5 ms·
Worried as I am about China's authoritarian practices and their growing influence, they sure are effective at solving environmental problems.
by _bxg1 9y ago
Worried as I am about China's authoritarian practices and their growing influence, they sure are effective at solving environmental problems.
- zaroth 9y agoYou may have missed this point in TFA; “China is ahead on electrifying its fleet because it has the world’s worst pollution problem. With a growing urban population and galloping energy demand, the nation’s legendary smogs were responsible for 1.6 million extra deaths in 2015, according to non-profit Berkeley Earth.” It’s great to celebrate progress, but don’t fall for the spin. A study published in Nature [1] found 3.3 million deaths per year worldwide attributed to air pollution. China owning nearly half that is mind blowing. The figure for the U.S., by comparison, is 60-80,000. In terms of per capita mortality rate, China’s polution problem is 5x more deadly. [2] Economics is the study of allocation of scarce resources. China investing more heavily in electrifying their buses is not surprising in the context of a deadly pollution epidemic. The same level of investment into electric buses in the US would be a tradgedy in the sense of actual lives lost due to gross misallocation of public funds. [1] - https://www.nature.com/articles/nature15371 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature15371 [2] - (1.6e6 / 1.3e9) / (8e4 / 3.2e8)
- m_mueller 9y agoIMO conflating air polution and greenhouse gases does not make a lot of sense. CO2 has the highest impact greenhouse gas, yet it has no adverse health effects in the concentrations humans are exposed to it. In terms of CO2 emissions per capita, China is AFAIK still below EU average and 3x below the US who is by far the worst offender among highly populated developed nations. Air pollution is a problem, yes, but a different one than combating human induced climate change.
- zaroth 9y agoI’m not sure where climate change enters the picture in this story. I don’t think China is investing in electric buses to reduce CO2 to head off climate change, but rather to control actual smog/air pollution.
- danans 9y ago> The same level of investment into electric buses in the US would be a tradgedy in the sense of actual lives lost due to gross misallocation of public funds. I get it that you don't like public investment in electric buses, but there is no evidence to suggest that such investment would cause any "actual lives lost", vs the other much bigger public budget items in the US. If anything, more people in buses would likely reduce a significant cause of deaths in the US: car accidents.
- zaroth 9y agoI have no issue at all with the appropriate level of investment in electric buses. Investment in public transit in general is besides the point. It’s economic fact that paying more for an electric bus and building the infrastructure to support them is more justifiable and will provide better ROI in China where the pollution is 5x more deadly. If your metric is spending dollars efficiently to save lives, there’s better ROI in the US by spending the money elsewhere.
- danans 9y ago> If your metric is spending dollars efficiently to save lives, there’s better ROI in the US by spending the money elsewhere. It's massively oversimplifying the trade-off to reduce it to a single metric, and it proposes a false choice. Why not also consider reducing congestion, reducing local-air-pollution related respiratory conditions, etc? And compared to the known types of huge government expenditures that might be doing actual harm to some subset of citizens (i.e. lives lost in wars of questionable value) why point the finger at electric buses?
- pjc50 9y ago> actual lives lost due to gross misallocation of public funds. The US already makes gross under-allocation of public funds with the result of lives lost, but since that relates to healthcare and homelessness it seems hard to get anyone to care.
- _bxg1 9y agoI'm not saying they have fewer environmental problems, I'm saying that when they decide to solve one they're able to just go all-in and get it done.
- jimmywanger 9y agoFor some things authoritarianism is very effective at achieving results. For instance, China's government simply mandated that everybody would start using a simplified writing system that was supposed to increase literacy. And the country.. just sort of went along with it. Also, iodizing salt is sort of a big deal. Turkmenistan, being a dictatorship, simply declared non-iodized salt illegal and gave out 11 pounds of iodized salt each year to each family, and (presumably) sent out inspectors with iodine testing kits and threats of fines. Kazakhstan, being a democracy, had to cajole its people into accepting the change. Same thing with China and India. China switched to a remarkably different writing system. I'm guessing that the process went something like "You guys have two years. After that all government forms and mass media will be written in the new system. The schools will all be teaching the new system." Whereas India, which would benefit greatly if they all spoke a mutually intelligible language, is a democracy and will never give up their ancestral languages.
- Mediterraneo10 9y ago> China switched to a remarkably different writing system. The simplified characters are not actually "remarkably different". In many cases, simplification just codified a large number of short forms of the traditional characters that were already being used by the people. Have you ever seen how Chinese actually write many common characters with a paper and pen? > For instance, China's government simply mandated that everybody would start using a simplified writing system that was supposed to increase literacy. Orthography reforms happen in non-authoritarian countries, too. After the fall of Communism, Romanian saw a change to its spelling rules. Spanish and German, too, have had changes in recent decades. Even under a democracy, language academies and the big publishers can have enough prestige to push changes.
- jimmywanger 9y ago> The simplified characters are not actually "remarkably different". You're incorrect. As a simple example look at the difference in the character horse between the two character systems. You might be able to sort of figure it out if you knew ahead of time what it meant. Just plopping a whole pile of text in front of you with no translation in the language you're familiar with is fairly incomprehensible. >Have you ever seen how Chinese actually write many common characters with a paper and pen? Yes, I have written some stuff in chinese and I have friends who write sloppily. The strokes are still suggested if not perfectly expressed. Have you any experience? > Orthography reforms happen in non-authoritarian countries, too. Although there since it's not enforced, you end up with a plurality of languages, like India. You can change any individual language but still have to support the old way.