2 ms·
> Why not just give the people who need things the things they need? We already have this. It turns out that you wind up with lots of overlapping bureaucracie
by bsder 9y ago
> Why not just give the people who need things the things they need?
We already have this. It turns out that you wind up with lots of overlapping bureaucracies that waste far more of the money than any fraudulent usages that you actually catch.
It's like drug testing people on assistance, it turns out that poor people use drugs less than the population at large. Funny that.
> Is this really an economic problem or a cultural one?
Yes to both.
The cultural problem, at least in the US, is that the politics of the Southern Strategy (ie. racial politics in the South) have made this into "How dare those undeserving so-and-sos get free money?" instead of "How many genuinely needy people did we help with the limited resources we have and can we help more?"
One other thing that a basic income affects is that you may find people willing to relocate to very low cost of living area with high unemployment since they know that they can survive even if they don't have a job. That can kickstart bringing the unemployment rate down because you wind up with a critical mass of people and those people need services.
There are lots of good possibilities. I'm hoping more experiments like this get tried out as some form of UBI is going to be required in the very near future when automation has replaced most manual labor jobs.