3 ms·
> You consider two hours a limited window? To automate capturing traffic for any domain on the internet? Just as one example, you could initiate bank transfers
by acdha 9y ago
> You consider two hours a limited window? To automate capturing traffic for any domain on the internet? Just as one example, you could initiate bank transfers for everyone doing online banking at any bank. Malware sitting on desktops have been doing this instantly, automatically, using valid sessions from the client side, for like a decade. No reason they couldn't do this sitting in the middle.
Again, I'm not saying that this isn't a big deal but that you're really downplaying the level of effort required for the worst-case scenarios. Besides the average script kiddie not being likely to compromise an ISP to send the malicious announcements, your online banking scenario would only work for the people actively logging in during those two hours to banks which don't use IP fixing, out of band confirmation or other precautions to actually transfer money (every single financial institution I use has a period measured in days with human-on-phone verification to setup a new outbound transfer target); whose security staff don't check certificate transparency logs; and you'd have to develop the code to collect credentials and run the transfer for each bank, taking care to avoid triggering key-pinning and other high visibility errors.
Malware is similar: yes, it'd suck if you could get a valid HTTPS cert for someone's automatic update service but these days those certificates are pinned and most system use signed updates which would require a separate exploit to avoid.
One thing to remember is that this is coming after a decade of everyone responsible in the tech industry trying to protect against malicious state actors. This attack is what happens all the time to people in countries with repressive governments.