3 ms·
It's worth noting that Spolsky lost the "How do you move the turtle in LOGO" philosophical debate. [1] Atwood won and thus people get an excuse to treat people
by brudgers 9y ago
It's worth noting that Spolsky lost the "How do you move the turtle in LOGO" philosophical debate. [1] Atwood won and thus people get an excuse to treat people badly. Particularly relevant is that people get an excuse to treat new comers particularly badly. Sure, there's a scale at which aggressively closing questions is administratively necessary. [python] or [android] are at that scale. But the small corners of StackExchange are often dominated by Usenet behaviors because such behaviors are sanctioned from on high. Policies that encourage treating people badly are established by fix or sixteen votes on the related Meta site. And blessed in the moderator discussions as site wide policies based on the administrative needs of tags like [php] on StackOverflow.
A lot of StackExchange is similar to comp.lang.c did in the Usenet era. As in the days of the Usenet, They tolerate and encourage those behaviors. I think there's a critical lower bound and a maximum upper bound for the number of users. The topic has to be big enough that there is a steady stream of new questions and small enough that regulars talking among themselves is a meaningful percentage of the activity.
[1]: The discussion from 2009 in SO Podcast #58 (under the old numbering system): https://stackoverflow.blog/2009/06/18/podcast-58/ https://stackoverflow.blog/2009/06/18/podcast-58/
- Quarrelsome 9y agoThe question in question [1] was closed as "not a real question" and then further "locked". [1]: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1003841/how-do-i-move-the-turtle-in-logo https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1003841/how-do-i-move-th...
- brudgers 9y agoAs Spolsky describes in the recent article, the question was seen as problematic by Atwood because it didn't reflect enough research. Atwood even deleted it in 2011.[1] A moderator later restored for historical relevance. But the site's policies reflect a lot more of Atwood's personality than Spolsky's...most unfortunately. [1] See revision 16 https://stackoverflow.com/posts/1003841/revisions https://stackoverflow.com/posts/1003841/revisions