3 ms·
I saw the book as relatively neutral on this point. Nell certainly is improved by it (though it could be easily read that this is largely due to Miranda), and
by aidenn0 9y ago
I saw the book as relatively neutral on this point. Nell certainly is improved by it (though it could be easily read that this is largely due to Miranda), and Elizabeth's malaise is easily explained by growing up in luxury, with an abusive teacher.
The YLIP is shown as something inferior to a true parent (Miranda being Nell's surrogate parent being pointed to as a big reason for her success), but better than nothing (it was a "best availabe" tool Dr X. provided for the orphans).
- Jtsummers 9y agoWasn't Elizabeth's tutor-actor different from day-to-day? (If I'm recalling my characters correctly.) And that was partly the explanation for how she turned out. While Nell's was a dedicated tutor-actor through the whole time.
- undersuit 9y agoNell's tutor started recognizing the job offers for the tutor lessons and choose to become the dedicated one.
- aidenn0 9y agoThis is true, and more support for the the book considering the Primers to not be insufficient replacement for an involved parent, which is an easy argument to make, but does not mean the book thinks they are bad.