4 ms·
I don't think you can assume a constant rate for the speed of sound. Sorry, not trying to add new parameters, but the question is based on a real-world scenari
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
I don't think you can assume a constant rate for the speed of sound.
Sorry, not trying to add new parameters, but the question is based on a real-world scenario. So air density has to play a factor (although it's certainly fair to assume density changes evenly with altitude instead of the much more complicated real-world situation)
I would have brought up density, but it was one of the gotchas, and I was curious to see who spotted it first.
- btilly 16y agoWhen you allow variable air density, and variable speed of sound, the problem depends strongly on what assumptions you have made there. For example one complication is that if the plane is high in the sky at a 45 degree angle, even if it isn't moving it will sound like it is in a different place than it really is thanks to refraction. Those variants of the problem are much harder, and less interesting to me.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoWow. Didn't think of refraction. Wonder how much the delta in appearance and sound source for a high altitude jet is due to refraction?
- photon_off 16y agoWell, given that with non-variable air density altitude doesn't matter, it should seem that if air density [actually, temperature] did matter (that is, it caused the sound to travel slower), then the higher the altitude, the higher the "plane to speed of sound" ratio would be, and the higher the angle between hearing the plane and observing it. So, I'd answer with infinite altitude. Eventually, the plane would travel from horizon to horizon without the sound ever reaching you. Or, you're going to say that curvature is now a parameter, or the air temperature is some weird function of altitude, etc, etc.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoNo, I'm not just trying to over-complicate things for the sake of it. My first though was eye-level, then, after thinking about air density, it was infinity. But the problem with distance is that *as things get farther away, they appear to move slower". So although some pulsar in the crab nebula might be moving millions of miles an hour, and there is no sound, there is also no movement, therefore the angle of the sound source to the light source is nothing. No sound. So the only other (natural) constraint I would mention would be that the sound has to be able to reach the observer.