2 ms·
Yes and no. The two comments leading up to my first comment was one suggesting that you could achieve a similar effect by simply closing a damn, followed by one
by vidarh 9y ago
Yes and no. The two comments leading up to my first comment was one suggesting that you could achieve a similar effect by simply closing a damn, followed by one implying that did not take power out of the grid. My first comment then stated:
> You are taking power off the grid: The power otherwise produced by the hydro plant.
>
> Of course with a lower reservoir, you can go into negative territory instead of "just" taking the plant down to 0.
In other words, my point from the beginning was that there is - absent transmissions limitations - no conceptual difference in the outcome of stopping a damn and pumping into a reservoir, as I've gone into at great length in the subsequent comments.