18 ms·
Electric scooter “mayhem” sounds like when cars were introduced
- analogmemory 9y agoMy only problem with scooters is the assholes who ride on the sidewalk and then run into you. I could care less if they want to ride in the street without a helmet. Good luck with that.
- coatmatter 9y agoThere's a bit of research that suggests helmets can encourage risk compensation and have people traveling faster. For a glimpse into a possible dire future, Australia and New Zealand are one of the very few countries in the world with mandatory bicycle helmet laws - the results have been dire. (See also the helmet law debate - there's probably not enough room in this thread to go into all of that.) But yes, arseholes are arseholes wherever they might be. It's not limited to people on smaller lower-powered wheels.
- notaki 9y agoI'm all for having more scooters parked on sidewalks and less Uber/Lyft vehicles blocking bike Lanes and adding to downtown traffic. The scooters are much needed, obviously. But, as usual, the media and city are crying about it and all you read in the news is "scooter mayhem" like this is the scooter apocalypse. Find something else to write and worry about, Jesus.
- closeparen 9y agoScooters going painfully slow in bike lanes will not be terribly different from cars stopping in them. Either way, you have to merge into traffic to pass.
- coatmatter 9y agoI bet that in places such a Utrecht and Groningen, scooters are much less in vogue since the default option available to both young and old is the bicycle. This is another case of Silicon Valley looking at using more tech to solve a societal and political problem. However, unlike Tesla/Uber/Waymo et al, it's a little more grounded.
- closeparen 9y agoOne of the main uses cases for these scooters is to connect to Caltrain, which doesn't have anywhere close to 1:1 bike racks:seats.
- notaki 9y agoNot much different? A car is about 10x the width of the scooter. And bike lanes in the city are wide enough to allow passing within the bike lane if the slower traffic stays on one side. https://twitter.com/BrentToderian/status/626511830261760000 https://twitter.com/BrentToderian/status/626511830261760000
- Tiktaalik 9y ago> Today’s startups are promoting their products by following the same playbook as cars: get them on the street, and figure out how to regulate them afterward. > But cities are moving quicker this time. Austin and San Francisco have seized dozens of them. San Francisco has sent a cease and desist letter (paywall) to one company decrying the scooters as a “public nuisance” and “endangering public health and safety.” Good. It's a shame that we weren't able to do the same with cars before they ruined North American cities.
- lolc 9y agoThe sad thing is that cars have had priority for so long it's hard to even imagine how it could be different. Now the scooters may boost the meager advances of bicycles.
- walshemj 9y agoYou know that horse's and horse riding are highly risky sports and also came with health risk's - the amount of horse poop in London as it grew was a major health issue. A parked car doesn't suddenly get spooked and lash out with its hooves does it.
- s0rce 9y agoWhile true, cars and horses aren't the only options. Trains, buses, bicycles, scooters, etc. also don't spook, take up less space, can reduce pollution and increase capacity.
- vaughanb 9y agoHorse manure was considered a serious risk in NYC. The banana skin (and the inevitable slip that followed) was a euphemism for slipping on horse manure in the street.
- justboxing 9y agoThese Electric Scooters in San Francisco have become a total nuisance. I've seen quite a few riders ride them on the sidewalks and 1 person even ran into a dude on a wheelchair who was trying to get onto the sidewalk after crossing the road on his wheelchair. The last safe place for Pedestrians and disabled persons -- the Sidewalk -- is under attack. The startups that have created this nuisance also park these scooters on the sidewalk, and it routinely blocks disabled people on wheelchairs from travelling safely on the sidewalk.
- str33t_punk 9y agoThe sidewalk in San Francisco is already not a safe place. Everyone is looking down at their phones. If they aren't, it seems like a large amount of SF residents don't know how to walk on sidewalks appropriately (stick to one side of the road when someone is coming the other way, don't walk 6 abreast, etc.). I have seen so many people bump into each other and get into accidents simply walking. I wouldn't mind scooters on the sidewalk because then people will actually be forced to be aware, instead of walking around like mindless zombies staring at their phone and bumping into poles
- Blaine0002 9y agoI can't agree with you more. No one is aware of anyone around them on the sidewalks of San Francisco. I've seen people pacing back and forth on the phone on the corner of a busy foot intersection not caring that they are a nuicense. Most others are buried in their phone and don't notice you until they see your feet. God forbid it's raining and everyone's walking around with beach umbrellas that take up the entire sidewalk and don't give a shit who's eyes they poke out. huff
- coatmatter 9y agohttps://thebaffler.com/latest/whos-afraid-petextrian-fraade https://thebaffler.com/latest/whos-afraid-petextrian-fraade "Petextrians" bumping into each other isn't anywhere near as dangerous as motorists with easy access to heavy vehicles driving near sidewalks.
- maherbeg 9y ago
- ryanobjc 9y agoI initially was bah humbugy about these scooters, but after reading an article that points out we have acres of space devoted to private automobiles, and that it really wouldn't be hard to accommodate these electric scooters, I changed my mind. They look fun, they seem more flexible than the hard-wired go-bike stations, and they don't seem super expensive. It's pretty obvious that our cities are broken, and SF needs help in particular. I've worked at companies that had to choose between being near bart or near caltrain to provide a shorter commute to different employees. The time it took to walk across soma was non-trivial and annoyed people. Ultimately the caltrain commuters used foot-powered scooters. As for the self righteousness of "only peds belong on sidewalks", I get tired of that. Being in traffic is exceedingly dangerous, and apparently as long as someone else's life on the line you're good with it. If "sidewalks" were a lot larger, then there would be more ability to mix traffic. See: the embarcadero. Let's work on our cities and have some fun doing it!
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoI have more sympathy for pedestrians. They go around 2-3mph. Auto traffic around 25-50. Bikes and scooters are way closer to cars than pedestrians. So, its a matter of risking the safety of cyclist, or pedestrians. No clear win there I can see.
- seanp2k2 9y agoSidewalks also have two-way traffic whereas the bike lane should be only one direction (which is also the direction of car traffic).
- randyrand 9y agowalking 3-4, scooter 10-15, cars 25-60. each is about 3x more than the previous. But it's a stupid comparison for safety. Colliding with a scooter will rarely be fatal, regardless of the 3x. But cyclist often get killed.
- seanp2k2 9y agoSee also: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/535/why-does-kinetic-energy-increase-quadratically-not-linearly-with-speed https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/535/why-does-kin... There's a LOT more energy being transferred into whatever the car hits both because it's going much faster and because it's much heavier.
- physcab 9y agoI hate these scooters with a passion. People litter them all over, I even saw one tossed into the street.
- gkoberger 9y agoI think that the people using the scooters and the people putting them in the street/garbage/water/trees are two different groups of people.
- coatmatter 9y agoI'd wager that a large proportion of those people who dump them like garbage are intoxicated. Perhaps it's alcohol that is the bigger problem?
- HenryBemis 9y agoI so very much disagree with the article. Someone with a car can kill 10 people and himself-herself. Someone with scooter will most likely die in an impact with most vehicles. It is most likely someone can break a leg, than have thousand deaths per year. But hey, humanity has proven common sense wrong befoe.
- xivzgrev 9y agoI think bird fucked up in SF by not giving clear-enough guidelines to their users (or not taking it seriously enough). People just need to treat these like a bike, basically. 1) ride in the street, not on the sidewalk. The only thing that should be on sidewalks are people walking and wheelchairs (disabled people walking). 2) park it next to an area where people expect bikes to be parked, like a bike rack or parking meter or street post. but not next to a fire hydrant, someone's home/garage, in the middle of the walkway, etc. I've seen all three of those.
- scrumbledober 9y agoThey make it incredibly clear through the app before you can unlock a scooter what the rules are. They have a very well designed and simple to follow few pages of rules you have to swipe through. The problem is enforcement. Who cares if the app tells you to not ride on the sidewalks if you've seen a hundred people doing it as they ride past police officers and don't get any tickets?
- woolvalley 9y agoReplace these scooters with bicycles and all of the same issues apply. Imagine if real self locking bicycles were somehow theft proof and private citizens started putting their bicycles willy nilly everywhere. That is the only new issue that is generated by these companies, and creating more parking for bikes and other low speed vehicles is the eventual solution. The fact that these dockless bike companies have effectively created the 'theft proof' bike is pretty amazing on it's own.
- seanp2k2 9y agoNot sure how much of it is that they're theft-proof vs anyone who wants to steal one either already has or doesn't care enough to do so. You could e.g. line the inside of a U-Haul with RF-blocking material and load up a ton of these, strip the radios in there, and sell them, but if you were to try this at a large enough scale it would likely be worth them going after you. If they lose a few here and there it's probably just cheaper and easier to move on. It looks like they're using either http://www.segway.com/products/consumer-lifestyle/es2-kickscooter http://www.segway.com/products/consumer-lifestyle/es2-kicksc... or https://www.amazon.com/Electric-long-range-Fold-n-Carry-Ultra-Lightweight-electric/dp/B076KKX4BC/ https://www.amazon.com/Electric-long-range-Fold-n-Carry-Ultr... for most of these companies. The resale value probably isn't great for beat-up rental ones, especially if they still have any of the company branding on them or have e.g. obviously ripped apart electronics (or both). Bicycles can be parted out if they're expensive, or re-sold on Craigslist very easily. Many less people are in the market for these things, so it's probably just not worth the risk + small expected profits to steal them.
- woolvalley 9y agoIt's 'theft proof' as in insurance. You don't have to worry about it being 'stolen' from you or damaged because your only responsible for it when your using it. It's not real theft & vandalism-proof, but it effectively is.
- zethraeus 9y agoThis article makes some throwaway concession to the 'far less dire consequences' but this is huge. These vehicles have far fewer negative externalities than cars. People don't die when they get hit by scooters and bikes. We can charge them with renewable energy. They don't take space from pedestrians as cars do. These are a huge clear good for cities. (And yes, people should gtfo the sidewalk, companies should educate as such, and there should be tickets for people who make others less safe.)
- bigtunacan 9y agoWhile the death toll is fairly low and declining, just to be clear, pedestrians do die from being stuck by cyclists. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.citylab.com/amp/article/381013/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.citylab.com/amp/article/381...
- cup-of-tea 9y agoThe article doesn't even talk about deaths, only injuries. Compared to the number of pedestrians killed by motor vehicles the figures seem insignificant. More people die each year from choking.
- bigtunacan 9y agoFirst paragraph from the article... "The recent death of Jill Tarlov, a pedestrian killed by a bicyclist in New York’s Central Park —the second such incident in two months—engendered a flurry of commentary and analysis of the dangers of cyclists determined to train for speed in one of the city’s most crowded recreational havens." It goes on to discuss that most deaths are due to head injuries.
- GoToRO 9y ago"train for speed" so it's not transport...
- michaelmrose 9y ago
- habosa 9y agoI've ridden a few of these. They're pretty fun and cheap. I actually like the model for trips in the 1mi range. In an ideal world full of well behaved people and good intentions I'd keep them around. But am I the only one that has a problem with the complete hubris shown by these companies. Raise $100M, buy thousands of $500 Chinese scooters, drop them on the city sidewalks and hope everyone just deals with it. Why can you disrupt life in a city just because you have a lot of VC money? What about when all the competitors come and we're drowning in low quality scooters? And let's not kid ourselves that these scooters will even remain loved. Right now they're unsustainability cheap and vulnerable. Bird and Spin are undoubtedly bleeding money. When they come back and triple the prices and change the model we'll see we've sold our sidewalks for nothing.
- randyrand 9y agoTheir profit margins are huge, though. I bought an electric scooter for $300 (Segway ES1). It costs near nothing to charge. These scooters make back their money in a mere 40 hours of use. A 1 week car rental would have to cost $35,000 to have the same profit margin.
- coatmatter 9y agoPeople who don't get around under their own steam (even if electrics are involved) don't see it the way you and I do. While they don't blink at the costs of car registration, fuel and maintenance cost (not to mention initial outlay), a few hundred dollars on a bicycle or scooter is seen as quite a leap of faith because they're unsure about whether they can adapt to fit it into their lives. Anglophone societies are very blinkered into thinking that car is king.
- kalleboo 9y agoI'm waiting for the first one to go up in flames
- rdiddly 9y agoSort of an empty comparison to the automobile. Similar in the fact that it's being thrown out into the world without a plan, and there's no space for them, and there's an outcry. Different because they're a lot less deadly. The proliferation of private automobiles is a net negative for the world, so if these scooters displace (i.e. take away space from) cars, they're good. If they displace, hassle or inconvenience pedestrians or cyclists in any way, they're bad. I don't hold out a lot of hope for them to change the world per se. I mean sheeeit, people trying to ride bikes at 15mph (which were the original reason for paving roads, no less) have been fighting for a space that's not filled with 40mph cars or 3mph walkers for years and getting mostly nowhere. To properly integrate scooters you would need basically a two-lane bike lane - one lane for bikes (10-25mph) and one for scooters (less than that, I assume). In a lot of places the automotive demographic has such a stranglehold on the polity, we can't even get a one-lane bike lane. The only way it would work is if they end up being ragingly popular... like maybe if something like 1/3 to 1/2 of all trips started being done by scooter, that would get the attention of the scooter-lane-planners. Though there is still the problem of "where does the capital come from?" when every municipality is seemingly always broke ever since 2008...
- woolvalley 9y agoElectric scooters go the same speed range of 10-25mph. All of these relatively new electric mini-vehicles go as fast or faster than a bicycle. For stability reasons the sweet spot is about 10-15mph, which is the speed of a typical bicycle rider. Bike riders should see them as allies in getting better bike infrastructure, because they are pretty much equivalent.
- scrumbledober 9y agoTo add to this, I bike commute in downtown SF and have been stuck behind slow cyclists many more times than I have been stuck behind electric scooters. On the flats I can hit a higher speed than them if I'm working hard just because I think their max speed is governed, but I don't think the average cyclist is capable of sustained 250W output for too long.
- 9y ago
- vaughanb 9y agoSurely a large part of the problem is thinking it's OK to leave the the hire scooters on public property wherever is convenient for the customer. Can't wait for the flying-vehicle startup. It's another tragedy of the common. BTW "sidewalks" are also known as "footpaths" and "roads" as "carriageways" in countries that speak British English.
- coatmatter 9y agoJust like "free" car parking, but to a much smaller scale.
- odammit 9y agoAre they the new modern moloch? If you don’t know about the terror of cars being introduced this 99pi episode is pretty good. https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/episode-76-the-modern-moloch/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/episode-76-the-modern...
- thejerz 9y agoPRESS RELEASE AS OF Apr 25, 2018@9:03:38 PM PT ~~~ Hello, My name is Nate Matherson, and my company runs The Student Loan Report. We created The Student Loan Report in 2016 as a source for news on the student loan industry, financial aid, and scholarships. At the time, we were building a marketplace for student loans, LendEDU, and felt we could contribute to the conversation. Especially because each of us had deep and personal experience finding student loans from trustworthy lenders. Personally, I graduated from college with over $50,000 in student loan debt. Today, I am still working to repay the majority of that debt. As we prepared to launch The Student Loan Report, we debated who should author it, and felt that it was really a blend of our personal experiences and perspectives that would create the best source material, so we created a pen name of “Drew Cloud,” and conceived a background that we felt personified a lot of the perseverance we hoped to inspire with The Student Loan Report. When we pictured what Drew Cloud looked like, we pictured a friend of ours from college, so we used his photo (with his permission) to round out the pen name. We used this character of “Drew Cloud” as the primary author of the site -- a shared pen name through which we could share experiences and information related to the challenges college students face while funding their education. There were also other pen names used to publish content on the site. The thoughts, stories, and opinions come from the actual experiences of our team. We have always held ourselves to high standards of content quality -- all of the data we published on The Student Loan Report was vetted, accurate, and licensed from the related polling companies. Now that you have that background, and now that I have been able to reflect on how we got here, I want to apologize for a couple things: (1) We never disclosed that “Drew Cloud” was a pen name that (represented a group of us writing these posts. I really regret that. (We are proud of our personal backgrounds and where they have brought (us today. We should’ve chosen to be clear about who was authoring the (posts. We have made a change on the site, effective immediately, to (use each author’s real name for every post. We will also (retroactively notate posts by Drew Cloud. (2) We have always worked to keep editorial separation between The (Student Loan Report and our other site, LendEDU.com, which is our (main business. However, there have been nine Student Loan Report (articles that mention LendEDU. We now realize that we should’ve had a (disclosure that the sites were owned by the same company. We are deeply sorry for any confusion or frustration our readers may feel. Please reach out to us at hello@studentloans.net with any questions or concerns about past content. Source: https://studentloans.net/ https://studentloans.net/ (homepage)
- jl2718 9y agoThe maximum deceleration of a vehicle is g times the tangent of the angle from the center of mass to the front wheel contact point. On a sidewalk, a safe stopping distance is about 1 meter. Because of the small angle, safe speed for scooters and skateboards is about the same as walking. Also, the small non-pneumatic wheels are easily stopped by cracks and small objects. They are far less safe than bicycles, which are excluded from sidewalks, and riding them on roads with vehicle traffic is suicidal. I guarantee that this will be born out by accident data soon. I’ve spent years of my life on the road by my own power, and I am certain that I would be dead many times over if I were on a scooter instead of a bicycle. When the streets of SF are wide open because the cars got kicked out, ride whatever you want. Until then, ride a bike. Ride a big long frame with steel-spoked wheels. E-bike if you must, and don’t mind me trying to keep up with you with an aging meat motor.
- coatmatter 9y ago> On a sidewalk, a safe stopping distance is about 1 meter. Because of the small angle, safe speed for scooters and skateboards is about the same as walking. The safe stopping distance depends on your line of sight around corners - if you're riding far enough from entrances and exits, at an appropriate pace, the stopping distance can be either greater or smaller provided you anticipate enough. > Also, the small non-pneumatic wheels are easily stopped by cracks and small objects. But much less so than normal kick scooters or skateboards. Skateboards are a worse in that regard, and scooters much better with the wheels being larger and in-line. > They are far less safe than bicycles, which are excluded from sidewalks, and riding them on roads with vehicle traffic is suicidal. I guarantee that this will be born out by accident data soon. It depends on whether you take them on a daredevil mountain descent at peak hour or not. If you want to look at the data, you might realise that while sidewalk riding in San Francisco is prohibited (but not well enforced, perhaps because police have better priorities), it is permitted in the states north, Oregon and Washington State. It's also permitted in many places around Australia - in fact, often times, where a shared path ends and a footpath begins is a blurred line. Where sidewalk/footpath riding is permitted, cyclists are largely as safe around pedestrians whether the pedestrian is on the footpath or the road. > I’ve spent years of my life on the road by my own power, and I am certain that I would be dead many times over if I were on a scooter instead of a bicycle. Many times over, only if you don't learn from the first instance. Not everyone proceeds forth with the same unchanged attitude after their first early mishap. > When the streets of SF are wide open because the cars got kicked out, ride whatever you want. Until then, ride a bike. Ride a big long frame with steel-spoked wheels. E-bike if you must, and don’t mind me trying to keep up with you with an aging meat motor. The best way to encourage rider uptake is to build the appropriate balanced infrastructure - that will mean taking away "free" on-stree car parking spaces along with other measures. America's experiment with "vehicular cycling" has long failed and people are simpy no longer riding, but instead spending more time on the sofas and chairs. That's the greatest health burden right now going forward. The electric scooters are a symptom of a larger problem, not the cause.
- kentbrew 9y agoI'm frankly amazed these things aren't instantly stripped for their batteries. How long does an unattended bicycle last in San Francisco? Minutes?
- seanp2k2 9y agoLonger than minutes. It's not NYC. I'm guessing that these companies just eat the loss for now.
- linkregister 9y agoWhat's the secondary market for batteries?
- lonk 9y agoIn this click bait only 6 short paragraphs are about scooters. Remanining 8 are about cars history.
- coatmatter 9y agoHere's better-written and more direct piece on the topic: http://haveago.city/disgraceful-dockless-drama/ http://haveago.city/disgraceful-dockless-drama/
- pkulak 9y agoNow we just need to start arresting people for jaywalking across the sidewalk.
- coatmatter 9y agoI'm not sure if this is a remark in jest, but here are a few good pieces on the topic of jaywalking: 1. https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/04/invention-jaywalking/1837/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/04/invention-jay... 2. https://usa.streetsblog.org/2017/09/11/where-jaywalking-is-not-a-crime/ https://usa.streetsblog.org/2017/09/11/where-jaywalking-is-n... 3. https://www.mnn.com/green-tech/transportation/blogs/on-a-sustainable-street-there-are-no-jaywalkers https://www.mnn.com/green-tech/transportation/blogs/on-a-sus...
- pkulak 9y agoAbsolutely jest.
- dayaz36 9y agoHow are scooters even a public hazard?? Governments just make up non-existent issues whenever there is an industry that they have no control over, then create laws that stifle innovation and create high barriers to entry by creating endless laws that will discourage other startups from entering. This is how oligopolies are created.
- dredmorbius 9y agoOn auto safety, the perception is that safety improvements came late, and improved dramatically at some particular point in time, though that is variously given: 1950s and safety belts (as they were called), 1960s and crash tests, 1970s and speed laaws, 1980s and airbags / ABS, etc. The truth is that on a miles-travelled basis, early gains were greatest, followed by a remarkably steady rate of halved risk roughly every 20 years, starting around 1925 and continuing to present. The chart below begins in 1921. I recall one I'd found previously dating to ~1910 showing an even more pronounced early decline, halving in ten years, before the 20-year trend was established. http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_otfwl2zc6Qc/TIp8lXB5h2I/AAAAAAAAOW8/fmXi_SCP-jw/s1600/highway2.jpg http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_otfwl2zc6Qc/TIp8lXB5h2I/AAAAAAAAOW... A lesson on seeveral grouds: perception/impressions vs. reality, the power of gradual improvement, diminishing returns, underappreciated early gains, and the power of standardisation, regulation, and liability. Which may also relate to the scooter debate.
- frgewut 9y agoThe only thing I don't understand is the renting - these things are meant for owning them. You can store scooter under desk in office or under bed in condo.