2 ms·
> I'd even be in favor of a means-tested phase-out of the UBI. This is a bad idea. A phase-out is indistinguishable from a tax in the same amount, but it harde
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> I'd even be in favor of a means-tested phase-out of the UBI.
This is a bad idea. A phase-out is indistinguishable from a tax in the same amount, but it harder to reason about and consequently tends to be implemented incoherently.
Suppose you have $10,000 basic income with a 20% phase-out rate and a progressive income tax with a 15% tax rate up to $50,000 and 25% thereafter. Then what you really have is a $10,000 UBI and an income tax of 35% up to $50,000 and 25% thereafter. Probably not what you wanted, right?
Much better to have a $10,000 UBI with no phase out and a flat 30% tax rate. Which has the added benefit of vastly simplifying the tax system -- no need for multiple rates and all the complexity and opportunities for tax avoidance that go with them.
- djrogers 9y agoYour phase-out and progressive taxation numbers don't work out for any logical application of the concept. A means-tested pahse-out of a UBI in a progressive tax scheme would reduce the UBI for earners only in the highest tax bracket, thus further increasing their tax rate. I would prefer a flat tax, with the UBI acting as the progressive mechanism while also being phased-out for high earners. Your assumptions in your response are really bizzarre...