7 ms·
This doesn't sound like it itself "exploits" anything, just deflates Nintendo's attempted scheme to exploit their customers by booby trapping their hardware. I
by mindslight 9y ago
This doesn't sound like it itself "exploits" anything, just deflates Nintendo's attempted scheme to exploit their customers by booby trapping their hardware.
If you rigged your car to destruct 30 minutes after it went out of cell service, sold it to an unsuspecting buyer, and then laughed when they got stuck in the desert, you'd be rightfully thrown in jail. But yet these companies keep attempting to pull the same shit with impunity.
- BoorishBears 9y agoWell it’s your choice, open hardware or billions of dollars invested in an industry employing millions of people...
- yarrel 9y agoFalse dichotomy.
- BoorishBears 9y agoNot everything has to be a fallacy, I remember when people understood the concept of tongue-in-cheek. DRM (10NES) was a core part of the strategy for the console that brought a recovery from the 1983 video game crash. And even today publishers value a platform that is able to combat privacy (see: Denuovo and the lengths AAA productions go to delay piracy in PC.
- reality_czech 9y agoYes, publishers do certainly value a platform that is able to combat privacy. Although lately the combat has been a little one-sided.
- boomboomsubban 9y ago>DRM (10NES) was a core part of the strategy for the console that brought a recovery from the 1983 video game crash. About 1/3rd of the consoles sold didn't contain the DRM, yet the Japanese market still saw similar growth. Publishers value Denuovo, is there any proof that it helps sales?
- BoorishBears 9y ago1/3rd of the units sold? Or 1/3rd of the types of consoles? I know several consoles of the era also had DRM, so I’d be curious which ones youre referring to and the time period if referring to 1/3rd sold. And if Denuovo actually helps sales is not an easy question to answer since no publisher has come out and said it (that I’ve seen). The premise seems sound enough, sales follow an “inverse hockey stick”, so design DRM meant to delay cracking instead of stop it and you can get more time with maximum interest and sales, with no easy piracy options. A few times it’s fallen in hours, and pirates started to write it off, but just recently Far Cry 5's implementation lasted weeks, which seems to be what they’re going for (some versions even lasted months on end). One could argue no pirates would buy instead of wait, and one could argue all pirates would buy instead of wait, but both would be wrong and the truth is somewhere in the middle, publishers have evaluated that question and apparently the answer is something they like enough to keep shaving margins for
- baud147258 9y agoIf I remember right, DOOM and the latest Tomb Raider used Denuvo and they weren't cracked until a few weeks after release, but they did not report sales above the norm.
- BoorishBears 9y agoAre those digital sales? Usually I see numbers quoted as tracking physical sales, which don’t tell the whole story. And I still feel only publishers would be able to tell what the “norm” is. They have better insight into what their “norm” is in terms of returns for development and marketing based on game type, release date, and tons of other factors that can’t be correlated casually
- boomboomsubban 9y agoSorry for the late reply >1/3rd of the units sold? Or 1/3rd of the types of consoles? I know several consoles of the era also had DRM, so I’d be curious which ones youre referring to and the time period if referring to 1/3rd sold. The Famicom did not have the DRM, and accounts for about a third of the total Nintendo sales. That market did not suffer because of the presence of piracy. As for Denuovo, why would publishers hide data showing it works? And the base capitalism answer doesn't work,continuing to use aggressive DRM gives them information and a power over users that may not directly show a profit. The rest of your arguments ignore the sales piracy brings because more people talking about it, an effective advertising, and the people who use piracy as a true demo.
- loup-vaillant 9y agoHow about an open hardware industry that would employ millions of people? Not to mention the questionable premise that we should have enough work to employ almost everyone. I mean, we're mostly programmers in here. Our primary task is to destroy jobs. Shouldn't free time be a good thing?
- BoorishBears 9y agoPeople seem to not understand this was a tongue in cheek reference to the NES and the recovery from the 1983 crash... That being said, I don’t have major qualms about closed hardware. It creates the incentives that have allowed for massive investment in what is now cutting edge technology, and over time it is trickling down to more open hardware. The number of proprietary technologies in a modern high-end GPU is staggering. Maybe one could say in an alternate timeline open hardware could have beaten companies creating GPUs with proprietary IPs, but it didn’t really happen. So I’ll take 1080tis with binary blobs over the open alternative.
- mikeash 9y agoIt’s half and half. This scheme defeats Nintendo’s attempt to control what console owners do with their own hardware, it’s true. But it also allows console owners to be exploited by malicious hardware (say, a cheap charger).
- tinus_hn 9y agoHomebrew is cool but 99% of the real world usage is pirated games.
- white-flame 9y agoI actually kind of liked the Gameboy approach. You needed to include a byte-for-byte image of the trademarked Nintendo logo in order for the boot ROM to run your cartridge. So there were no technical hurdles to running your code in it, but it just made it legally dangerous to distribute.
- fragmede 9y agoSega tried this with the Dreamcast, and further, tried to enforce it in court. They lost.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- qbrass 9y agoGenesis. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade
- Someone1234 9y agoIndeed but since then the DMCA[0] has radically shifted to the law. Sega would win today. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_A...
- Pharaoh2 9y agoIANAL, but the two things seem related, why is GP being down voted? From just a reading of the wiki pages without much law knowledge it does seem like sega would win today? What I am getting wrong?
- monocasa 9y agoI don't think they would assuming that they wrote their own game and were only using of Sony's what was necessary to run their own code. See Chamberlain v. Skylink for a post DMCA case on the matter. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chamberlain_Group,_Inc._v._Skylink_Technologies,_Inc https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chamberlain_Group,_Inc._v._S....
- crankylinuxuser 9y agoSounds kind of like a Tesla, now that you mention a car like that. They already will call and threaten you if you own a Tesla and mess around with it under the hood. https://www.slashgear.com/expect-an-irate-call-if-you-try-to-hack-your-tesla-model-s-06323921/ https://www.slashgear.com/expect-an-irate-call-if-you-try-to... How much further will they go? Will they remotely disable it? Or perhaps, they'll send it into "Service Needed" mode and cripple it?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hvidgaard 9y agoIt ought to be the law that anything I can do, is fair game. If I fuckup something it shouldn't be under warranty, but only for the issues the tinkering causes. If I can connect to a port in the car I've paid for, and read something, it's not industrial espionage. That is just Tesla being lazy and trying to get security-by-obscurity, instead of a proper secure implementation.
- freerobby 9y agoThat article is clickbait. Tesla contacted the owner out of fear that his car had been hacked (i.e. by someone else). That the owner stop was merely a "recommendation," warranty invalidation was the only threat they made, and "industrial espionage" was the owner's characterization of Tesla's concern, not an allegation it made against the owner. Lots of people have gone on to hack their Teslas without consequence in the years that followed. There was another episode where Jason Hughes was denied firmware updates after rooting his car. Elon responded that no punitive action was intended and that he views white hat hacking as a gift, and they seemed to resolve it pretty quickly. It will be interesting to see how Tesla responds to these cases when FSD is available. edit: Here's the original post: https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/successful-connection-on-the-model-s-internal-ethernet-network.28185/page-6#post-610152 https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/successful-connectio... > This evening I got a call from service center :crying: They told me Tesla USA engineers seen a tentative of hacking on my car... I explained it was me because I tried to connect the diagnosis port to get some useful data (speed, power, etc...). They told me it can be related to industrial espionage and advised me to stop investigation, to not void the warranty.... Don't know if they really seen something in the log, because I just sniffed the network. Or maybe they seen the port scanning with nmap ? Or maybe they just read this topic ? :eek: