3 ms·
>The answer is not at all the one most people think at first when given this problem. The answer depends on the disease! If it's the common cold, it's probabl
by joshuamorton 9y ago
>The answer is not at all the one most people think at first when given this problem.
The answer depends on the disease!
If it's the common cold, it's probably close to 99%. If it's huntington's disease, the likelyhood is much lower. (when asked, this question is normally posed as "you are given a test, which is 99% accurate, for some rare and deadly disease", the "rare" part is important)
- sykh 9y agoSorry, you are correct. I'll update the problem.
- joshuamorton 9y agoI'll follow up by mentioning that even as you have it worded now, it's not precise enough to answer. You need to explicitly describe the false positive and negative rates separately. As is, a test that is just "return false" (100% false-negatives, 0% false-positives) will be 99% accurate, but gives no information, whereas a test with 1% false positive rate can have a 1% false negative rate and still be correct 99% of the time, and will provide much more information. Statistics is weird and unintuitive.
- sykh 9y agoI guess I should say that everyone takes the test. I'm not a statistician, I'm a mathematician. The way I understand the phrase, "the test is 99% accurate" is that this means: assuming everyone were to be tested then 99% of the time you get an accurate result. Thus .99(1%) = 0.99% of the people will correctly test positive and 0.01(99%) = 0.99% of the population will incorrectly test positive.
- beojan 9y agoThe problem still stands then.