3 ms·
GB and BG take up more area in probability space. If you have a thousand paths in front of you, one leading to a fortune, one to a potion and the rest to a pit
by jodrellblank 16y ago
GB and BG take up more area in probability space.
If you have a thousand paths in front of you, one leading to a fortune, one to a potion and the rest to a pit of death, you can't say the 998 paths are together equal to the other two just because they all end at the same place. It's much more likely you'll hit the pit of death.
It's much more likely to have boy/girl children even though BG and GB look the same at the end. You get as much probability current down each of the wires BG and GB you do down the GG and BB wires, making twice as much in total for BG/GB combined.
If there are four buildings, red, green, gray and gray, and you pick one at random you are more likely to end up in a gray building. You dont get to say there are three colours because I can class the two gray buildings as the same the chances are 1/3rd for each colour.
- thwarted 16y agoIf there are four buildings, red, green, gray and gray, and you pick one at random you are more likely to end up in a gray building. I guess that's where my confusion lies. I see that the chances of picking a grey building the above is 1/2, but I assert that the set of possibilities for the children is "two girls", "different genders" and "two boys". But yours is a good explanation, I see that that "different genders" state has a double chance of occurring compared to the other two states. The Wikipedia article I cited above is interesting in that in one explanation, it bases the different results on interpretation of the givens. I see the problem stated as about a specific man's state, not the chances that a randomly chosen man/family with two children has two boys. In my case, this was a misdirection in trying to understand this.