11 ms·
Something about Ethereum feels like a 19th century perpetual motion machine. "Ok, so the overbalanced wheels didn't quite work, but we'll add ball bearings and
by pavlov 9y ago
Something about Ethereum feels like a 19th century perpetual motion machine. "Ok, so the overbalanced wheels didn't quite work, but we'll add ball bearings and flowing water and gears and..."
In 1872, a man named John Keely demonstrated a machine that operated on what he called the "vaporic" or "etheric" force:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Ernst_Worrell_Keely https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Ernst_Worrell_Keely
The same year he raised 5 million dollars, equivalent to about $100M in today's money. Two years later he demonstrated a model that was described as a "hydro-pneumatic-pulsating-vacu-engine" with "quadruple negative harmonics". No doubt he'd be a blockchain entrepreneur today.
(Edit: Someone actually maintains a big wiki dedicated to Keely's "Sympathetic Vibratory Physics" and "Etheric Elements":
http://www.svpwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Sympathetic+Vibratory+Physics http://www.svpwiki.com/tiki-index.php?page=Sympathetic+Vibra...
Amazing that an investment fraud from 150 years ago is still producing "research"! A sobering reminder of the power of lies.)
- jessriedel 9y agoPerpetual motion machines are disfavored because they break a law of physics, not merely because they involve a stack of complicated mechanisms, each of which fixes a problem introduced by the mechanism below. If you've ever had a complicated medical problem, you know that very often you get drug A to counteract side effects of drug B, which was used treat an infection caused by procedure C which was a necessary precaution before performing treatment D to treat the underlying illness. Yes, sometimes such complicated mechanisms are obfuscating a doomed process, but other times engineering is just complicated. The Saturn V had a lot of interdependent parts too...
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoI would say the "Proof of Stake" they're planning to move towards also defies the law of physics.
- Hermel 9y agoIntuitively, I think "proof of stake" could violate Gödel's incompleteness theorems. These basically state that no complete system can proof its own correctness. And that's exactly what "proof of stake" tries to do: proof its correctness without external anchor of truth. Of course, Vitalik Buterin knows that so he resorted to "weak subjectivity", basically saying that if you are not online often enough, you need to trust someone with providing you check points to decide which fork is the "true" one.
- DSingularity 9y agoI do not find your explanation of the objective of PoS convincing. Maybe you are talking about their protocol that is true by construction? Proof of Stake strategy is to make it where attacks on the blockchain are impossible in the economic sense. Proof of work strategy is making the attack infeasible by making the work required impossibly large. Now is PoS possible? No idea. That possible fork attack seems like an impossible barrier to overcome. But we will see.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoHistory has shown us that humans don't always act economically or rationally. So nothing is impossible.
- profalseidol 9y agoIn PoS, it is a known assumption that if the majority of nodes act rationally, then so be it. This is an issue that is out of scope. Humans can be rational or irrational. That is how they are born. So far, we can only make tools and books to prevent irrationality.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoDo you think PoS is as safe as PoW when dealing with irrationality?
- snissn 9y agoIn what way?
- jessriedel 9y agoPossible. Progress will be made by sharpening that intuition into a mathematical proof or clean toy model exhibiting the failure, not by arguing from analogy.
- dragontamer 9y agoI dunno. Proof of Stake is simply codifying an old rule of economics: The rich get richer. You prove your stake and get more Ether out of the deal. A "Dividend" if you will. I don't think its very good for the cryptocoin community, but hey, I'm up to see the grand experiment unfold.
- ericb 9y agoI feel like proof of work reduces to proof of stake because the rich get richer, there's just an intermediate step of buying miners with your dividend.
- tuesdayrain 9y agoPoW is generally even less balanced than PoS, because poor people can't afford to take advantage of economies of scale with ultra-efficient mining farms. Meanwhile everyone will get the same % return in PoS.
- cocktailpeanuts 9y agoBoth are "rich get richer" schemes in the grand scheme of things, except that Bitcoin PoW started out as a completely open network which anyone could start mining from, so technically it's our own fault that we didn't realize the potential of Bitcoin in the early days and jumped onto Bitcoin. Otherwise we would be all billionaires. So I don't think it's the same. Just because you can label two things "Rich get Richer", doesn't mean they have precisely the same quality of "rich get richer scheme". Bitcoin PoW is completely capitalistic where people who mined to get their bitcoins deserve their wealth--they "worked" for their coins. So in Bitcoin it is true that "the rich get richer", but also "poor can get richer" too, as long as they started out mining early. This is not the case for PoS systems where bootstrapping PoS requires external capital, so this one is truly "Rich get Richer" in a sense that ONLY the rich can get richer. That said, talking about this "fairness" is totally missing the point. As I mentioned, in the grand scheme of things it's all "rich get richer" and that's how capitalism works. The truly important question is how immutable an stable the ledger is, because that's what makes these blockchain projects meaningful. If you ask anyone who has a thorough understanding of these technologies they would say PoW is superior to PoS in this sense. And Yes, this includes even the guys who are working on PoS blockchains. The only reason people bother with PoS is because PoW is having a hard time scaling and many people think maybe there may not even be an ultimate solution just with PoW.
- stjohnswarts 9y agoYou have to at least give him credit, he didn't use a car metaphor.
- deft 9y agoThe name isn't a coincidence. I kind of agree with you, there's a whole lot of words and invented terminology but not much is being said... however solving the problems DLT currently has is (hopefully) doable even if the "well let's add XYZ to the ABC!" approach fails.
- curyous 9y agoI agree, I don't think there's any clear evidence that they will eventually get Ethereum to work at scale. At one company I was with, there was an experimental project that only had "just one more thing to fix before it will work" for ten years, before being eventually abandoned.
- mikedouglas 9y agoFunny that you mention the 19th century, because another example of a system that required an ever-increasing series of hacks to solve major flaws is the internal combustion engine. Whether the problem that Ethereum solves is anywhere near as valuable as the problems solved by ICE remains to be seen, but this just seems like the engineering process to me, especially for a young technology.
- ajkjk 9y agoInternal combustions work, really well, today, and are not theoretically impossible. Not really the same.
- smallnamespace 9y agoWell, you haven't proven Ethereum's theoretical impossibility either. 'I think this might be a scam' is not a proof, no matter how many heuristics are on your side.
- tfha 9y agohttps://download.wpsoftware.net/bitcoin/pos.pdf https://download.wpsoftware.net/bitcoin/pos.pdf This paper does a pretty good job of laying out a formal, mathematical proof that pos doesn't work
- fastball 9y agoICE didn't work really well in 1910. Ethereum works today as well. I think you missed the point of the analogy.
- mikedouglas 9y agoThey work really well thanks to the invention of the spark plug, the carburetor, the supercharger, and decades of iteration. For many years, they were objectively terrible. Ethereum is three years old. ICE is 200+.
- beefield 9y ago
- aaron-lebo 9y agoYep. I've considered many times that Ethereum went down one path of evolution from Bitcoin, which is get more and more complicated. The problems with certain subsystems (the scripting language for example) have been discussed at length on HN, knowing how hard it is to modify complex systems that only get more complicated, I doubt they'll ever fix these issues, they'll be battling them indefinitely. That's a real problem considering you can never really trust Ethereum and the entire thing is predicated on trust. And what does all this complexity buy? Cryptokitties. We sure this is a worthy tradeoff? Would they Eth guys even be able to recognize this considering what's invested personally and monetarily? There's plenty of suckers, so I'm sure the "next year" kicking the can down the road cycle can go on as long as it's needed, but I'm interested to see if we ever get something of value out of it. The other evolutionary route interests me, but I'm too busy, lazy, ignorant, and disturbed by the entire space to test it out. Maybe some day.
- fastball 9y agoI guess you aren't familiar with MakerDAO and DAI. etheraffle.com also seems like a relatively good use case for a ÐApp. In fact there are thousands of good use cases. I don't think you're familiar enough with the space to be providing meaningful criticism. Your reductio ad absurdum to "just cryptokitties" is fairly telling.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoI've been observing the space since before Eth launched. If you believe that raffles are an example of useful systems, then we'll have to disagree. In fact there are thousands of good use cases. If there are, then we'll surely see them. You're providing more of what I'm talking about - it's always next year, always coming, but the mainstream adoption is nascent.
- mst 9y agoWhile I suspect that in the long run blockchains will absolutely end up finding some niches where they're persistently used, I do agree that a lot of the broader claims remind me a lot of "next year will be the year of linux on the desktop".
- Nition 9y agoGreat, if frustrating reading there. I love the linked news article interviews with Lieutenant E.L. Zalinski.[1][2] > Lieut, Zalenski's mirth interrupted him at this point. "Now," he resumed," when I started for Philadelphia I was careful to take with me a 10,000-pound gauge. That was my little equipment. This, as I suppose you know, or if you don't must take my word for it, is a standard instrument. Well, as soon as the Keely people saw this gauge they said to me, 'You had better not show it to Keely. It would only anger him!' Much I cared about angering him! I wanted justice. One of his partisans, however, informed Mr. Keely that I had brought this gauge with me, and the great man replied that he would not use it. In the course of his experiments he said he had got 50,000 pounds pressure. But—observe the but—he then remarked that he had broken all the pressure gauges he had. I then quietly rejoined that I had a pressure gauge which was only capable of registering 10,000 pounds. Said I, 'I would like to have you put it on, and break it for me.' Mr. Keely made no immediate reply to this. Shortly afterward, however, he remarked, with an air of feeble assertion, 'I do not believe in pressure gauges, anyhow.'" > The subject appeared to be excruciatingly funny to Liet. Zalenski. [1] https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1884/09/24/106158625.pdf https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1884/09/24/106... [2] https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1884/11/16/106166155.pdf https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1884/11/16/106...
- scrumper 9y agoThose are just brilliantly written, thank you. What a contrast in journalistic style to today! "And the energetic gentleman laughed in the same strain in which the cat was heard when she feelingly exclaimed, 'Hi, Hi! I have eaten the canary!'" "The 'etherealized vaporic force' which was so liberally poured into the ears of a large and gullible public..." I can't get enough. It's wonderful.
- asciimo 9y agoReminds me of that guy who pretends to be Satoshi Nakamoto: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/08/craig-wrights-proof-that-he-invented-bitcoin-fuck-off-im-not-going-to-jump-through-hoops/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/08/craig...
- kang 9y agoHaha, “Vitalik’s project immediately before Ethereum is that he was collecting investments from people to fund building a computer program to solve NP-complete problems in polynomial time, supposedly by simulating a quantum computer."
- drcode 9y agoHe was like 16 years old when he was working on that thing and has a solid track record since then... let's cut him a break.
- nope96 9y agoHe tried and failed to scam people when he was 16, but now has a successful scam so we should cut him a break? "solid track record" meaning cloning bitcoin and giving yourself and friends a bunch of free tokens worth $7,764,000,000: "12 Million Ether were created to the development fund, most of it going to early contributors and developers"
- kang 9y ago"solid track record" Can you name one thing he built/invented that does anything? Beyond collecting bitcoin.
- paulmd 9y agoSpeaking of which, Ethereum is not really novel either. Bitcoin includes its own VM which has opcodes that allow smart contracts too... just most of them are disabled because the reference implementation had bugs at the time Satoshi abandoned the project, and the development process is currently so calcified and politicized that development has essentially ground to a halt. The concept of memory-hardness is not really novel either, see: bcrypt/scrypt.
- lojack 9y agoVitalk was originally a bitcoin developer who proposed extending the op codes to make a more general purpose computer, and only started Ethereum after he encountered resistance to the idea. I don’t think anyone was claiming bitcoin wasn’t prior work.
- narrator 9y agoYeah, I looked at the original Ethereum spec and thought this thing isn't going to scale. Boy, did I miss out on making a lot of money. I still don't know what practical use people actually use Ethereum for besides as a currency and ICO scams.
- asciimo 9y agoThere's a decentralized Twitter clone that runs on the Ethereum blockchain. https://peepeth.com/welcome https://peepeth.com/welcome
- ENGNR 9y agoOne use case that's already operational and doesn't need additional transactions - distributed domain resolution The entire .eth registar runs in a smart contract. You put your ETH in to claim the domain, others also bid during the bidding period, the winners ETH is locked away and returned when they release the domain, the rest get refunded. Considering DNS is continually politicized and still subject to points of failure (the CAs), distributed ENS is a far better design IMO
- drcode 9y agoAs someone deeply involved in this community, I sort of agree about the "Rube Goldberg" feel of his ideas, but Vitalik et al have delivered pretty reliably: I think both ethereum and casper are pretty safe bets at this point (yes, I'll likely get some comments telling me I'm wrong and how horrible ethereum and casper are) The sharding stuff, however, is still iffy at the moment (I've studied it pretty closely) ...but if vitalik is confident he can make it work, I'll bet on v every time.
- nextos 9y agoEthereum is, so far, missing a key element for me to take it really seriously: Formal Methods. There are some small efforts, but I'd rather have formal methods from the beginning, not as an afterthought. The problem is that market forces favor releasing early rather than releasing correct things. It's the MIT vs NJ paradox again, or worse is better. But this time the potential risks are much bigger.
- drcode 9y agoWell it was a ton of work to get ethereum out the door... Adding a couple more years to formally prove everything first sounds like the perfect way to be stuck in development limbo forever. As you say, formal methods are being applied after the fact to some degree at least.
- nextos 9y agoI think it is a common misconception that formal methods will lead to an extremely slow development cycle. That is only the case if you go for the best guarantee of correctness: Theorem Proving. There are more agile options. For example, model checking all protocols is pretty easy in comparison to theorem proving. Still a significant effort, but perhaps an order of magnitude easier.
- rickycook 9y agowell, that would be tooling though. you wouldn’t say that x86 is missing formal methods therefor you shouldn’t use it right... solidity, etc sure maybe... but at that point, releasing early is probably a good thing so that you can get a whole community working on things and getting ideas and collaboration from a large group of people *edit: unless you mean like geth, or some minimal reference client should be formally proven
- nope96 9y ago> Something about Ethereum feels like a 19th century perpetual motion machine. Funny you'd say that: "Vitalik's project immediately before Ethereum is that he was collecting investments from people to fund building a computer program to solve NP-complete problems in polynomial time, supposedly by simulating a quantum computer." http://archive.is/8wHvq http://archive.is/8wHvq "Buterin later said he had “greatly overestimated” the likelihood of the team breaking mathematics" https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/buterins-quantum-quest/ https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/buterins-quantum-quest/ More: http://bitcoinerrorlog.com/2016/08/vitaliks-quantum-quest/ http://bitcoinerrorlog.com/2016/08/vitaliks-quantum-quest/
- ttul 9y agoAll sufficiently successful entrepreneurial “geniuses” are eventually shown to have been lucky for the most part. - Proverb
- DalasNoin 9y agoSimulating a quantum computer on a regular computer to speed up np-complete problems is insanity. Trying to break mathematics is insanity. I tried to verify your sources, it seems to go back to Gregory Maxwell and an anonymous source, BitcoinErrorLog. David Gerard cites BitcoinErrorLog. zero proof.
- nope96 9y agohttps://twitter.com/peterktodd/status/906189639802859520 https://twitter.com/peterktodd/status/906189639802859520 Jorge Timón was pitched it > Was he soliciting investment though? > Jorge Timón @timoncc Yes, he and another guy were claiming the classical computers simulating quantum would be a mining revolution.
- DalasNoin 9y agoi'm honestly trying to verify this. i'm quiet skeptical about the character of some developers of bitcoin, i dont know about peter todd. bitcoinerrorlog is linking to this video of him talking about quantum computers as a proof. this is the closest i have come to hard evidence of this extreme claim. i have listened to the first half of the video, just him talking about quantum computers. Very impressive talk for a 19 year old. https://youtu.be/DkUpZkeqhF4?t=16m46s https://youtu.be/DkUpZkeqhF4?t=16m46s
- tCfD 9y agoOr the epicycles of the heliocentric era, where the focus then as now was on futile ever finer retweaking of conclusions to fit unexamined and faulty premises.
- zodiac 9y agoI'm sorry, but I feel this is really lazy and nonconstructive criticism. Perpertual motion machines violate a law of physics, and the bells and whistles attached to it were at best misguided attempts that didn't address the fundamental issue, or at worst attempts to defraud investors. I can't tell what you are claiming here; is it that 1. Sharding is fundamentally impossible; in any public blockchain, all computers must validate all transactions, and the scalability trilemma cannot be avoided, or 2. Sharding is possible, but the solutions outlined in the FAQ are unnecessarily complicated; a much simpler solution exists You haven't provided arguments for either, and I can't even tell which argument you're making. On a higher level, I could agree with the general sentiment that complicated solutions tend to be wrong or at least very suboptimal, but only as a heuristic. It's a heuristic that doesn't even hold very well in this space; in the space of PoW fork-choice rules, bitcoin-style longest-chain is simpler than Somplinsky's GHOST rule (https://eprint.iacr.org/2013/881.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2013/881.pdf), which is in turn simpler than ethereum's current "modified GHOST", but in each case the added complications really were necessary and lead to better properties.
- pavlov 9y agoMore explicitly, my position is this: Ethereum's claims of an upcoming blockchain-powered "Web 3.0" revolution are so overblown that they're indistinguishable from perpetual motion peddlers. The Ethereum designers don't want to recant their outlandish promises, so they keep proposing increasingly complex bells-and-whistles fixes that sound impressive in a 10,000 word FAQ but won't bring the "global supercomputer" substantially any closer to reality.