4 ms·
Because they're making fun of a comic, not out of a personal tragedy: it was a gag-a-day comic strip about video games with limited plot, and giving the charact
by geofft 9y ago
Because they're making fun of a comic, not out of a personal tragedy: it was a gag-a-day comic strip about video games with limited plot, and giving the characters a deeply personal tragedy was extremely out of character for the comic strip.
Plenty of people make fun of webcomics that developed a serious plot and actual characterization over time (MegaTokyo and Questionable Content both come to mind). This one went from 0-100 in one strip.
- fwip 9y agoAnd after that one strip, it dropped back down to 0 pretty quickly. It seemed to a lot of people that Tim Buckley realized "oh hey I don't want to have a baby in the strip" and decided to get a cheap emotional punchline while he was writing himself out of that self-inflicted hole. But when your comic has less depth than your average Garfield comic, it doesn't work out so great.
- sneak 9y agoCalling QC “serious characterization” is a huge stretch. JJ appears to basically only know how to write characters that have the same crippling anxiety that he does. It’s maddening to read.
- geofft 9y agoI'm not commenting on whether it's good characterization (although I do non-ironically enjoy reading QC personally), just that it's a marked departure from the esrly days of the strip when there was no attempt at giving the characters any more characterization than requires for the short-term jokes. Regardless of how good he is at it, the author is certainly being consistent about writing a long-term plot that is isn't just a bunch of gags and about giving the characters meaningful backstories and personalities beyond "likes indie rock."