4 ms·
Side note, a question often asked is why do guitarists players insist on tube amps? The answer from a lot of unscientific explanations is "warm tone" and "great
by exabrial 9y ago
Side note, a question often asked is why do guitarists players insist on tube amps? The answer from a lot of unscientific explanations is "warm tone" and "great timber" which is pretty unsatisfying. After going down the rabbit hole of designing and building my own HVDC guitar amp, I can assure you it's much more complicated! They do "sound better", but it's the way vacuum tubes modifying the signal is imperfect. The extremely simplified explanation is this: Any modification of the source signal during amplification is called distortion. It turns out some types of distortion sounds "pleasing" to the human ear. This is because the distortion can produce harmonic artifacts musically related to the fundamental note. This is what violin and sax players called "overtones" and gives those instruments their signature sound. Guitarists can use a tube amps cranked into distortion (either from the pick attack or from having it set too loud) to create overtones, aka the sound of rock and roll.
- VestingAxis 9y agoYes, you are correct, vacuum tube amps have higher levels of distortion (and noise in most cases) compared to solid state amps. For vacuum tube amps the characteristic curve of distortion is a quadratic function called the second harmonic (frequency double the original sound and an overtone factor produced by most musical instruments - eg. a stradivarius - that gives depth and richness to sound). Solid state amps on the other hand produce tertiary and quintic harmonics that are not as pleasing to hear (which is why they try to reduce distortion for solid state amps to zero).
- yellowapple 9y agoIt was my impression that vacuum tubes also tend to be more readily able to handle high voltages than transistors (whether absolutely or for a given price), which might also be a factor; the tube amp might just be able to pump out sound at a higher volume, which tends to be a big deal for live performances (especially outdoor performances with large crowds).
- exabrial 9y agoNot really :/ my tube guitar amp is 5w and has an EL84 output tube. The tube alone is $5-$20 and there's the transformer which can be $100 or more. A single MOSFET can do the same job for less than $1 and similar wattages without the transformer. You can get MOSFETs that'll switch 500v for under $2 as well. Check out the irf820, I issued it to drive an fx loop in my amp design. This changes at extreme power levels. There are few semiconductors that'll transmit in the thousands of watts. Tubes still are used in transmission technology for this reason.
- yellowapple 9y agoThe "extreme power levels" are what I was getting at, though I might've been mixing up voltage and wattage.
- exabrial 9y agoAh, makes sense. Actually audio engineering is a few years ahead of software engineering as far as architectures go. The similarities are uncanny. For a concert, its better to have 20-40 amplifiers rather than one big single point of failure (microservices vs mainframe). It's better to lose a few small parts than one big one. When it comes to distribution of source signals, the architectures live engineers are using with aes50/Midas or Dante are pretty danged cool. They just assume component failure is assured.