6 ms·
Does anyone have an idea as to why the testicles weren't included in the transplant? My best guess is that the testosterone produced wouldn't be "compatible" w
by fastball 9y ago
Does anyone have an idea as to why the testicles weren't included in the transplant?
My best guess is that the testosterone produced wouldn't be "compatible" with the recipient and they would want to avoid an immune system rejection?
Additionally, I suppose that if sperm is still being produced, you could effectively impregnate a woman with someone else's DNA. That would be... strange. I can see how that might be unwanted by both parties.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThe article I read earlier specifically said there were ethical concerns with him potentially being able to father children with the donor's genetic code. Which is a weird ethical concern I'd be intrigued to read more about.
- badosu 9y agoThat creates an interesting twist: since DNA test is legally acceptable as fatherhood proof the recipient could create a lot of trouble for the donor.
- fastball 9y agoI'd assume that the donor in every case (as in this case) would be diseased, so I'm not certain how that could be an issue for the donor.
- ars 9y agoThere have been lawsuits about children born to deceased fathers and inheritance. So it's a real issue. For example: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/can-kids-inherit-sperm-donors-federal-benefits/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/can-kids-inherit-sperm-donors-f... https://cathompsonlaw.com/estate-planning-for-your-embryos-do-you-have-a-plan/ https://cathompsonlaw.com/estate-planning-for-your-embryos-d...
- mistersquid 9y agoPerhaps it would be possible (ethical?) to set up a system to provide organs from post-operative female-to-male transgender patients to potential recipients.
- khedoros1 9y agoDid you mean male-to-female patients (assuming that you're trying to provide penises)? My understanding is that most of the structure of the penis is used to craft various structures of the newly constructed female genitals (shaft for the vagina, glans for the clitoris, and so on).
- mistersquid 9y agoOh dear, I did mean male-to-female. <embarrassed face> Thank you, also, for clarifying that male-to-female gender reassignment surgery wouldn't result in an organ that could be donated.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rdl 9y agoI assume you mean “donor deceased”. Even if I were dead I would not necessarily want people using my DNA to father children. I wouldn’t necessarily be against it, either, but I would feel I had some interest in how sperm were used in a different way from other organs. I’d also feel differently about something physically identifying like a face, and even more so about the brain/cognition (if there were a way to do a partial brain transplant which carried memories or something but didn’t transfer consciousness — seems unlikely given what we know of the brain today, but I wouldn’t count it out since we don’t really know all that much.)
- DoreenMichele 9y ago(if there were a way to do a partial brain transplant which carried memories Years ago, I saw an interview with a woman on TV. IIRC, she was the first recipient of a heart and lung transplant. She was asked a question shortly after surgery in which her reply was something like "I'd love to have a beer!" though she did not drink. The young male donor who died in a motorcycle accident did drink. She also reported having dreams and other experiences in line with having somehow inherited some piece of his consciousness. Over time, they faded. If anyone is curious to read more, this might be her book: A Change of Heart: A Memoir by Claire Sylvia
- fjsolwmv 9y agoThat's sounds like an urban legend / exaggerated story.
- freedomben 9y agoI hope it is urban legend or exaggerated, because that is terrifying.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rrobukef 9y agoOr it's wishful thinking / placebo. The mind is very good at deceiving itself.
- sigstoat 9y agoassuming that even worked, i wouldn't expect a lot of living donors, and the timing of decease and birth should clear most everything else up.
- cat199 9y agoand yet uniqueness of DNA is 'irrelevant' in cases of new life.. 'medicine' will decide what it wants.
- maxerickson 9y agoI imagine divorces involving sperm and embryos would be a good source of material. And those are situations where there is a relationship instead of anonymous posthumous donation. I guess lots of people don't think it's weird to assert some right of control over their genetic material.
- killjoywashere 9y agoThe testes are immunoprivileged. Transplanting testes would probably result in dead nubs of fibrous tissue after a couple years or severe immunosuppression requirements. Even autologous testicular tissue transplant has had only a 1 in 7 success rate (https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn1851-man-fathers-child-after-testicular-transplant/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn1851-man-fathers-chil...)
- luddaite 9y agoAdditionally the testes derive their blood supply from the testicular arteries that branch off the aorta all the way up in the abdomen. I would imagine that 'hooking them up' would be a much more complicated surgery since the vessels would have to be passed through the pelvis into the scrotum.
- encoderer 9y agoOh man it’s like having to pass props all the way down through my react components. No wonder the surgeon closed as #wontfix.
- onion2k 9y agoJust need the context API for blood... Somehow.
- davidkuhta 9y agoGraftQL
- mifeng 9y agoNominated for comment of the year,
- killjoywashere 9y agoWell, there are plenty of big arteries in the pelvis the surgeon could anastamose with, and you can harvest the donor artery as far up as you want (it supplies nothing else), so I'm not sure the arterial supply is really the problem. Venous drainage could be a problem. The other thing: they may actually plan to do those transplants down the line, but there's no sense in doing them if the scrotum fails to take.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- philwelch 9y agoThey did transplant the scrotum. I wonder if they included some cosmetic testicles just to make the patient look more "fully equipped".
- serf 9y agopet owners have been doing that for years. [0] [0]: https://www.neuticles.com/ https://www.neuticles.com/
- johnp_ 9y agoWhy not just keep the testes? https://www.parsemus.org/projects/calcium-chloride/ https://www.parsemus.org/projects/calcium-chloride/ Two intratesticular or intraepididymal shots are far cheaper and so much less invasive than two surgeries.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoMy kneejerk reaction is that I imagine appearances are a low priority here compared to regaining basic functionality. I say that as someone who was quite vain about my looks when I was young, but chronic health problems have drastically changed my priorities. That's not intended as dismissive. I just kind of feel like it's a detail likely to be a low priority at this stage, what with it being groundbreaking surgery to begin with, etc. This article indicates he's also missing his lower legs: https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/04/23/605054470/veteran-receives-penis-transplant-to-repair-war-wound https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/04/23/6050544... No indication if they made the scrotum look like there are testes.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoIf they don't add cosmetic testicles, it's a constant reminder that testicles are missing, which causes psychological stress.
- bonesss 9y agoCosmetic testicles would be tremendously simple, too, compared to the operations complexity. Google tells me that "testicular prostheses have been used for 50 years to replace missing or removed testes"... I would speculate that they would be a relatively simple addition to the surgery itself, but at the very least it would be very simple to do as an additional operation once the transplant stabilized.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bayesian_horse 9y agoThe testes don't provide a useful or vital enough function for the recipient to warrant the additional risks and effort. Really, the only thing a male body normally needs its rocks is to produce some hormones. Those are easily substituted. Simple silicone implants will satisfy aesthetic properties. The tactile nerve endings aren't vital to recreative copulation.
- delecti 9y agoAs trans people, post-menopausal women, and diabetics can tell you, your body doesn't care where the hormones came from as long as it's the same substance.