3 ms·
Honest questions for discussion: Assuming for the sake of argument that the current status quo is not an option, what would be the particular advantage you are
by jerf 9y ago
Honest questions for discussion: Assuming for the sake of argument that the current status quo is not an option, what would be the particular advantage you are seeking in creating such a structure rather than just having three states? (Obviously the status quo is an option, the default one in some sense, but since that probably dominates a rational conversation I'm discarding it to get somewhere interesting.)
Would it be advantageous for, say, Vermont and Rhode Island to create such a superstructure?
How would you address the question of redundancy? We've got a couple centuries now of the line between federal, state, and municipality to go off of, and since you're presumably not going to create more government powers through this mechanism, how do you propose redrawing the relevant powers in a way that makes sense?