4 ms·
Reading the court documents, the conclusion is that the guy is shady and the journalist and the newspaper are borderline lying. The correct headline is: "E-was
by lucio 8y ago
Reading the court documents, the conclusion is that the guy is shady and the journalist and the newspaper are borderline lying.
The correct headline is:
"E-waste recycler loses appeal on 28,000 counterfeit windows installation disks, must serve prison term"
>The sentencing judge determined that the appropriate infringement value was the value of the infringed discs to small registered refurbishers: $25. The court found credible the government expert’s testimony that he was able to use the infringing discs to install functioning Microsoft software
So there were 28,000 discs with Microsoft and Dell logos which can be used to to install functioning Microsoft software
That's a different picture than the one painted by the article.
>In particular, the court noted that it did not find it
reasonable to believe that Lundgren and his codefendant had spent at least around $80,000 to create discs that had no value. Using the $25 infringement amount, Lundgren’s guideline range was 37 to 46 months imprisonment. The court
sentenced Lundgren to 15-months imprisonment
https://www.courtlistener.com/pdf/2018/04/11/united_states_v._clifford_eric_lundgren.pdf https://www.courtlistener.com/pdf/2018/04/11/united_states_v...
Did the journalist read the court papers?
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> there were 28,000 discs with Microsoft and Dell logos which can be used to to install functioning Microsoft software I thought those discs could only “install functioning Microsoft software” if provided with a valid license key, a key Lundgren didn’t provide nor purport to provide. The “$25 infringement amount” seems like a bad comparison since those disks include a license key. Lundgren’s did not.
- criddell 8y agoEven without the key, the software is still copyrighted material.
- pas 8y agoIt seems, according to others' comments, that the "functioning MSFT software" is the Windows preinstall environment, that means people can start installing re-windows, but it still asks for a license. That said, I don't see what was the operation. How he created the disks, who are the customers, are there receipts, etc?
- csdreamer7 8y agoThis is one of the better comments here.