4 ms·

Are there other instances where I can demand people's time without compensation? Where I can demand they forget something all the way down to the fact someone v

Are there other instances where I can demand people's time without compensation? Where I can demand they forget something all the way down to the fact someone visited their location? I see this is as a move in the WOGPC.

ballenf 9y ago
Pressing the crosswalk button as a pedestrian and making traffic stop? In fact the law requires us to do many things for other people without compensation. Part of the give and take of living in society.
- jakeogh 9y ago
  Interesting counterexample, if you have more I would love to hear them. Where I live, I am required to render help if someone needs water etc. I like that law very much. Back to your example: In one case, I can press the button and then cross or not (I could stand there all day pressing the button). Without getting into local law, I bet that attack is illegal in most places, I suspect it is where I live. In the GDPR case, I can press every button in an entire union, apparently every 40 days. EDIT: regarding response times, I found a breakdown: https://www.burges-salmon.com/news-and-insight/legal-updates/gdpr-subject-access-requests/ https://www.burges-salmon.com/news-and-insight/legal-updates... Obviously this kinda-example ignores the point about forced forgetting which will be interesting in many ways; the astroturf market for example.
  - chopin 9y ago
    GDPR allows you to ask reasonably. Repeated attempts to overwhelm the target are not allowed.
  - xearl 9y ago
    > I can press every button in an entire union, apparently every 40 days. In most cases that will be considered "repetitive" and "excessive" - Art. 12 (5) - and businesses will be allowed to charge for fully responding to your "button presses".
    - jakeogh 9y ago
      Is it legal to ask every GDPR subject company? Is there a way to accomplish that? How often is it OK to ask (all of them)? This is similar outlawing free speech and then blaming everyone else for not doing the same because free speech keeps leaking back across your borders. Non-EU corporations will get the intel business, and that's a good thing. A demonstration of why sovereignty is important in the WOGPC.

ballenf 9y ago

Pressing the crosswalk button as a pedestrian and making traffic stop? In fact the law requires us to do many things for other people without compensation. Part of the give and take of living in society.

jakeogh 9y ago
Interesting counterexample, if you have more I would love to hear them. Where I live, I am required to render help if someone needs water etc. I like that law very much. Back to your example: In one case, I can press the button and then cross or not (I could stand there all day pressing the button). Without getting into local law, I bet that attack is illegal in most places, I suspect it is where I live. In the GDPR case, I can press every button in an entire union, apparently every 40 days. EDIT: regarding response times, I found a breakdown: https://www.burges-salmon.com/news-and-insight/legal-updates/gdpr-subject-access-requests/ https://www.burges-salmon.com/news-and-insight/legal-updates... Obviously this kinda-example ignores the point about forced forgetting which will be interesting in many ways; the astroturf market for example.
- chopin 9y ago
  GDPR allows you to ask reasonably. Repeated attempts to overwhelm the target are not allowed.
- xearl 9y ago
  > I can press every button in an entire union, apparently every 40 days. In most cases that will be considered "repetitive" and "excessive" - Art. 12 (5) - and businesses will be allowed to charge for fully responding to your "button presses".
  - jakeogh 9y ago
    Is it legal to ask every GDPR subject company? Is there a way to accomplish that? How often is it OK to ask (all of them)? This is similar outlawing free speech and then blaming everyone else for not doing the same because free speech keeps leaking back across your borders. Non-EU corporations will get the intel business, and that's a good thing. A demonstration of why sovereignty is important in the WOGPC.