5 ms·
very concept of "shopping around" for healthcare is absurd No it's not. A very large percentage of medical care is planned, not urgent. There is no reason wh
by refurb 9y ago
very concept of "shopping around" for healthcare is absurd
No it's not. A very large percentage of medical care is planned, not urgent. There is no reason why price comparison can't happen for those.
A great example of a highly functional healthcare market is vision correction laser surgery. Every time I look around some deal is being offered. Competition is what drove those prices down.
Can you do that with everything? Of course not. But you can do it with a lot of planned medical care.
- andrewla 9y agoAnd it's not purely a race to the bottom; as expected price levels are achieved, it also becomes possible to read signals in the price, so that medical practitioners who are willing to do extra work (reduce wait times, better followup, home visits, etc.) can charge more to compensate for that, rather than just doing the minimum amount of work necessary in order to get the fixed payment.
- omegaworks 9y ago>No it's not. A very large percentage of medical care is planned, not urgent. And for those procedures, a hybrid system should suffice. All Americans, should, at minimum, be able to get urgent, surprise medical issues addressed in a way that doesn't completely destroy them financially. Of course, nothing is black and white. Issues that could have been treated in a planned way become urgent if they're left to fester. Obamacare started shifting the incentives to make preventative measures more palatable, and healthcare cost growth has come down as a result. ACA is a /conservative/ set of policies. Even still, it elicits extreme reactions from loud people on the fringes.
- bobwaycott 9y agoI’d suggest a slight addition: > All Americans should, at minimum, be able to get routine and urgent, surprise medical issues addressed in a way that doesn't completely destroy them financially. Elective procedures are obviously a thorny issue people will debate over where to draw the lines. But standard checkups, routine wellness procedures, and covering the unexpected ought to be the bare minimum—the healthcare floor of social decency beneath which we do not allow any member of society to fall without recognizing we are failing as a society.
- hsljekskfh 9y agolasik is a luxury surgery and as such is treated like an expensive toy. you really picked a misleading example. if i need a hip replacement i don’t want to “shop around.” if i have procedures every month like my parents i don’t want to “shop around.” i just want to be healthy.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>No it's not. A very large percentage of medical care is planned, not urgent. There is no reason why price comparison can't happen for those. The idea is that money shouldn't enter into the decision to have planned care at all. Let's say the price for a regular checkup goes from $200 to $100 (just an example). Okay but there are still people who will put off the checkup because of the cost. That shouldn't happen, people should just go to the doctor when they feel they need to, planned or unplanned. >A great example of a highly functional healthcare market is vision correction laser surgery. Every time I look around some deal is being offered. Competition is what drove those prices down. You mean LASIK? I mean besides the fact that you're falling for a markup-then-sale strategy there is a lot of contention around lasik surgeries - that they're misleadingly advertised, not that effective, bad side effects, etc. Heap a bunch of advertising on top that makes it hard for consumers to know the quality of what they're purchasing and you have basically all the hallmarks of bad un(der)regulated markets.
- refurb 9y agoThe idea is that money shouldn't enter into the decision to have planned care at all. Money always enters the decision, even in a single payer system. Someone decides what will and won't be paid for. Your example of preventative care isn't a good one, since every US insurer had to cover it at no copay. You mean LASIK? Yes I do. And I mean the fact that it went from several thousand dollars in cost to under $1000 in pretty short time due to competition. And of course consumers know what quality they are purchasing, any smart person would make the decision on more than just price.
- txcwpalpha 9y agoLasik eye surgery is a terrible example for you to pick for this. Lasik is notorious for being a market where laser clinics bought the machines when Lasik was a fad and were hoping demand would stay high, and are now having to resort to unscrupulous sales tactics to recoup their losses. Laser clinics give sales commission to their eye counselors as an incentive to get you to purchase Lasik even when you might not need it or it may not be best for you [1]. They have incentives to use deceptive marketing techniques to make you think that you need it and that it is affordable, even though the price you hear on the radio is almost never the actual price you will pay (they will tell you that the advertised price is only for some eyes, and that yours are more complicated and require more money). They will try to convince you that there are no side effects, despite an FDA study showing that 46% of people reported visual issues caused by Lasik, with 30% of all recipients stating that Lasik caused them to have chronic dry eye [2]. This is so commonplace that the FDA and FTC had to get involved to guide consumers about how to avoid these shady clinics and to tell these Lasik marketers to knock it off [3], [4]. I don't know about you, but I certainly don't think the 'marketplace' for procedures such as childbirths, biopsies, transplants, bone replacements, etc should look anything like the marketplace for Lasik does. 1: https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2001/09/04/lasik-surgery-sales-tactics-raise-eyebrows/b7b19fed-7b26-4ec1-b0c3-305996baca55/?utm_term=.7f96ba8d1814 https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/2001/09/04/l... 2: https://www.fda.gov/MedicalDevices/ProductsandMedicalProcedures/SurgeryandLifeSupport/LASIK/ucm190291.htm https://www.fda.gov/MedicalDevices/ProductsandMedicalProcedu... 3: https://www.fda.gov/MedicalDevices/ProductsandMedicalProcedures/SurgeryandLifeSupport/LASIK/ucm061354.htm https://www.fda.gov/MedicalDevices/ProductsandMedicalProcedu... 4: https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/marketing-refractive-eye-care-surgery-guidance-eye-care https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/mar...
- refurb 9y agoHow does that differ under a single payer system where a doctor might do surgery that isn't needed. The problem of bad actors exists whether you have a market or not.
- txcwpalpha 9y ago