4 ms·
Cool. I hadn't thought of risk calculation as a Bernoulli process. Hey, I know next to nothing about risk calculations! However. If we work backwards in time a
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
Cool. I hadn't thought of risk calculation as a Bernoulli process. Hey, I
know next to nothing about risk calculations!
However. If we work backwards in time and keep to the same reasoning, the
yearly probability of a violent revolution goes up for every year you get
closer to the last event (because there are fewer years to sample from). For
example, the chance to have a violent revolution in 1866, after the US Civil
War, was at its maximum for the period after the Civil War (0.57 by my
calculation). That is intuitively wrong. Surely, the probability to have a
violent revolution must be minimal right after the end of the last one, when
the new status quo is in its most well established, everyone is tired of
fighting, etc etc.
I guess you can argue for and against that- but the point is that revolutions
cannot be accurately modelled as a Bernoulli process, with a constant
probability depending on time, else there is a risk of wildly over- or
under-estimating the chance of having another one.
Finally- I think it's very dangerous to assume that just because you can model
someone's reasoning as a rational process, that person will actually follow
that process and reason rationally. Or in other words- someone else might be
able to come up with rational arguments to back up preppers' actions, but that
doesn't mean preppers themselves are thinking rationally. You can get to the
same behaviour through very different lines of reasoning, not all of which are
necessarily consistent.
- cc439 9y ago>That is intuitively wrong. Surely, the probability to have a violent revolution must be minimal right after the end of the last one, when the new status quo is in its most well established, everyone is tired of fighting, etc etc. Is that intuitively wrong? How many civil wars and revolutions have we seen spiral into madness after the official end to hostilities between the "governments" involved? Iraq, Libya, and South Sudan are among dozens of examples we can pull from recent memory. The defeat of a government or other high level of societal organization does not imply the defeat of the reasons why the war began in the first place. The rise of the Jim Crow laws and the incessant waves of black emigration fron the South after the collapse of the Union state's Reconstruction efforts speaks to the inherent instability of post-war societies. There are more historical examples of "post-conflict" societies which almost immediately descend into further conflict than one can count. Once the seal of peace is broken, it's incredibly hard to recreate.