4 ms·
I think you're confusing concepts. The original point is about the difference between the map and the territory. And, because I'm (finally) systematically going
by scott_s 16y ago
I think you're confusing concepts. The original point is about the difference between the map and the territory. And, because I'm (finally) systematically going through Eliezer's sequences: http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Map_and_Territory_(sequence) http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Map_and_Territory_(sequence)
Your second paragraph is about a particular map: quantum theory. Quantum theory has probabilities in it. The dominant interpretation of quantum theory is that the probabilities accurately represent what happens in the universe; they are not artifacts for us to correct. But there is still a difference between our map (quantum theory) and the territory (the universe itself).
Put another way: quantum theory is a map with uncertainty baked into it. But this uncertainty has been accurately mapped.
- tome 16y agoNo I don't think so. Unlike statistical physics, where probabilities are simply a mathematical technique for dealing with uncertainty, quantum mechanics actually postulates that randomness is inherent to the universe. If you disagree with me, please describe how your concept of "maps and territories" applies to the StatPhys/QM distinction.
- scott_s 16y agoSuppose I accurately map the coastline, and every relevant part of the coastline is depicted in my map. But the map is not the same as the coastline itself. If my coastline has some feature that blips in and out of existence in a predictable way, I can integrate that into my map. My map then has uncertainty in it. That uncertainty is an accurate reflection of the coastline itself - but there is still a distinction between the map and the coastline. I don't disagree with your second sentence. But there is still a difference between our theory of quantum mechanics and the universe itself.