts of temporary blockage, even if latency isn't great (at least in a high demand place like Manhattan -- in a more modest town it could make traffic insanely fast if one way green waves are used). Eg If 41st street is blocked, 39th and 43rd work, and if those are clogged, so does 37th and 45th, etc. BTW the fact that there is a linearly increasing cost to using a parallel street is a feature not a bug; it dampens induced demand while still making the capacity available in proportion to its actual demand. Just adding more lanes to a single freeway is not as effective for this reason. I think artificially forcing traffic into scale free graphs with chokepoints every place you switch hierarxhy levels may have been quite a mistake. Those chokepoints are always clogged.
- chongli 9y agoGrids are bad. They encourage traffic. They turn everything into a snarl. Look at Manhattan, it's a disaster! A scale-free network makes through-traffic impossible in residential areas. That is a good thing. People don't want commuters constantly driving by when their kids are out playing. The goal of a road network is to connect everything, not to guarantee a shortest path from every point to every other point.
- ghaff 9y agoI'm not sure the grid is the problem. More like the number of vehicles that want to get from point A to point B. Manhattan is indeed horrible to drive in at locations/times when the roads are very congested. But I've also driven in plenty of sparsely-traveled grids where traffic isn't bad at all.