9 ms·
Billionaire Khosla Is Asking the Supreme Court to Keep People Off His Beach
- webkike 9y agoHere are two quotes from Khosla on the notion of "fairness": > “This is about unfairness, and I don't tolerate unfairness.” > “I decide what's fair,” he says. “They can do it or not. I don't go back and forth six times.”
- Amygaz 9y agoYep. Another babyllionaire who wants it all, just for himself.
- DrScump 9y ago"State law says the public owns all coastline on the ocean side of the mean high tide line. Khosla says he shouldn't have to open up his private land without compensation to allow passage to the cove, which is buttressed by cliffs and impossible to reach otherwise except by water. " Bloomberg misses the whole point, which is that the road was an easement that had long existed before and into Khosla's ownership.
- eloff 9y agoHe knew what he was buying into then. It doesn't change the legality of what he's trying to do - and I don't see any legal basis for his claim. But it certainly makes me less sympathetic to his cause. If I lived nearby I might visit the beach just out of equal parts curiosity and protest.
- yaur 9y agoIf the easement predates his ownership of the property, hasn’t he already been “compensated” in the form of a lower price for the property?
- eloff 9y agoYes, exactly.
- rayiner 9y agoThe previous owners ran a business allowing people to access the beach. Its not at all clear that he knew what he was buying into.” Put differently, your point is at most a standing argument. Either the previous property owners suffered the taking, or Khosla did. But somebody did.
- gleenn 9y agoWhile I'd have some sympathy for mistakes in real estate, the guy's a billionaire. If he can't afford a good agent that would point out that obvious issue then I don't know how anyone else gets anything done in that industry. He should be talking to his agent and not the Supreme Court.
- couchand 9y agoFrom the Court of Appeal opinion: "Prior to appellants' purchase of the Martins Beach property, appellants were told by San Mateo County that '[t]here is existing parking [and] access to the beach at Martins Beach. This access [is] also memorialized [and] required to be preserved (no exceptions) by the Local Coastal Program' and 'the access is there & will have to remain.'"
- rayiner 9y agoThe government can’t just say you have to keep using your property in a certain way.
- couchand 9y agoNice job moving the goalposts there.
- rayiner 9y agoSorry I meant to elaborate the thought. The government can’t just tell you to keep using your property a certain way. So if you get a notice from the government claiming to exercise some power it probably doesn’t have, what exactly do you “know” you’re buying into? If the county sends you a letter saying that they want you to operate a public park out of your back yard. And then you sell your house to someone who has notice of that letter. What does that mean? That the government gets to order the new owner to operate their back yard as a public park?
- swampthing 9y ago... and that it's not his beach, unless you are only counting the part above the high tide line (which would be an uncommon definition of the word "beach").
- DrScump 9y agoI haven't heard that he's tried to limit beach access from the water's side (as certain Malibu types have tried); the legal battle is over access to the road.
- swampthing 9y agoI was referring to the title of the article.
- tehlike 9y agoSo he wont be annoyed if people constantly accessed from the water? Doesnt sound likely.
- DrScump 9y agoHe would lack even a veneer of acting lawfully in such a case. It would be fun if a group got together with boats and had a huge party every week or more at low tide, being right in his conceptual face regularly. Bonus points for immaculate cleanup after every time.
- tehlike 9y agoThat is what i was thinking pretty much. Maybe that is what needs to happen.
- paloaltokid 9y agoI used to drive that section of the coast all the time. I remember passing the Martin's Beach sign often and thinking it was kind of neat. Then one weekend, I drive by and it's a big black ugly box. I thought "that's strange..." and here we are almost 10 years later. It's really crappy what Khosla's done. That section of the coast is so beautiful, it's a real shame to see it get shut off from public access.
- rmason 9y agoSpent some time on Martins beach in the past and it's beautiful. It's like a hidden little nugget compared to its much more popular big brother Half Moon Bay. I was by there in early February and had planned to try and visit both, even if I had to jump the fence. But I was running late for a meetup later in the evening in SF and didn't make it. I respect Khosla but if there was ever reason for risking a ticket for civil disobedience by visiting a public beach this is the place.
- nugget 9y agoI believe the sheriff's department has publicly stated that they will not ticket or arrest anyone caught using the easement to access the beach, even if they have to hop the fence or take similar measures. This situation seems ripe for some persistent civil disobedience.
- jackfoxy 9y agoExcept that it's not civil disobedience. It is disrespecting someone who is being civilly disobedient. Disrespect and civil disobedience, one action is not always bad, the other not always good.
- lovich 9y agoThe guys literally bourgeoisie taking public land that was public before he purchased it. You don't get to buy a house and then block off your sidewalk because you don't think you should have to allow access to your land without compensation. This is blatant theft from society
- amarkov 9y agoDo you have a source for this? I hadn't seen the claim that there was any previous easement.
- sidlls 9y agoThe easement is at the very least implied by law. Consider the case where person A owns property that has no access except by crossing person B's property. There is an easement granting person A the right to cross B's property whether B agrees or not and whether or not it's recorded in the public records, etc. This is similar, although I suspect he'll try to argue alternative access exists or some other nonsense.
- killjoywashere 9y agoAs I recall, he has also argued that there was some sort of treaty that pre-dated the California Constitution. None of it makes sense, he's just decided this is a fight he wants to fight.
- rayiner 9y agoThat’s not what the cert petition is about. The government didn’t just force Khosla to allow people to use the easement: > To be clear, all agree that petitioner owns the property in fee simple absolute. But the Coastal Commission and the County nonetheless declared the power not only to mandate that the property be kept open to the public unless petitioner obtains a permit to close it, but to dictate essential aspects of how petitioner must invite the public onto its private property—including the hours it must allow access, the absurdly low price ($2) it may charge, and even the extent of advertising alerting the public of its ability to access petitioner’s private property for a pittance.
- rtpg 9y agoThere's a lot of court cases about how making something absurdly expensive is the same as not allowing something. The rules exist because otherwise people act in bad faith
- metei 9y agoPerhaps foreigners who flagarantly and repeatedly violate our laws should be prioritized for deportation. Why should some rich foriegner be allowed to break state and federal laws for years with no serious repercussions? Edit: If you disagree, please reply with an explanation!
- saagarjha 9y agoYour comment is xenophobic, and besides, Khosla is a US citizen, not a foreigner.
- metei 9y agoI'm not a fan of rich foreigners buying their way into citizenship, sure. But stealing from the public is illegal, no matter how good your lawyers are. Khosla is an immigrant who has applied for and been granted citizenship, but generally for less well to do immigrants, we hold them to high standards if they wish to retain citizenship (even though that results in us creating stateless people). Why is Khosla special?
- rayiner 9y agoIt’s a pretty decent cert petition: https://d3583ivmhhw2le.cloudfront.net/images/uploads/publications/Petition_for_Writ_of_Certiorari_-_Martins_Beach_v._Surfrider_Found-2clean.pdf https://d3583ivmhhw2le.cloudfront.net/images/uploads/publica.... He’s hired one of the leading Supreme Court advocates in the country, and there is some compelling “overstep of regulatory authority” optics to the case. Getting cert on any case is a slim chance, but this seems at least interesting enough to grab someone’s attention.
- wavefunction 9y agoYou've asserted that there are "compelling 'overstep of regulatory authority' [considerations] to the case" but failed to make any points to persuade a reader to that conclusion. There was an existing regulation upon the property, Khosla purchased it and now is subject to the regulation. Ignorance of the law is no defense, especially when one is as fortunate and well-equipped as Khosla is.
- ggm 9y agoThis. Buying your way out of public access easements, is bad law. Really, really bad precedent, to let the commons be bought.
- rayiner 9y agoThe commons is the part up to the mean high tide line. Maybe a path to get to the high tide line. But the parking lot, etc, that the state is forcing Khosla to keep open certainly isn’t the commons.
- couchand 9y agoFrom the Court of Appeal opinion: "In support of a different argument that the trial court's injunction forced them to operate a parking business at a net loss, appellants point to testimony from the manager of Martins Beach that improvements, including a new bathroom, would cost over $500,000, and annual costs would exceed $100,000. However, the injunction does not obligate appellants to provide staff or any amenities. Instead, it requires, 'The gate across Martins Beach Road must be unlocked and open to the same extent that it was unlocked and open at the time [appellants] purchased the property.'"
- davidw 9y agoWhat a NIMBY :-(
- everyone 9y agoThe article is incredibly pandering to Khosla. Does he own the publishers parent company or something?
- harryh 9y agoBloomberg.com is owned by Bloomberg L.P., the majority of which is owned by Michael Bloomberg who is one of the 10 richest people in America and the former mayor of NYC.
- git_rancher 9y agoI wonder how long until a critical mass of people get fed up with the resource hogging of the ultra rich. Seems likely to happen at some point if current trends in wealth inequality continue.
- aphextron 9y agoHighly doubtful while it's still the case that American Capitalism openly encourages and rewards predatory, sociopathic behavior. The existence of these people is inevitable.
- ixtli 9y agoAgreed. I just worry it'd be the wrong people.
- ajmurmann 9y agoAccording to "The Great Leveler" by Walter Scheidel inequality throughout human history has always been going up and only been reset by things like war, violent revolutions or major economic throwbacks. So I'm pessimistic that we can solve the issue in a more pleasant manner.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- _jal 9y agoI have that book in my pile. Skipped it last time I picked up the next one, due to not quite being in the right frame of mind for a depressing read. > So I'm pessimistic that we can solve the issue in a more pleasant manner. Oh, I'm quite sure we can't. The peaceful dissolution of the USSR has been a miracle, although that story isn't really over yet. The U.S., at least, will not have a pitchfork moment so anywhere near so quietly. The question of 'how bad does it have to get' is quite relevant to those of us who have enough money to be planning for retirement, but not enough for his'n'her's yachts - what are the odds that we should maybe start scoping retirement-nations with the best combinations of freedom, opportunity and tolerance for refugees from a place famously losing tolerance for refugees?
- atomical 9y agoWhat happens if you cross the no trespassing sign?
- tomcam 9y agoNothing. It has no legal basis.
- maxxxxx 9y agoIn Malibu there is a similar situation and I have seen private security guards harass people who walked to the beach. You have to have good nerves and be 100% sure of the legality to ignore them.
- mindslight 9y agoGiven the general ambiguity of the law, there really needs to be some penalty for those who knowingly push an incorrect interpretation as a spectre to intimidate/deprive others of their rights. Off the top of my head, it seems that it is at least fraud and an inappropriate giving of legal advice. But obviously an explicit statute to curb the practice would be better.
- spacemanmatt 9y agoWell, for starters, if they raise their voice or a limb at you, you can have them done for assault. If they actually detain you, it's false imprisonment aka kidnapping.
- mindslight 9y agoExcept, if it turns out that there is actually not an easement, then the same applies to you. Pretty high stakes for a question that likely can only be decided by all parties doing the research to become fully informed, presenting arguments to a court, and then waiting for deliberation. Due to the way the legal system works, much of this ambiguity is unavoidable, so the reasonable thing to do is to not escalate the situation physically. But then this creates an incentive for one party to act in bad faith and misinform the others, so that they can benefit in the meantime or even discourage the question from being investigated.
- AIX2ESXI 9y agoCool, an Indian billionaire is using to his wealth to privatize public lands. How they assimilate so quick!
- Steeeve 9y agoThe story from the other side: https://www.surfrider.org/coastal-blog/entry/martins-beach-to-go-to-us-supreme-court https://www.surfrider.org/coastal-blog/entry/martins-beach-t...
- jcoffland 9y agoHere's a highly relevant quotation from the above linked article. > There has been no permit or other final decision requiring Petitioners to charge visitors $2 or any amount for vehicle access, or to advertise any message on its property So Khosla's claims that he is being forced to charge $2 and operate a business are lies. Obviously he looked in to restricting access by charging an exorbitant fee but found that he could charge no more than $2 and only if he applied for a permit that would likely be denied.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- roflchoppa 9y agoWe should have a BBQ there.
- walrus01 9y agoI know this is in poor taste, but it's the best thing I could think of: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2ZBVk6gpFA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2ZBVk6gpFA
- johnrob 9y agoGiven how the state of California has ruled, is there any practical obligation for local authorities to prevent people from using the road? Would a federal ruling change that? This reminds me of the marijuana situation where states are making their own decisions without federal support.
- raz32dust 9y agoWell, if Khosla paid for the land the road is built on, I agree that the state should pay the fair price for the road. Seems straightforward and fair to me. Can someone help me understand why this is not that simple? And then we should have a law that prohibits private ownership of any land that is the sole connector between two public pieces of land. i.e, there should always be a pathway at least enough for 2 cars to pass through that connects 2 pieces of land. This should be verified every time a new land deal is registered. That should prevent such mishaps in future.
- metei 9y agoPublic access laws like what California and Washington State have require the property owner to allow access to the beach. This means a property owner has to provide a reasonable right of way to access shoreline on their property. Anything less is illegal, up here in Seattle people get hauled to court (or worse if they refuse to allow access repeatedly). Stealing a beach from the public domain is illegal, and Cali seems to have serious enforcement problems. No property owner has a right to steal public beaches
- raz32dust 9y agoBut then, the state should not have allowed the sale, right? What is the meaning of ownership if the land is not really yours?
- throwawayjava 9y ago> What is the meaning of ownership if the land is not really yours? You can't own the beach. And you can't de facto own the beach by buying all the land around it and then restricting access. These were both well-understood when Khosla bought the land. He knew exactly how California interpreted land rights in this particular case. Land purchases regularly come with both private (contractual) and public (statutory) limitations/restrictions on use. Landowners are not kings, and private properties are not sovereign borders. > But then, the state should not have allowed the sale, right? I guess that's one way the state could react to these sorts of lawsuits. That would be unfortunate, because it'd probably end up meaning that one asshole prevented a whole bunch of reasonable people from buying beachfront views with their hard-earned money.
- francisofascii 9y agoEven if there was no preexisting easement, people should be allowed to get from point A to point B. This type of property ownership entitlement happens all the time with hikers and such. It is flat out evil behavior.
- maxxxxx 9y agoHere in the West it's really hard to hike cross country. Big areas are fenced in without any way to get through. In Britain and Germany they usually have a path through but here it's just closed off. Really annoying and doesn't feel like the "land of the free".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- himom 9y agoThis jackass, again? I refuse to do business, recommend or patronize any such individual whom wastes their life and resources on such petty self-indulgences at the expense of commonwealth capital when they could be doing real good saving lives, species or making a positive dent on the universe, instead of walling themselves off from “the plebs” and making them have absolutely no legacy worth discussing further. Their friends should also distance themselves from such people or that obvious malevolence will rub off on their reputations as well.
- needToSay 9y agoPoo in the loo, koshla
- sunstone 9y agoIf he really wants his own beach why didn't he buy an island? Growing up in privilege in India I guess it just comes naturally to him to shut out the poor people.