2 ms·
Much of this is predicted by classical economics. When you have an asset with minimal elasticity in supply (such as housing in areas where building more is dif
by nostrademons 9y ago
Much of this is predicted by classical economics.
When you have an asset with minimal elasticity in supply (such as housing in areas where building more is difficult) that is nevertheless needed for survival, owners of that asset will be able to capture most of the productive capacity of the people who need that asset. In areas with high productivity and high incomes - like around rich coastal cities - that's manifested by skyrocketing housing prices. In areas with lower productivity and lower incomes, prices still go up, but not as much, and the effect is felt as an inability to get ahead or even make ends meet even when you work hard. The wealth generated by younger laborers is transferred to older asset-owners who own the necessities of life, simply because they continue to own them.
Similarly, classical economics predicts a substitution effect for these goods: as they become increasingly less affordable, buyers will try to bypass the market entirely.
That's behind nearly all the social changes and huge tech businesses of the last two decades. Can't find a place to live? Rent in a tiny apartment instead of buying a house.
Live out of a van. Move to cheaper locales while working remotely. Can't get a job because that's yet another scarce resource monopolized by an older generation? Drive people around in your car with Uber. Sublet your rental on AirBnB. Blog for advertising revenue. Sell your crafts on Etsy. Start a new service business and advertise on Facebook or Google. Take funding from YCombinator and try to start the next great marketplace.
The last couple years have brought even more radical examples, eg. Bitcoin is basically an attempt to setup a shadow financial & monetary system and opt out of the dollar-denominated economy entirely.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fbonetti 9y agoThis isn’t predicted by classical economics. This is the result of the housing supply being artificially constrained by zoning laws. If developers could build a 40-story high rise next to a single family home, housing would be dirt cheap. On top of this, rent control further disincentives developers from constructing new properties. AirBnB and Uber aren’t “bypassing the market”, they’re bypassing local laws and ordinances. The reason why AirBnB is cheaper than hotels and Uber is cheaper than taxis is because they don’t incur the cost of regulatory compliance. Real estate would also be cheaper if developers didn’t have to comply with zoning regulations.
- nostrademons 9y agoStill predicted by classical economics. Zoning laws change the elasticity of supply. Housing in a completely free market should have relatively high elasticity; if the price is too high, build more! Zoning laws artificially constrain the supply and so create a monopoly/oligopoly situation, which is what allows owners to charge economic rents beyond the marginal cost of producing more housing. Similarly, the local sublet/taxi regulations that AirBnB/Uber bypass artificially constrain supply, allowing owners of properties or taxi medallions to charge economic rents. Bypass them and you get a competitive market, where owners of houses & cars can charge only the marginal cost of use (and instead, AirBnB and Uber get to charge monopoly rents).
- fbonetti 9y agoI think we’re saying the same thing. Your original comment made it sound like high real estate prices is just a fact of life.
- dnomad 9y agoYeah, this is not predicted by classical economics. Westerners really need to look at other countries. You do not see these sorts of extreme housing shortages in Asia. You don't see it in Tokyo, Bangkok, Shanghai, or Seoul. I have trouble even explaining what's happening in places like San Francisco or London or Paris to my Asian partners. That's because Asian cities aren't afraid to grow. Tokyo, Bangkok -- these cities have grown enormously and continue to do so [1]. Ultimately, the West has collectively decided to tombstone their cities. There is enormous demand to live in the West's metro centers and yet, at virtually all levels, powerful forces work to ensure that these cities do not expand to satisfy this demand. This decision not to grow is very much a political decision. The end result here probably won't be good. A great deal of economic growth is being left on table. Cities are the primary engines of economic growth and when they aren't allowed to grow the result is less growth and opportunity. Political instability ticks up; a great deal of many people stuck languishing in less dynamic areas because they can't afford to move to the dynamic cities end up feeling like they're stuck and now want to tear the whole system down. Democracy itself breaks down as the urban-rural divide becomes more and more severe. But hey, in the short term, those who bought early get rich. [1] https://jamesjgleeson.wordpress.com/2018/02/19/how-tokyo-built-its-way-to-abundant-housing/ https://jamesjgleeson.wordpress.com/2018/02/19/how-tokyo-bui...
- nostrademons 9y agoSee reply to sibling comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16908733 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16908733 Monopoly is well-treated in classical economics, and this is an instance of zoning regulations enforcing an artificial monopoly. And the results are exactly as predicted in a microeconomics textbook: owners of the monopoly asset capture nearly all economic surplus from trade in it.
- nerfhammer 9y agoeconomics posits that individuals are rational actors, not that societies always make good collective decisions, and further economics describes many conditions under which collective decision-making can end up disastrous for all involved despite or because of each individual acting in their best interest along the way.