3 ms·
That’s a cynical interpretation. The logic is that a newspaper article is an atomic unit. You can pick up a digitized NY Times article from 1890 and have the s
by Spooky23 9y ago
That’s a cynical interpretation.
The logic is that a newspaper article is an atomic unit. You can pick up a digitized NY Times article from 1890 and have the same facts (albeit without the same context) as a contemporary reader.
Linking to sources, even primary sources, encourages laziness on the part of the writer and an implicit expectation that the reader has that knowledge. As a layperson, I want a story, I don’t somebody directing me to read Supreme Court opinions.
Most internet focused reporting is sort of a hybrid of news magazine and TV. 99% of links are dead in five years. It’s one of the many ways that the disruption and destruction of newspapers is an objectively bad thing for society.
- Zak 9y agoA good hybrid approach would be to write as if there will be no links, but add them at the end.
- Nomentatus 9y agoIf you read science stories, you're going to need the link, very often. The chances that the writer has it exactly right are slim. But I'm off - to read the Supreme Court's view of early patent history.
- azernik 9y agoThe New York Times is in fact a counter-example; all their online articles link extensively to sources they refer to.
- cryptonector 9y agoIn the old paper world this makes sense, and anyways, printing links wouldn't be all that useful. It was "easy enough" in the olden days to just go to the local library and search for whatever was referenced. In the digital world, if it's link-rot you're worried about, then the paper could just, you know, _archive_ the linked documents and provide links to both, the original and the archived copies. Yes, there's a bit of a copyright law issue there, but it's manageable, and certainly legal opinions from U.S. courts are freely republishable.