2 ms·
I honestly can't think of any good reason today why someone who could hack would want an MBA. If you're concerned about learning, you will learn more about bus
by edw519 19y ago
I honestly can't think of any good reason today why someone who could hack would want an MBA.
If you're concerned about learning, you will learn more about business in one good hands on project than 2 years of formal education.
If you're concerned about having a mentor, you will meet infinitely more business saavy people in business than you ever will in school.
If you're concerned about money, 2 years of earning will put you hundreds of thousands of dollars ahead of 2 years of spending.
If you're concerned about what others think of your credentials, you're focusing on the wrong thing.
If you're concerned about climbing the corporate ladder more quickly, then fine. Get an MBA. What are you doing here?
And, most of all...
If you're concerned about making yourself the best you could be, then hack, hack, hack. You already excel at the weakest link in the business chain. You will get better by continuing to "do" in your specialty. More school will add little, cost you time, cost you money, but most of all, cost you experience doing what you already love and what the world needs most right now.
(Response to Bonus Question: One of the best post-graduate business programs for technical people is Carnegie Mellon. Ironically, they don't award an "MBA", but an "MSIA", Master of Science in Industrial Administration. Even they don't care for the MBA.)
- wheels 19y agoThis is quite inaccurate. There exist jobs for which the above are true, but not most. If you're concerned about learning... Sure, but it'll be completely different stuff. If you're concerned about having a mentor... Or not. Real leaders in the corporate world are rare. If you're concerned about money... Not really. If you've worked and then go back and got an MBA you come back at mid-management. I'm hardly a cheerleader for MBAs, but the stuff that you've written here is a little too typical, "hacker with a chip on his shoulder". I've seen a lot of people learn good stuff in MBA programs and I've seen more waste their time. It's not one size fits all.
- edw519 19y ago"This is quite inaccurate." Maybe for someone, but not for me. "it'll be completely different stuff" Exactly. That's my whole point. Some things I learned in my MBA program, like the time value of money, were at best, easily gleaned from dozens of books at Borders. Other things, like marketing strategies and case studies, were just wrong and counterproductive. Nothing valuable I ever learned on the job was even on the business school's radar. "Real leaders in the corporate world are rare." True. And much rarer in academia. "If you've worked and then go back and got an MBA you come back at mid-management." So what? Been there, done that. As an experienced hacker, I don't remember the last time I had a mid-manager who earned more than I do. They are easily expendible. I am on the critical path. "hacker with a chip on his shoulder" No, just one who loves what he does and has seen the light. If you can hack, don't make the same mistake I did. Forget the MBA and get better at hacking by hacking.
- ssharp 19y ago>>> If you're concerned about learning, you will learn more about business in one good hands on project than 2 years of formal education. That statement pretty much discredits everything you say. Have you run through an entire MBA program? This statement is unbelievably ignorant. As for CMU, they certainly do have an "MBA" program. Also, CMU is a 2nd tier B-School. It's still very good but not at the top of U.S. MBA programs.
- edw519 19y ago"pretty much discredits everything you say" How? Please provide some data to support this statement. Then I'll understand and perhaps, be better able to respond. I have my MBA, 86 hands-on IT projects, several management jobs, non-IT P & L responsibility, and have hacked tens of thousands of original programs, all in a business environment. I freely share my experience and assessment so that someone else might be able to take advantage of my mistakes. Don't like it? Fine. But when you say something like "This statement is unbelievably ignorant" with no supporting data, you add no value and make yourself look like the fool. If you disagree, say why. If you don't...</FlameResponse>.
- ssharp 19y agoSo take one random sample from one of your 86 "hands-on IT projects", and you're trying to tell me that you learned all the things that you would need to learn in a full-time 2 year MBA program? I just don't see how that is remotely possible. If you're just talking about random learning, then your statement doesn't really reply. I could spend two years reading Wikipedia and learn a lot more than I could in two years of full-time MBA study -- the problem is the quality not the quantity. Besides, a lot of the value of the MBA doesn't come directly from the curriculum but rather having in-depth case analysis with your professor and the other students. I find it pretty interesting that a lot of the values of the MBA and the decisions for firms to hire MBAs parallel a lot with how YC operates, yet YC is viewed as the holy entity and MBAs are viewed as hell spawns. The bulk of the value of YC doesn't come from the investment, it comes from the community, much like an MBA. The curriculum doesn't vary that much between a top school like Wharton or Chicago and your standard state school. The difference is the quality of the other students. And much like YC, firms hire MBAs on their abilities to learn and not what they've already learned. Don't get me wrong, the curriculum is very important and gives a very good general overview of every major operation in a corporation (operations, accounting, finance, marketing, IS, etc), but honestly, you COULD learn it all on your own. But that applies to just about anything. I could learn all the curriculum I would need for a CS PhD on my own if I wanted to as well...