3 ms·
If you are going to pick just one, English is a pretty good choice, because there are few places you can go where absolutely nobody speaks it.
by emodendroket 9y ago
If you are going to pick just one, English is a pretty good choice, because there are few places you can go where absolutely nobody speaks it.
- jacquesm 9y agoYou typically do not get to pick the language of the place you are born in.
- emodendroket 9y agoIt is a figure of speech. Surely you did not think I was confused on this point.
- jacquesm 9y agoGGGP wrote that they spoke only one language, that implies that this is their mother tongue. So as soon as you 'pick one language' you are talking about two languages, your birth tongue and another one. This was not the case with the comment I replied to so either you are off-topic or you really are confused. So I guess you are off-topic then rather than confused?
- emodendroket 9y agoIn a hypothetical situation where you were given the choice of any language on Earth as your native language before being born, [insert the rest of my comment here]. I hope this helps.
- jsgo 9y agoThe GGGGP (who you’re talking to) asked the GGGGGP if a country having a Latin based alphabet would really be easier for a non-speaker than another alphabet (in this case Cyrillic). I stated I only speak English for context (I can get by with Spanish and a middling amount of French, but neither at a level where I’d say proficient) as to why, yes, I would personally find a Latin based alphabet easier to search for words than one where the glyphs are very different as being able to locate said words helps with the stresses of traveling in a foreign area. If anything, I’d say the initial statement of the limited nature of speaking a single language was off-topic. True, yes, on topic, not so sure.
- amaccuish 9y agoActually it's more common than you think. I've lived in Russia, Germany and France, each with varying levels of proficiency in English. Many people know basic English but not much more. If you're not a tourist then it's more likely than not that someone you meet has a low level of English.
- emodendroket 9y agoI've never been to Europe but I have spent time in Asia. It is certainly true that not everyone speaks English and some people may speak English only at a rudimentary level -- but how many languages give you the ability to expect even that? I'd bet that English is also very near the top, if not at the top, of the list of languages used to conduct conversations where neither speaker is native.
- Mediterraneo10 9y ago> there are few places you can go where absolutely nobody speaks it. I can only assume you have never been to francophone or lusaphone Africa or many Latin American countries. Yes, if you search you might be able to find an intelligentsia that can manage some English, but the majority of people you meet will expect to communicate in French, Spanish or Portuguese.
- emodendroket 9y agoI'm not talking about having a discussion on the finer points of Melville here. I personally have some familiarity with Spanish and French and anyway haven't ever traveled to Africa.
- Mediterraneo10 9y ago> I'm not talking about having a discussion on the finer points of Melville here. No, seriously, the level of English in those countries is sometimes so low that you won’t even be able to obtain the most rudimentary things. In francophone Africa, even French is sometimes limited only to the upper classes. (In Madagascar, for instance, French disappears as soon as you leave the capital city and people generally speak solely Malagasy from then on.) Only a person who hasn’t actually traveled on every continent will believe that English (or even other languages) is widely enough spoken now to always get by. There is a reason that that "point to the picture" phrase book is still published and loads of travelers swear by it.
- emodendroket 9y agoAlright, man, you got me. I've never traveled around rural Madagascar. I think you can appreciate the point, though, which is that no other language has the same kind of reach English does. Even Africa, as a whole, has many fluent speakers of English (including many native ones).
- disordinary 9y agoYou'd think that, but it's not true. Or, people learn it at school which is quite different from being able to convey even basic conversation in it. With a language if you don't use it you forget it.
- emodendroket 9y agoThere is a good chance whoever you find will have halting, stilted, or limited English. But that's a little different than the situation you'd encounter if you tried, for instance, speaking Japanese outside of Japan.
- disordinary 9y agoMaybe in the cities, but it can still take time and you're often in the street trying to find someone to act as a translator, disrupting their day. It's a completely different proposition if you're somewhere rural.
- emodendroket 9y agoI mean, sure, that's true.
- skissane 9y agoAs an English speaker, one problem with learning another language is that there isn't an obvious choice of which other language to learn. Whereas, if you are from a non-English speaking background, then English seems the most obvious choice of language to learn in today's world. I think that is worse here in Australia than in some other parts of the English-speaking world. I mean, in Canada, the obvious choice is French; in parts of the US it is probably Spanish. There is no obvious choice in Australia.
- rangibaby 9y agoChinese, Japanese, or Malay?
- skissane 9y agoThat's still three choices, how does one choose which one? Back in the 1980s, Japan was having a major economic boom, and it was thought that everyone should learn Japanese. Since then, the Japanese economy has been rather sluggish, and now people don't think that so much any more. China is booming, so now people think they should learn Chinese instead. (Although, I think learning Japanese is easier for native English-speakers than learning Chinese–no tones to worry about.)